Russia's IP Court has clarified how trademark proceedings run against individual debtors. Key implications for foreign trademark owners. Make an enquiry.
Russia's IP Court has issued clarificatory guidance — confirmed through a series of decisions in 2025 — on how trademark proceedings are to be conducted when the respondent is an individual rather than a corporate entity. For foreign trademark owners managing Russian IP portfolios, the development resolves a procedural ambiguity that has generated inconsistent outcomes at first instance: specifically, whether the IP Court has jurisdiction over trademark claims brought against individuals who are not registered as individual entrepreneurs under Russian law. The answer is now more clearly defined, but the practical implications for in-house counsel require careful assessment.
Until recently, the treatment of individual debtors — that is, natural persons who are not registered as individual entrepreneurs (IEs) — as respondents in trademark disputes before Russia's IP Court was a source of persistent uncertainty. The IP Court sits as a specialised commercial court within the Russian arbitrazh court system. Its subject-matter jurisdiction covers intellectual property disputes of a commercial character. Where a respondent lacked IE status, first-instance arbitrazh courts and the IP Court itself applied divergent approaches: some panels accepted jurisdiction on the basis that the underlying infringement had a commercial character; others declined and referred claimants to courts of general jurisdiction.
The clarificatory position that has emerged from IP Court decisions through 2025 draws a cleaner line. Where an individual is alleged to have infringed a trademark in the course of commercial or entrepreneurial activity — even where that individual is not formally registered as an IE — the IP Court may accept jurisdiction if the nature of the activity is commercial in substance. The test is functional rather than purely formal. Evidence of systematic conduct, commercial scale, or business-related use of the infringing mark will be material to establishing jurisdiction at the threshold stage.
This shift has direct consequences for how foreign trademark owners structure claims against individual infringers operating through informal or unlicensed channels. Proceedings that would previously have required re-routing to courts of general jurisdiction — with different procedural rules, longer timelines, and reduced specialist expertise — may now proceed before the IP Court, provided the commercial character of the infringement is adequately documented at the outset.
For in-house counsel responsible for Russian IP portfolios, this development also interacts with the enforcement landscape for EAEU trademarks: individual operators who distribute goods across EAEU member states without authorisation may now be reachable via IP Court proceedings even where their formal legal status would previously have excluded the forum. The jurisdictional threshold, rather than disappearing, has been recalibrated around substance over form.
"
If your Russian IP portfolio includes unresolved claims against individual infringers — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
"
The practical effect of the IP Court's clarified position varies materially by the type of foreign trademark owner and the nature of their Russian commercial presence.
For multinational consumer brands, the most immediate exposure involves grey-market and counterfeit distributors operating as natural persons through online marketplaces. These individuals frequently resist formal registration precisely to avoid the arbitrazh court's jurisdiction over them. The IP Court's functional test now provides a route to specialist proceedings that was less reliably available before.
For foreign technology companies whose trademark infringement cases involve software resellers or unlicensed service providers operating as individuals, the clarification addresses a structural gap. Claims in this category can now be maintained before a tribunal with genuine specialist expertise in IP matters, rather than before a court of general jurisdiction where trademark doctrine may receive less consistent treatment.
Foreign pharmaceutical and life sciences companies face a different configuration. Where an individual debtor is linked to the unlicensed manufacture or distribution of products bearing a registered mark, the commercial character of the activity is ordinarily straightforward to establish. The more significant practical question for this sector is documentation: ensuring that evidence of the commercial nature of the infringement is preserved and organised before the claim is filed.
Foreign trademark owners with Russian licensing arrangements should also note the interaction between this development and contractual enforcement. Where a licensed individual distributor has fallen into arrears or has exceeded the scope of the licence, the IP Court's expanded effective jurisdiction creates an additional route to relief alongside contractual claims. The two proceedings are not mutually exclusive.
"Russia's IP Court has moved from a formalistic status-based test to a substance-based assessment of commercial activity — a shift that materially improves the enforcement toolkit for foreign trademark owners facing infringement by individuals operating outside the registered IE framework." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners
The loss aversion framing is worth stating plainly here: foreign trademark owners who have historically deferred enforcement against individual infringers on the assumption that IP Court proceedings were unavailable may be holding a weaker position on the register than the clarified jurisdictional rules now require them to reassess. Delay in initiating proceedings does not stop the accumulation of third-party use evidence that a subsequent cancellation claimant may deploy.
Three actions warrant immediate attention for in-house counsel managing Russian trademark portfolios.
First, review pending or deferred claims against individual infringers. Cases that were assessed as requiring referral to courts of general jurisdiction should be re-evaluated against the IP Court's clarified functional test. If the underlying infringement is commercial in character, IP Court proceedings may now be available and should be considered on their merits.
Second, audit documentation of infringement conduct. The functional test requires evidence of commercial activity at the threshold stage. Internal records of infringement — purchasing records, marketplace listing screenshots, correspondence with the infringing individual, evidence of scale and systematicity — should be collated before proceedings are commenced. Incomplete documentation at the outset is one of the most consistent sources of delay in IP Court proceedings.
Third, assess Rospatent filing status and registration health. IP Court proceedings against individual infringers will be more effectively maintained where the claimant's trademark registrations are current, unchallenged, and cover the relevant classes. A registration audit through qualified Russian IP counsel is a sound preliminary step. Where registrations have lapsed or are subject to non-use risk, that vulnerability will be tested in any contested proceedings.
For foreign counsel coordinating on behalf of clients with Russian IP assets, the Vetrov & Partners IP enforcement practice offers direct partner-level involvement and English-language case management from initial strategy through IP Court proceedings.
To discuss strategy for IP Court proceedings against individual infringers in Russia — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Two areas of interpretive uncertainty remain open following the 2025 decisions.
The first concerns the precise evidentiary threshold for establishing commercial character. The IP Court has articulated the substance-over-form principle, but decisions from different panels suggest that the quantum of evidence required — in terms of the number of documented transactions, the volume of goods, and the period of activity — has not been uniformly applied. Until appellate guidance standardises this threshold, claimants should err on the side of comprehensive documentation.
The second concerns the interaction between IP Court proceedings against individuals and insolvency proceedings where the same individual is subject to personal bankruptcy under Russian insolvency legislation. Where an individual is both an IP infringer and a debtor in personal insolvency, the procedural relationship between the two sets of proceedings — and the priority of any IP-related monetary claim in the insolvency estate — remains incompletely settled. Counsel advising on enforcement against individual debtors in this configuration should coordinate IP enforcement strategy with insolvency analysis from the outset. For the insolvency dimension, the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice works in parallel with IP enforcement matters where individual debtor status is relevant.
Q: What specifically changed in how Russia's IP Court handles trademark proceedings against individual respondents?
A: The IP Court has moved from a formalistic test — based on whether the respondent holds registered individual entrepreneur status — to a functional test based on whether the underlying activity is commercial in character. An individual who infringes a trademark through systematic commercial conduct may now be sued in the IP Court even without IE registration, provided the claimant demonstrates the commercial nature of the activity at the outset of proceedings. First-instance decisions that previously diverted such claims to courts of general jurisdiction were inconsistent; the clarificatory decisions from 2025 establish a cleaner, more predictable approach.
Q: Which foreign trademark owners are most directly affected by this change, and why does it matter for their Russian IP strategy?
A: Foreign trademark owners whose infringers include individual operators — marketplace sellers, informal distributors, unlicensed service providers — are most directly affected. Previously, the lack of a clear IP Court route against non-IE individuals meant that specialist trademark proceedings were sometimes unavailable or uncertain at the threshold stage. The practical significance is forum quality: the IP Court offers specialist expertise, more consistent trademark doctrine, and a procedural framework suited to complex IP claims, compared with courts of general jurisdiction. For multinationals managing Russian portfolios, the change expands the effective enforcement toolkit and should prompt a review of deferred claims.
Q: What should foreign companies do now in light of this development?
A: Three steps are advisable. First, review any pending or deferred claims against individual infringers to assess whether IP Court proceedings are now available on the clarified test. Second, audit and organise documentation of the infringing activity to ensure the commercial character threshold can be met at the pleadings stage. Third, verify the currency and scope of Rospatent registrations in the relevant classes, since contested IP Court proceedings will invariably test registration health. For portfolio-level strategy or specific enforcement matters, making an early enquiry allows counsel to assess the strength of available claims before the evidentiary position deteriorates.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry