Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Russian court practice on prior use rights in Russian trademark proceedings under Article 1252 of the Civil Code: 2027 update

Elizaveta Razina · October 2026 · 10 min read

Russian courts tightened the evidential bar for prior use rights under Article 1252 in 2027. What in-house counsel at multinationals needs to know. Make an enquiry.

Following a marked shift in judicial reasoning visible across IP Court decisions issued throughout 2027, the evidential standard applied to prior use rights claims in Russian trademark proceedings has become materially more demanding for foreign brand owners. Where Russian courts once accepted relatively thin commercial evidence to establish prior use under the Civil Code's general framework for IP protection, the emerging line of decisions requires claimants to demonstrate a continuous, commercially significant presence in the Russian market before the disputed trademark's priority date — a threshold that frequently catches multinational subsidiaries and foreign trademark holders off-guard. For in-house counsel managing a Russian brand portfolio, this shift calls for an immediate review of the evidence base underpinning any prior use position.

§ I. What has changed: the evidential standard in 2027

The prior use right in Russian trademark law operates as a defence mechanism available to a person who, in good faith, used in Russia a designation identical or confusingly similar to a subsequently registered trademark, prior to the priority date of that registration. The right is personal and non-assignable except together with the business or part of the business to which the use relates.

Until recently, the courts' approach to prior use claims under the Civil Code's IP protection provisions tended to be relatively tolerant of evidentiary gaps. It was not unusual for proceedings to be resolved on the basis of documentary evidence that demonstrated use at a single point in time, or use that was modest in scale but geographically identifiable. The claimant needed to establish good faith and priority of use — but the courts were not consistently demanding in assessing what "use in Russia" actually required in commercial terms.

The 2027 line of decisions changes this in two distinct ways. First, courts are now applying a continuity requirement — sporadic or opportunistic use is treated as insufficient to generate a prior use right, even where a priority date advantage exists on the face of the evidence. Second, and more significantly for multinational groups, the courts are scrutinising whether the prior user has actively maintained a commercial relationship with Russian consumers or business partners, rather than simply operating from a foreign base and directing activity toward Russia from outside. Use via distributors or agents remains relevant, but courts have indicated that the prior user must demonstrate knowledge of, and engagement with, the Russian market — not merely exports directed at it.

"[The Russian IP Court's 2027 decisions mark a structural shift: prior use is now a commercial question as much as a chronological one, and groups that relied on export records alone face a materially weakened position.]" — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

For the purposes of Article 1252 of the Civil Code — which governs the general framework for IP rights protection and the interaction between conflicting rights holders — this development affects how courts assess the merits of competing claims where a trademark registration conflicts with an asserted prior use. The change is not legislative; it is a doctrinal development in court practice, which makes it both difficult to predict from the text of the Civil Code alone and unlikely to be reversed without sustained appellate correction.

§ II. Which foreign companies are affected — and why?

The narrowing of the prior use right most acutely affects three categories of foreign company operating in Russia.

The first is the multinational that entered the Russian market via an exclusive distributor arrangement before establishing a local legal entity. In these structures, the trademark was often used under licence or informally by the distributor, with the foreign parent retaining ownership. If the foreign parent subsequently needs to assert a prior use right, demonstrating "use in Russia" — as opposed to use by a Russian intermediary with whom a commercial relationship existed — raises precisely the kind of attribution question that the 2027 decisions leave unresolved in favour of claimants.

The second is the foreign company that suspended active Russian commercial operations but continued to receive royalties, licensing fees, or other passive income from Russian entities. Courts have indicated that passive receipt of income does not amount to "use" for prior use right purposes, a position consistent with earlier IP Court guidance but now applied with greater rigour.

The third — and most immediately concerning for in-house counsel — is the group entity that consolidated its Russian trademark portfolio at parent level, leaving its Russian subsidiary to operate under a licence rather than as a rights owner. Where the subsidiary's commercial activity is extensive but the licensor's own "use in Russia" is thin, a challenge to the trademark registration may expose the group to a prior use claim by a third party who operated in the same category before the registration date.

For companies registered in EAEU member states, the position is complicated further by the interaction between Russian domestic trademark law and the Eurasian trademark system. EAEU-level registrations do not automatically resolve prior use disputes at national level — Russian courts apply Russian Civil Code standards to prior use claims regardless of the EAEU registration status of the mark in issue.

If your company's Russian trademark position relies on a prior use argument, or if you are assessing the risk of a prior use challenge to a registration you hold, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should in-house counsel do now?

The immediate priority is an evidence audit. For every Russian trademark position where prior use is either asserted as a right or assumed as a defence, in-house counsel should identify and consolidate the available evidence of use prior to the trademark's priority date. This means gathering contemporaneous commercial records — invoices, distribution agreements, marketing materials addressed to Russian customers, import documentation, and correspondence with Russian counterparties — rather than relying on post-hoc reconstructions.

The audit should address three specific questions. First: does the evidence demonstrate continuous use, or does it show a pattern of intermittent activity? Second: does the evidence connect the trademark owner — not merely a distributor or licensee — to commercial activity in Russia before the priority date? Third: is the geographical scope of the evidence anchored in Russia, or does it primarily document activity in other EAEU or CIS markets that incidentally reached Russian consumers?

Where the evidence base is thin, consider whether the prior use right remains the correct strategic posture. In some cases, an opposition to a conflicting registration through Rospatent — based on relative grounds rather than prior use — may offer a more defensible path. Alternatively, securing a new Russian registration as early as possible, even where a prior use position exists in principle, removes the dependency on evidence that may not survive the 2027 evidential standard.

For companies whose Russian operations are managed by a local entity under a licence, review the licence structure to ensure that the licensor's own engagement with the Russian market is documented and current. A licensor that cannot demonstrate its own commercial connection to Russia — beyond the fact of a licence — may find that its prior use argument is treated as derivative of the licensee's activity, which courts do not currently equate with the licensor's own "use in Russia."

The firm's IP Enforcement practice has been tracking this development since the first decisions emerged in early 2027. See also A Practical Guide to Prior Use Rights in Russia for a step-by-step account of the procedural requirements, and Deep Dive: Prior Use Rights in Russian Trademark Law for the doctrinal background against which these decisions sit. For matters already in proceedings, the Matters section records examples of how prior use disputes have been handled in practice.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian IP portfolio under live commercial pressure, an early-stage position review is the most cost-efficient response to this development. Request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ IV. What remains uncertain — and where court guidance is still awaited

Several questions left open by the 2027 decisions create genuine risk for foreign brand owners in the short term.

The first is the precise threshold for "continuity." The IP Court has not issued a definitive formulation of what interval between acts of use breaks the continuity required to maintain a prior use right. In some decisions, a gap of under twelve months has been treated as interrupting continuity; in others, commercial context has been considered. Until the courts provide clearer guidance, foreign companies cannot rely on a bright-line rule.

The second concerns the position of companies that exited the Russian market during a period of commercial disruption and are now seeking to re-establish operations. Whether the prior use right survives a period of commercially justified absence — as distinct from voluntary abandonment — remains an open question. Early indications from lower-court decisions are inconsistent, and the matter is likely to require IP Court resolution at cassation level before a settled position emerges.

The third open question is whether use documented exclusively in digital channels — websites accessible to Russian users, online advertising targeted at Russian IP addresses, e-commerce deliveries to Russian addresses — satisfies the "use in Russia" requirement under the Civil Code's IP protection framework. Courts have not yet addressed this systematically, and the answer will be of particular significance for software, media, and technology sector brands.

Foreign companies and their in-house teams should monitor IP Court decisions through the remainder of 2027 and into 2028. The pace of doctrinal development has accelerated, and a cassation ruling on any of the three points above could shift the practical landscape substantially within a short period.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on prior use rights in 2027?

A: Russian courts — principally the IP Court acting at cassation level — have applied a stricter evidential standard to prior use right claims in trademark proceedings. The two principal changes are: a continuity requirement (sporadic or one-off use is no longer treated as sufficient) and an active commercial presence test (use via distributors or passive licensing is scrutinised more closely, with courts requiring evidence that the prior user maintained a genuine commercial relationship with the Russian market, not merely directed exports toward it). These changes derive from judicial interpretation, not from legislative amendment, and apply immediately to pending and new proceedings.

Q: Which foreign companies are most affected by the tightened approach under Article 1252 of the Civil Code?

A: Three categories of foreign company face the greatest exposure. First, multinationals that entered Russia through exclusive distributors before establishing a local entity, where the prior use evidence is held by the distributor rather than the rights owner. Second, companies that held Russian trademarks but suspended active operations while continuing to receive passive licensing income — a position courts are now treating as insufficient to sustain a prior use right. Third, group structures where the trademark-owning parent entity's own Russian commercial activity is thin relative to the operating subsidiary's footprint. EAEU-registered companies should note that EAEU-level registration does not resolve Russian domestic prior use disputes, which are assessed under Russian Civil Code standards.

Q: What should in-house counsel do in the next 90 days?

A: The most effective first step is an evidence audit across all Russian trademark positions where prior use is relied upon — either as an asserted right or as a defence. The audit should test three things: whether the evidence shows continuous use; whether it documents the rights owner's (not merely a licensee's or distributor's) commercial activity in Russia; and whether it is Russia-anchored rather than general EAEU or CIS activity. Where the evidence base is inadequate, the next step is to consider whether a Rospatent opposition on relative grounds — or accelerated Russian trademark registration — offers a more secure position than a prior use argument that may not survive the 2027 standard.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry