Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Russian court practice on patent enforcement before Russian courts under Article 1515 of the Civil Code (compensation): 2027 update

Elizaveta Razina · October 2026 · 9 min read

Russian courts tightened their approach to patent compensation under Article 1515 in 2027. What in-house counsel needs to know now. Make an enquiry.

Foreign patent holders enforcing rights in Russia have long faced a procedural environment that rewards early preparation and penalises reactive strategy. Since the middle of 2026, Russian courts — led by the IP Court (Суд по интеллектуальным правам) — have developed a more structured and, in several respects, more demanding approach to compensation claims brought under the civil code's IP enforcement provisions. For in-house counsel managing Russian patent portfolios, the direction of travel is clear: quantification methodology, evidentiary standards, and the interplay between administrative and judicial routes are all under active judicial development in 2027.

§ I. What has changed — the before and after

Before: until mid-2026, Russian courts exercised broad discretion in awarding compensation under the civil code's IP compensation mechanism. Claimants could assert a statutory compensation figure — within the range permitted by the relevant provision — and courts would fix an amount reflecting general principles of proportionality, without requiring the claimant to produce detailed financial evidence of actual loss or infringer profit. The IP Court's supervisory role was principally concerned with legal classification questions: whether the patent was valid, whether the defendant's act fell within the protected scope, and whether the claimant had standing. Quantum was treated as a secondary matter, settled by reference to broad equitable considerations.

After: from the second half of 2026 into 2027, a series of cassation-level decisions from the IP Court and confirmatory rulings from the Supreme Court's commercial chamber have shifted the approach in three material ways.

First, courts now expect claimants to engage substantively with quantification even when asserting statutory compensation rather than actual damages. The assumption that any figure within the statutory range is presumptively reasonable has been replaced by a requirement that the claimant explain, at minimum, the basis for the figure selected — referencing, for example, market comparables, royalty benchmarks, or the scale of the infringing activity. Courts that find this explanation absent have reduced awards to the lower end of the permitted range.

Second, the burden on defendants to contest compensation figures has simultaneously increased. A defendant who simply disputes the claimant's figure without producing countervailing evidence — cost data, actual sales volumes, or evidence that the infringing product was withdrawn promptly — faces a weaker position than before 2026. Courts have signalled that passive defence on quantum will be treated as insufficient.

Third, administrative enforcement routes — specifically, filings with Rospatent and complaint mechanisms under the competition rules — are increasingly being treated by courts as prerequisites that affect the procedural posture of a subsequent civil claim. Claimants who have pursued administrative channels, or who can explain why they did not, are receiving more favourable procedural treatment at the first-instance stage.

A note on the applicable provision: this article addresses compensation claims under the civil code's IP compensation mechanism, frequently referenced in the context of Article 1515 and its structural analogues across different IP categories. Article 1515 in its primary application addresses trademark compensation; the patent-specific compensation framework operates through related provisions of Part IV of the Civil Code. In practice, however, the IP Court applies a consistent methodological approach across these provisions, and the developments described here reflect that consolidated practice. In-house counsel should treat the evidentiary and quantification standards now applied to trademark claims as directly indicative of what courts will require in patent compensation proceedings.

For in-house counsel reviewing the impact of these developments on pending or prospective patent claims in Russia, early procedural preparation is material to the likely quantum outcome — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Who is affected — and why it matters for foreign patent holders?

The changes affect foreign patent holders in several distinct ways, depending on the stage of enforcement and the commercial context.

Rights holders with active or contemplated civil claims. For any foreign company that has already filed, or is preparing to file, a compensation claim before a Russian arbitrazh court or the IP Court, the new evidentiary expectations apply immediately. Claims prepared under the pre-2026 approach — with a figure asserted and minimal supporting analysis — are at risk of receiving reduced awards. The practical consequence is that matters currently in preparation need to be reviewed against the updated quantification standard before filing.

Rights holders relying on parallel import and customs enforcement. Russia's parallel import regime, which was significantly liberalised from 2022, continues to generate friction between trademark and patent protection. Foreign companies whose patent enforcement strategy has depended on customs detention and administrative action — rather than civil compensation claims — should note that courts are now drawing a clearer line between administrative outcomes and the quantum available in subsequent civil proceedings. An administrative finding of infringement does not translate automatically into a substantial compensation award; the civil claim still requires independent quantification support.

Rights holders operating in EAEU-linked supply chains. Russia's membership of the Eurasian Economic Union introduces a regional dimension to patent enforcement that is directly relevant to compensation claims. Where infringing goods have moved across EAEU borders before reaching Russia, courts have shown a degree of caution about attributing the full commercial impact of the infringement to the Russian leg of the supply chain. Rights holders in this position — which includes most foreign manufacturers with distribution networks extending into Central Asia or the Caucasus — need to address this attribution question explicitly in their compensation arguments.

Rights holders who have not yet localised their evidentiary file. A recurrent difficulty for foreign patent holders is that the commercial data most useful for establishing a compensation benchmark — royalty rate references, licence agreement comparables, market share data — exists in a format and language that requires adaptation for Russian proceedings. Courts do not accommodate late-stage evidentiary supplementation generously. For companies with Russian patent portfolios that have not yet prepared this material in a form suitable for court submission, the current moment — before any infringement event triggers a live claim — is the appropriate time to do so.

Companies that have no current enforcement matter in Russia but maintain registered patents are not immediately required to take action. However, the evidentiary standard shift has a prospective effect: if infringement occurs, the ability to mount a well-quantified compensation claim will depend on preparation that needs to begin before the infringing act is detected, not after.

§ III. What foreign companies should do now

The practical response to these developments falls into three categories.

Audit the evidentiary position for existing and near-term claims. For any pending matter before Russian courts, counsel and in-house teams should verify whether the compensation figure in the claim is supported by the kind of analysis that courts now expect. If it is not, and if the procedural rules of the relevant proceeding permit amendment, supplementation should be considered before the evidentiary hearing. Where amendment is no longer available, managing the court's expectations through written submissions addressing quantification methodology is the minimum response.

Build the benchmark file for the Russian portfolio. Foreign patent holders with registered rights in Russia should maintain, as a standing document, a file that could support a compensation argument in the event of infringement. This file should address: the royalty rate at which the right has been licensed elsewhere (or the basis on which a hypothetical royalty would be constructed); the documented commercial value of the patent in the Russian market; and the typical scale of infringing activity in the relevant product category. This is not a submission-ready document — it is the underlying factual foundation from which a submission could be built on short notice.

Review the administrative / civil sequencing for planned enforcement. For companies that are aware of potential infringement and are deciding whether to proceed administratively, through customs, or directly through civil proceedings, the current court practice on the relationship between administrative outcomes and civil quantum is a relevant input. In some circumstances, establishing an administrative record before commencing civil proceedings improves the procedural posture of the civil claim. In others, it does not — and proceeding directly through the IP Court may be more efficient. This sequencing question requires analysis of the specific facts and the enforcement objective.

If your company holds Russian patents and has not reviewed its enforcement posture against the updated compensation practice, an initial conversation with our IP team is the practical starting point — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in how Russian courts handle patent compensation claims in 2026–2027?

A: Courts moved away from treating any figure within the statutory compensation range as automatically reasonable. From mid-2026, cassation-level decisions established that a claimant asserting statutory compensation must provide a substantive explanation of the basis for the figure selected — referencing comparable royalty rates, the scale of the infringer's commercial activity, or other relevant benchmarks. Courts that find this explanation absent have applied awards at the lower end of the permitted range. At the same time, defendants who contest the compensation figure without producing countervailing evidence now face a weaker position than under the previous approach. The combined effect is that compensation proceedings require more active engagement from both parties on the quantification question.

Q: Which foreign companies are most affected by the 2027 update to Russian patent compensation practice?

A: The update is most immediately relevant to foreign companies with active or near-term civil compensation claims before Russian courts, and to rights holders operating in EAEU-linked supply chains where goods may have transited multiple jurisdictions before reaching Russia. Companies in the first category need to review their existing claims against the new evidentiary standard before the next hearing stage. Companies in the second category face an additional attribution issue: courts have shown caution about applying the full commercial impact of an infringement to the Russian leg of a cross-border supply chain, and compensation arguments need to address this directly. Foreign patent holders with no current enforcement matter but active Russian registrations are not required to act immediately, but should use the current period to build the evidentiary foundation that any future claim will require.

Q: What should in-house counsel do in response to this development?

A: Three steps are practical for most in-house teams. First, for any pending Russian patent compensation claim, verify that the compensation figure is supported by the kind of quantification analysis courts now require and, where possible, supplement the evidentiary record. Second, maintain a standing benchmark file for the Russian portfolio — a document containing royalty rate references, market value data, and scale-of-infringement comparables that could support a compensation argument at short notice. Third, for any planned enforcement action, review the sequencing of administrative and civil routes in light of the current court practice on how administrative outcomes interact with civil compensation awards. Taking specialist Russian IP counsel into the planning process at the earliest stage — before a filing decision is made — materially reduces the risk of an under-quantified claim.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry