Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Russian court practice on patent enforcement before Russian courts against insolvency estates: 2026 update

Elizaveta Razina · May 2026 · 10 min read

Russian courts refined patent enforcement rules against insolvency estates in 2026. What in-house counsel needs to know now. Make an enquiry.

Following shifts in how Russian courts handle intellectual property claims in insolvency contexts, the intersection of patent enforcement before Russian courts and the treatment of insolvency estates has come into sharper focus for foreign companies with Russian operations. Through the first three quarters of 2026, a discernible direction in court practice has emerged: Russian arbitrazh courts are applying a more structured analytical framework when patent holders seek to enforce rights against assets held within a bankrupt estate, with consequences for how and when in-house counsel should instruct Russian patent counsel.

§ I. What changed in Russian patent enforcement practice in 2026?

Russian court practice at the intersection of patent rights and insolvency has historically been uneven. Patent holders – including foreign rights owners registered with Rospatent – faced a procedural ambiguity: whether a patent infringement claim against a debtor company should be pursued as a general commercial claim in the insolvency proceedings or maintained as a separate IP action before the IP Court or the relevant arbitrazh court. The two paths carry materially different procedural consequences, including timelines, priority ranking, and whether relief takes the form of a monetary award or an injunction.

Through 2025 and into 2026, the prevailing approach in a number of circuit courts shifted toward requiring patent enforcement claims against insolvency estates to be channelled into the creditors' register – the standardised mechanism under Russian insolvency legislation by which creditor claims are lodged, ranked, and paid from the debtor's assets in order of statutory priority. This development has a specific practical consequence: a patent holder asserting an ongoing infringement (for example, the unlicensed manufacture or use of a patented technology by a company in administration) cannot, under the emerging consensus, routinely obtain prospective injunctive relief as though the debtor company were a solvent defendant. The insolvency regime applies, and the bankruptcy administrator's control over the estate's ongoing operations is a structural constraint.

What has changed more specifically in 2026 is the treatment of two categories of claim that had previously been handled inconsistently. First, royalty arrears and past infringement damages are now treated more consistently as ordinary monetary claims to be registered in the creditors' register at the relevant priority level. Second, where the patent holder seeks to prevent the continued use of a registered patent by the estate – for instance, where the administrator proposes to sell or licence the infringing technology as part of asset realisation – Russian courts have been more willing in 2026 to entertain interim measures, provided the rights holder can demonstrate registration with Rospatent and the specific prejudice that continued use would cause to the value of the patent.

"The 2026 shift matters because it separates two types of claim that patent holders had previously conflated: past monetary harm and prospective use of the right. Russian courts are now treating them differently, and foreign rights holders who conflate them risk losing their strongest remedy."

— Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

§ II. Which foreign companies and patent holders are most affected?

The practical impact of this development falls most directly on three categories of foreign company operating in or through Russia.

Foreign manufacturers and technology licensors with Russian subsidiaries or former joint-venture partners that have entered insolvency proceedings will find that patent infringement claims arising from the subsidiary's production activities fall within the restructured framework. Where the technology was licensed under an intercompany arrangement, the licensor's claim for unpaid royalties will be registered as a monetary creditor claim. The ranking of that claim in the insolvency waterfall is determined by whether the royalty obligation is characterised as a current liability (текущие платежи, incurred after the insolvency petition) or a pre-petition debt, with current liabilities enjoying preferential treatment under Russian insolvency legislation.

Foreign companies operating in EAEU-member-state supply chains should note a particular complication. Patent rights registered under the EAEU's regional patent system, while recognised across member states, are still subject to Russian domestic insolvency procedure when the debtor entity is incorporated in Russia. Registration of the patent with Rospatent – whether as a national Russian patent or as a designation under the Eurasian Patent Convention – is a precondition for standing to bring enforcement proceedings before Russian courts. Companies that hold patents registered only in their home jurisdiction and have not secured Russian or Eurasian registration will not have enforceable rights in Russian insolvency proceedings and cannot register as patent creditors.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary or former joint venture now in insolvency, the procedural window for lodging creditor claims is strictly defined under Russian insolvency legislation. Missing the deadline for registration in the creditors' register forecloses the monetary remedy entirely; a late-registered creditor is placed behind all registered creditors and, in practice, may recover nothing from an insolvent estate. The urgency of establishing the firm's registration status and lodging the claim correctly – with documentary evidence of Rospatent filing and the patent's current validity – cannot be understated.

For in-house counsel assessing patent claims against a Russian insolvency estate, early registration analysis is critical. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should foreign patent holders do now?

The practical steps that follow from this development are sequenced by urgency. For companies already aware of an ongoing or imminent insolvency of a Russian counterparty or subsidiary, the immediate priority is to verify the status of relevant patents in Russia.

The first step is to confirm that the patent is registered with Rospatent or under the Eurasian Patent system and that the registration is current. A lapsed or pending registration confers no enforcement rights in insolvency proceedings. Where registration has lapsed, there is no mechanism to retroactively revive rights for purposes of an insolvency claim; the rights holder must assess whether other IP protections – trademark, know-how, or contractual indemnities – provide alternative recovery routes.

The second step is to establish the category of the claim. Counsel should characterise the monetary loss – arrears, damages, royalties – and separate it clearly from any prospective-use component. As noted above, the procedural route for each is now distinct. Monetary claims must be lodged in the creditors' register within the statutory period. Prospective-use arguments supporting interim relief require a separate application and carry a higher evidential burden.

The third step is to assess the insolvency stage. Russian insolvency proceedings pass through observation, financial rehabilitation, external administration, and liquidation. The stage at which the patent holder intervenes materially affects what remedies are available. Interim relief preventing continued use of the patent is most realistic during the administration phase, before assets are transferred to a liquidator and the estate is progressively wound up. Once liquidation is underway, the monetary creditor route is typically the only viable option.

Finally, companies with broader Russian IP portfolios – trademarks, utility models, and design registrations in addition to patents – should assess whether their enforcement strategy requires coordination across IP categories. In several recent matters, the firm has advised foreign rights holders in situations where patent claims interacted with registered trademark infringement by the same debtor entity; the evidentiary basis and procedural forum differed, requiring a coordinated approach rather than parallel independent actions.

For detailed analysis of the underlying patent enforcement procedure before Russian courts, see Patent Enforcement Before Russian Courts: A Practitioner's Guide and Strategic Considerations in Patent Enforcement in Russia. For further context on the firm's insolvency-related work, the Matters page provides representative examples.

§ IV. What open questions remain in Russian patent insolvency practice?

Two aspects of the emerging framework remain subject to ongoing court interpretation and warrant monitoring.

The first is the treatment of patent licences granted by the debtor before insolvency. Where the debtor company had licensed its technology to third parties – including related entities or former affiliates – and the administrator now seeks to realise value from those licences as estate assets, the position of the original patentee (if the patent was the subject of a sublicence or was co-owned) is not uniformly settled. Courts in different circuits have reached different conclusions on whether the administrator can continue to operate under a pre-insolvency licence without the patent holder's consent, and on whether the patent holder can terminate a licence granted by an entity now in insolvency. This question is live and the direction of the Supreme Court's supervisory practice on it has not, as of the date of this update, produced a definitive binding clarification.

The second open question concerns the valuation of patent rights as part of the estate. Where the debtor owns registered patents – distinct from the scenario of the foreign creditor holding patents infringed by the debtor – Russian insolvency legislation requires that estate assets be independently valued before sale or transfer. Existing appraisal methodology for intangible assets under Russian law has been described in judicial practice as inconsistent; the risk for foreign companies in cross-border transactions involving Russian insolvency estates that include patent portfolios is that the valuation methodology used may not reflect the commercial value that the foreign counterparty places on those rights.

In-house counsel should also note the EAEU dimension. Russia's participation in the Eurasian Patent Convention means that patent disputes touching on cross-border supply chains between EAEU member states may engage arguments about the regional exhaustion of rights and the territorial scope of enforcement. These arguments have begun to appear in Russian court proceedings with greater frequency, particularly in sectors – agriculture, pharmaceuticals, and industrial equipment – where EAEU-level parallel trade is commercially significant.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on patent enforcement against insolvency estates in 2026?

A: The principal change is the increased consistency with which Russian arbitrazh courts now distinguish between two types of patent-related claim against an insolvent estate. Monetary claims for past infringement, royalty arrears, and damages are now treated as standard creditor claims to be registered in the insolvency proceedings within statutory deadlines. Claims for prospective relief – to prevent the continued use of a patent by the administrator or in the course of asset realisation – are assessed separately and require the patent holder to demonstrate Rospatent registration, current validity of the patent, and specific prejudice from continued use. This separation, which had been inconsistently applied in prior years, has become the prevailing approach across the principal circuit courts through 2026.

Q: Which foreign companies are most affected by this development?

A: The primary categories are: technology licensors and manufacturers whose Russian subsidiaries or former counterparties have entered insolvency proceedings and whose intercompany royalty claims or infringement damages need to be formally registered; EAEU-dimension rights holders whose patents are registered under the Eurasian Patent Convention and who need to confirm that their registration basis gives them standing in Russian proceedings; and companies with broader IP portfolios (trademarks, utility models, and patents) where coordination across enforcement routes is required. Foreign companies that hold only home-jurisdiction patents and have not registered with Rospatent or under the Eurasian system have no enforcement standing in Russian insolvency proceedings.

Q: What should in-house counsel do now to protect patent rights against a Russian insolvency estate?

A: The immediate steps are: (1) verify that relevant patents are registered with Rospatent or the Eurasian Patent system and are currently valid – a lapsed registration cannot be revived for insolvency purposes; (2) characterise the claim as monetary (past infringement, royalty arrears) or prospective-use and identify the correct procedural route for each; (3) confirm the current stage of insolvency proceedings – the observation or administration phase offers more remedial options than liquidation; and (4) where the portfolio includes other IP rights asserted against the same debtor, assess whether coordinated multi-category enforcement is required. The creditors' registration deadline is strict under Russian insolvency legislation and missing it typically forecloses the monetary remedy.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry