Russian courts apply Article 1252 more strictly to franchise IP disputes in 2026. What foreign franchisors and GCs need to know. Make an enquiry.
Amendments to enforcement practice under Russian civil legislation have, in early 2026, sharpened the standard applied to franchise IP disputes. For in-house counsel managing franchise networks with Russian operations, the position under Article 1252 of the Civil Code now imposes more exacting obligations on rights-holders at every stage — from Rospatent registration through to active court enforcement. Foreign franchisors who have not reviewed their Russian IP arrangements in the past twelve months should treat this as a prompt to do so.
The core mechanism for protecting intellectual property rights through civil proceedings in Russia has long been Article 1252 of the Civil Code, which grants rights-holders a range of remedies — injunctive relief, claims for damages or statutory compensation, and orders for the destruction of infringing goods. What has shifted in 2026 is less the statutory text than the way Russian courts are applying it.
Before the current period, courts applying Article 1252 in franchise-related disputes tended to resolve ambiguous cases in favour of the rights-holder where registration at Rospatent was in order and a franchise agreement (commercial concession agreement) was on record. The evidentiary threshold was relatively permissive: a registered trademark, a notarised copy of the franchise contract, and evidence of infringement were generally sufficient to obtain compensation at the lower statutory band.
From early 2026, the IP Court — which hears cassation appeals in intellectual property matters and whose guidance shapes first-instance practice — has reinforced a stricter reading in several respects. First, the court has emphasised that a franchisee's use of the franchisor's trademark outside the precise scope defined in the commercial concession agreement constitutes infringement by the franchisee, and that the franchisor cannot simply rely on the agreement's existence to establish scope — the agreement must expressly and unambiguously delimit the permitted uses. Second, the court has clarified that sub-franchise arrangements (where a franchisee grants sub-licences) require independent registration at Rospatent to be enforceable against third parties; the franchisor's original registration does not transfer protection downstream without a separately registered sub-licence. Third, the statutory compensation bands under Article 1252 are now being applied with greater granularity, with courts distinguishing between first-instance infringement and repeat infringement — a distinction that affects the quantum of available compensation materially.
"The practical shift in 2026 is that Article 1252 now rewards franchisors who maintain a disciplined registration chain — and penalises those who rely on informal arrangements or outdated agreements." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners
The developments described above affect foreign franchisors differently depending on how their Russian networks are structured. Three categories of franchisor are most exposed.
The first category is franchisors operating through a master franchise arrangement, where a Russian master franchisee holds the right to sub-franchise. If those sub-licence grants have not been registered at Rospatent as separate agreements, they are now at material risk of being treated as unenforceable against third parties — including in proceedings against infringers. In practical terms, this means that enforcement actions brought by sub-franchisees, or defended by them, may fail on standing grounds before the merits are reached.
The second category is franchisors whose commercial concession agreements were drafted under the pre-2020 standard form and have not been updated since. Agreements of that vintage frequently describe permitted trademark use in broad terms — "in connection with the operation of the business" — without specifying the classes, territories, formats, and channels of permitted use. Under the current judicial approach, this vagueness will be construed against the franchisor when the scope of the franchise right is disputed.
The third category is franchisors who have expanded their Russian networks into the EAEU region — Kazakhstan, Belarus, Armenia, and Kyrgyzstan — and assume that their Russian Rospatent registration provides coverage across those markets. Russian registration under Article 1252 protects rights within the Russian Federation only. EAEU members participate in the Eurasian trademark system, but that system requires separate registration through the EAEU mechanism and is a distinct procedural track. Franchisors relying on Russian filings for EAEU-wide protection will find that reliance unfounded in any enforcement action outside Russian territory.
For in-house counsel managing a franchise network with Russian and EAEU exposure, the registration chain — franchisor registration, franchisee sub-licence registration, and EAEU designation if applicable — now requires active audit rather than passive maintenance.
For a structured review of your franchise IP registration position in Russia and the EAEU, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The practical agenda for in-house counsel following these developments falls into three areas.
The first is agreement audit. Every commercial concession agreement governing the use of Russian-registered IP should be reviewed to verify that it defines the permitted scope of use with the specificity that courts now require. This means reviewing the trademark classes covered, the geographic scope within Russia, the permitted channels and formats, and — critically — whether sub-licensing rights are granted and, if so, whether those sub-licences are or can be registered at Rospatent.
The second is registration hygiene. Any sub-franchise arrangement in which a Russian franchisee grants rights to a sub-franchisee should be confirmed as a separately registered transaction at Rospatent. Where such registration is absent, franchisors should assess whether retroactive registration is procedurally available and what the gap in protection means for any pending or foreseeable enforcement action.
The third is enforcement readiness. Foreign franchisors who have identified infringement — whether by a terminated franchisee continuing to use branded materials, or by a third party passing off under a similar mark — should assess their evidentiary position now, before any limitation period risk crystallises. Under Russian civil procedure, limitation periods for IP compensation claims are counted from the date the rights-holder became aware of the infringement, and courts have shown limited sympathy for rights-holders who delay enforcement once awareness is established.
Foreign franchisors should also note that the IP Enforcement practice at Vetrov & Partners provides advice across the full enforcement cycle — from Rospatent registration and agreement review through to proceedings before the Russian IP Court. Related analysis on the position of foreign creditors in franchise IP disputes is available at Foreign creditors and franchise IP protection in Russia, and a broader review of franchise IP enforcement practice is set out at Franchise IP protection and enforcement in Russia: practitioner's overview.
Two questions remain open as of the date of this update and are likely to be resolved through further IP Court guidance in the course of 2026.
The first concerns the position of digital franchise elements — branded apps, proprietary software, and online platform rights — within the Article 1252 framework. The IP Court has not yet issued authoritative guidance on whether digital assets licensed within a commercial concession agreement require separate registration or whether they are covered as ancillary elements of the primary trademark registration. Franchisors with significant digital components in their Russian franchise model should obtain specific advice on this point before assuming coverage.
The second concerns the measure of compensation for multi-outlet infringement — specifically, whether statutory compensation is calculated per outlet, per infringing use, or per infringement event. The current divergence in first-instance court decisions on this question creates meaningful uncertainty for rights-holders assessing the commercial case for enforcement proceedings.
Q: What specifically changed in how Russian courts apply Article 1252 to franchise IP disputes in 2026?
A: The substantive text of Article 1252 has not been amended, but the IP Court — which issues binding guidance on intellectual property matters — has applied a stricter evidentiary standard in franchise-related cases. Courts now require commercial concession agreements to define the scope of permitted trademark use with specificity. They treat sub-franchise arrangements as requiring independent Rospatent registration to be effective against third parties. And they apply the statutory compensation bands under Article 1252 with greater granularity, distinguishing between first and repeat infringement. The combined effect is a higher compliance burden for franchisors and a more demanding evidentiary threshold in enforcement proceedings.
Q: Which types of foreign franchisors are most at risk under the current approach?
A: Three categories carry the greatest immediate exposure. First, franchisors operating through master franchise structures where sub-licences have not been separately registered at Rospatent — those sub-franchisees may lack enforceable standing in court proceedings. Second, franchisors whose commercial concession agreements were drafted before 2020 and use broad, non-specific language to describe permitted trademark use — current judicial practice construes ambiguity against the rights-holder. Third, franchisors who rely on their Russian Rospatent registration to cover EAEU operations — Russian registration protects rights within the Russian Federation only, and separate EAEU registration is required for enforceable protection in Kazakhstan, Belarus, Armenia, and Kyrgyzstan.
Q: What is the most urgent practical step for in-house counsel managing a Russian franchise network?
A: The most pressing step is a targeted audit of the registration chain: confirm that the franchisor's trademark is currently registered and valid at Rospatent, that any sub-licence agreements are separately registered, and that the commercial concession agreement defines the scope of permitted use with the specificity now required by Russian courts. Where any of these elements is absent or deficient, the franchisor's ability to bring or defend enforcement proceedings under Article 1252 may be compromised before the merits of any infringement claim are assessed. A structured review of this kind is the practical foundation for any enforcement action.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry