Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Russian court practice on parallel import disputes under Russian law post-2022 against individual debtors: 2027 update

Elizaveta Razina · September 2026 · 11 min read

Post-2022 Russian court practice on parallel imports has shifted against individual defendants. What in-house counsel must know. Make an enquiry.

The liberalisation of parallel imports under Russian law in mid-2022 was presented, at the time, as a pragmatic response to supply-chain disruption. What followed, however, was a five-year accumulation of judicial practice that foreign trademark owners could not have predicted from the enabling legislation alone. By mid-2027, Russian courts have developed a distinct and increasingly coherent body of doctrine on how parallel import disputes under Russian law are handled when the defendant is not a corporate entity but an individual — a sole trader, a private reseller, or a natural person acting outside any formal business structure. For in-house counsel at foreign multinationals with registered Russian trademarks, that development has materially altered both the risk calculus and the practical enforcement toolkit.

§ I. What changed — the shift from corporate to individual defendants in parallel import disputes

Before the 2022 liberalisation, parallel import disputes in Russia followed a largely settled pattern. Foreign rights holders pursued corporate importers through the commercial (arbitrazh) court system, relying on the principle of national exhaustion that Russian law maintained in conformity with the EAEU-wide framework. The exposure of individual defendants — natural persons, small private sellers, marketplace vendors operating under individual entrepreneur registration — was, in practice, limited. The volume and visibility of their activity rarely justified the procedural investment, and state courts had limited experience calibrating liability thresholds for individuals acting at the retail or near-retail level.

The 2022 changes fundamentally reorganised that landscape. Permitting the importation of goods bearing foreign trademarks without the authorisation of the Russian rights holder — on a list-based mechanism administered through ministerial orders — created a structural ambiguity: what precisely remained prohibited, and who remained liable? The legislative text addressed importers as a category but did not squarely resolve the treatment of individual resellers who acquire genuinely parallel-imported goods and then sell them onward domestically.

Between 2023 and mid-2027, Russian courts — principally the commercial courts and, on IP-specific questions, the IP Court sitting as a court of cassation — worked through this ambiguity in successive waves of decisions. The resulting doctrine, as of July 2027, reflects three identifiable shifts. First, courts have confirmed that the 2022 liberalisation does not extinguish the rights holder's entitlement to pursue individual sellers for trademark infringement where the goods were not imported under the permitted categories or where the seller cannot demonstrate a documented supply chain traceable to a permitted import. Second, courts have applied a knowledge-and-intent analysis to individual defendants that has no direct equivalent in the pre-2022 jurisprudence — the court asks not only whether the goods infringed the mark, but whether the individual defendant had reasonable grounds to know that the import route was impermissible. Third, and most consequentially for foreign rights holders, courts have shown a readiness to award compensation against individuals at levels calibrated to deter commercial behaviour rather than merely to compensate the rights holder for the specific transaction.

"[Parallel import disputes Russia] — [IP enforcement Russia] — [Russia law update parallel import disputes]"

"The shift to individual defendants in parallel import litigation is not a procedural curiosity — it reflects courts trying to close a gap that the 2022 liberalisation created by focusing the permitted categories on importers rather than on downstream commerce." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing registered Russian trademarks — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Who is affected — and why individual debtors now carry distinct litigation risk

The practical importance of this development for in-house counsel at multinationals lies in two directions: who they may now realistically pursue, and what new exposure their Russian-based distribution structures may inadvertently face.

On the claimant side, foreign trademark owners who had previously written off enforcement action against individual defendants — on the basis that recovery was uncertain and procedural costs were disproportionate — should revisit that assessment. Russian courts have demonstrated, across a sample of decisions over the past two years, that compensation awards against individual defendants are enforceable through standard civil enforcement mechanisms and that individual debtors in IP cases are not treated as judgment-proof in the way they might be in some analogous European consumer-facing proceedings. The enforcement mechanisms available against individuals — attachment of bank accounts and real property assets, restrictions on travel documents — are the same as those available against legal entities and are administered by the Federal Bailiff Service on the same procedural footing.

On the risk side, in-house counsel whose companies operate in Russia through a distribution network — including authorised parallel structures that were set up or reconfirmed post-2022 to accommodate the new import regime — should assess whether individual participants in that network are exposed to claims from competing rights holders or from Russian state enforcement bodies acting on the rights holder's complaint. The knowledge-and-intent doctrine cuts in both directions: a distributor's individual employee who physically receives or moves goods may, in limited circumstances, attract personal liability alongside the corporate entity, particularly where the corporate entity is thinly capitalised or has been struck off.

The EAEU dimension adds a further layer. As a member of the Eurasian Economic Union, Russia applies the regional exhaustion principle to goods first placed on the market anywhere within the EAEU. An individual defendant who can demonstrate that the goods entered Russia from another EAEU member state — Kazakhstan, Belarus, Armenia, or Kyrgyzstan — may have a viable exhaustion defence that would not be available if the goods transited outside the EAEU before entering Russia. Courts have accepted this argument, but the evidentiary burden rests on the defendant, and the standard for demonstrating a documented EAEU supply chain has, if anything, tightened as courts have become more familiar with the mechanisms by which parallel import routes are constructed and obscured.

For foreign trademark owners who have allowed their Russian trademark registrations to lapse or who did not pursue renewal post-2022 on the basis that enforcement was perceived as impractical, the current judicial environment represents a material opportunity cost. Enforcement against individual defendants is now viable in a way it was not in 2021 — but it requires a live, valid registration and a documented notice strategy to satisfy the knowledge-and-intent prong of the analysis.

If your company holds Russian trademark registrations and parallel import activity is under-monitored — request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What foreign companies should do now

The immediate priority for in-house counsel is an audit of the Russian trademark portfolio. Valid registration is the threshold requirement: without it, no enforcement action against individual defendants or corporate entities is available. Where registrations are pending renewal or are under challenge, that process should be treated as operationally urgent rather than a routine administrative matter.

Beyond registration, three practice steps have emerged as material from the current judicial environment. The first is documentation of the authorised supply chain. Courts applying the knowledge-and-intent analysis give evidential weight to rights holders who can demonstrate that they maintained a visible, documented distinction between authorised and unauthorised import channels — through official communications, website notices in Russian, and authorised dealer designations that are accessible to individual market participants. Where that documentation is absent, courts have been less willing to attribute knowledge to individual defendants, which reduces the compensation awards available and, in some cases, has led to claims being dismissed against individual sellers while succeeding against the primary importer.

The second is engagement with marketplace operators. A significant proportion of individual defendant cases in the current sample arise from sales on Russian marketplace platforms. The major Russian platforms have introduced brand protection mechanisms that are broadly comparable to those available on EU platforms, though the process for asserting rights and the response timelines differ. Formalising these relationships — through rights holder agreements, notice-and-takedown protocols, and periodic monitoring — provides both a prevention mechanism and an evidential record that supports the knowledge-and-intent prong in subsequent litigation.

The third is forum and defendant selection. The viability of enforcement against an individual defendant depends, in part, on the individual's asset profile and the jurisdictional reach of the relevant commercial court. Individual defendants who operate as registered individual entrepreneurs are pursued in the commercial (arbitrazh) courts, on the same footing as corporate entities. Individuals who operate outside any registered structure — selling through personal marketplace accounts, for example — may fall within the jurisdiction of the general courts (courts of general jurisdiction) rather than the commercial courts, which creates a procedural bifurcation that affects timelines, enforcement mechanics, and the applicable compensation framework. Counsel should map the defendant's registration status before selecting the enforcement forum.

The IP Enforcement practice at Vetrov & Partners has acted for foreign trademark owners in parallel import proceedings before both the commercial courts and the IP Court. For further context on the procedural framework for rights holders, see Foreign Creditors and Parallel Import Disputes and Anatomy of Parallel Import Disputes under Russian Law.

§ IV. Open questions — what the doctrine has not yet resolved

As of July 2027, three questions remain without a settled answer that foreign rights holders can rely upon with confidence.

The first is the outer boundary of the knowledge-and-intent standard. Courts have not produced consistent guidance on what level of commercial sophistication is required before an individual defendant is held to constructive knowledge of the impermissibility of the import route. The current cases cluster around defendants who were operating at a semi-commercial scale — repeated sales, marketplace store presence, bulk purchase patterns. Whether the same standard applies to a one-off private seller remains, in practice, untested at the IP Court cassation level.

The second is the interaction between the permitted import list mechanism and the exhaustion defence. Where goods are on a permitted category list at the time of import but are subsequently removed from that list before the downstream resale occurs, courts have not consistently resolved whether the downstream individual seller retains an exhaustion defence based on the status at the time the goods were first placed on the Russian market. This creates a timing-dependent risk for enforcement strategies built around category list changes.

The third is the CIS dimension. Goods that entered Russia through CIS countries that are not EAEU members — Georgia and Turkmenistan being the most commercially relevant examples — do not benefit from the EAEU regional exhaustion principle but may, depending on bilateral treaty arrangements, benefit from separate CIS-level frameworks. Courts have handled these situations inconsistently, and there is no IP Court ruling that provides authoritative guidance on the applicable exhaustion standard for goods with a CIS-but-non-EAEU origin.

For foreign rights holders designing enforcement strategy, these open questions counsel against a one-size approach. The strength of a claim against an individual defendant depends on the specific import route, the defendant's commercial profile, and the goods category — all of which require analysis before proceedings are initiated.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on parallel import disputes after 2022?

A: The 2022 liberalisation permitted the importation of certain goods bearing foreign trademarks without rights holder authorisation. What courts subsequently clarified — through decisions between 2023 and mid-2027 — is that this permission does not immunise downstream individual sellers from trademark infringement claims. Courts have developed a knowledge-and-intent analysis for individual defendants: a seller must be able to demonstrate that the goods were imported through a permitted channel and that the supply chain was documented. Where that cannot be shown, individual defendants face compensation awards calibrated to deter commercial activity, not merely to compensate for the specific sale. This is a material departure from pre-2022 practice, when individual sellers were rarely the target of trademark enforcement proceedings.

Q: Which foreign companies and individuals are most affected by this development?

A: Foreign trademark owners with active Russian registrations are the primary beneficiaries of this development — it opens enforcement pathways against individual resellers that were previously uneconomic. In-house counsel at multinationals with Russian distribution structures should also audit their networks: individual participants in distribution chains — employees, agents, individual entrepreneurs — may carry personal liability exposure where the corporate entity in the chain is thinly capitalised or has been dissolved. EAEU-based supply chains carry a specific additional consideration: goods first placed on the market in another EAEU member state benefit from regional exhaustion and may defeat an infringement claim, but the defendant bears the evidentiary burden of demonstrating that the supply route qualifies.

Q: What should in-house counsel do to protect their company's position under the current Russian rules?

A: Three steps are immediately advisable. First, confirm that Russian trademark registrations are current and valid — enforcement is unavailable without a live registration, and rights holders who allowed renewals to lapse post-2022 have lost the enforcement window that the current judicial environment offers. Second, document the authorised supply chain visibly and in Russian — courts apply the knowledge-and-intent test partly by reference to whether a reasonable individual defendant could have ascertained the authorised channels. Third, formalise relationships with Russian marketplace platforms through rights holder agreements and notice-and-takedown protocols, which both prevent infringement and generate the evidential record needed for proceedings against individual defendants.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry