Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

A practical guide to prior use rights in Russian trademark proceedings for US rights holders for foreign companies

Elizaveta Razina · June 2026 · 13 min read

US companies facing prior use claims in Russian proceedings need a clear framework. This guide covers requirements and strategy. Make an enquiry.

Unlike the US first-to-use system, in which trademark rights can arise from market use alone, Russian trademark law operates on a first-to-file basis: rights are formally constituted by Rospatent registration, not by commercial activity. For US companies that built brand recognition in Russia before registering, that structural difference creates a specific vulnerability. A local competitor may have filed a registration ahead of them — or may now assert that its own earlier use bars the US rights holder from enforcing a subsequently registered mark. Understanding how prior use rights function under Russian trademark law, and how to deploy or defend against them, is essential for any in-house counsel managing a Russian IP portfolio from the United States.

If your company is navigating a prior use dispute or seeking to secure its trademark position in Russia before litigation arises — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 1. Understanding prior use rights under Russian trademark law

Prior use rights — known in Russian legal practice as the right of the prior user — represent a narrow but legally significant exception to the first-to-file principle. Under Russian trademark legislation, a party that has been using a designation in good faith in Russia before the priority date of a conflicting registered trademark may acquire a right to continue that use within specified limits. This right does not cancel the registered mark, but it may prevent the registered owner from prohibiting the prior user's continued activity in the specific goods and services, and in the specific territory, where prior use was established.

This doctrine originates in Russian civil legislation governing intellectual property and has been interpreted and developed through decisions of the Russian IP Court — the specialist cassation court for IP matters — and of the Rospatent appeal board (the Palata po patentnym sporam). The right is defensive in character: it cannot be transferred independently of the business enterprise to which it belongs, and it cannot be expanded beyond the scope established at the date the conflicting registration acquired priority.

For US companies, this creates two distinct practical scenarios. First, a US rights holder that has registered a mark in Russia may face a third-party prior user claiming the right to continue use despite that registration. Second, a US company that failed to register in time but used the mark in Russia before a local applicant filed may itself seek to assert prior use rights to protect its commercial activity.

What to prepare before engaging with a prior use matter:

Explore the firm's [IP Enforcement practice for further context on trademark strategy in Russia.]

Step 2. What does Russian law require to establish a prior use right?

Russian courts and Rospatent have articulated three cumulative requirements that a party must satisfy to establish a prior use right. All three must be met; the failure of any one of them is fatal to the claim.

First, the use must have begun before the priority date of the conflicting registered trademark. The priority date is typically the filing date of the application at Rospatent, though earlier priority dates can arise from exhibition use, international registrations under the Madrid Protocol, or EAEU-level filings. US rights holders should note that the US filing date of an earlier application has no automatic effect on Russian proceedings: unless a Paris Convention priority claim was properly made within the six-month window and recorded at Rospatent, the Russian priority date will be the date of actual Russian filing.

Second, the use must have been in good faith. Russian law does not define good faith exhaustively, but courts have consistently held that use by a party who knew of an earlier pending application or registration — and who accelerated use to manufacture a prior use defence — does not meet this standard. Good faith is assessed objectively, by reference to what the user knew or ought to have known at the date of first use.

Third, the use must have been of the designation in the territory of the Russian Federation, in connection with the specific classes of goods or services in respect of which the right is claimed, and at a commercial scale sufficient to constitute genuine market use. Isolated or preparatory acts are insufficient. Advertising and promotional activity directed at Russian consumers, sales to Russian distributors, and participation in Russian trade exhibitions have all been treated as probative evidence of genuine use, but none is individually sufficient.

A note on limitation: even where all three requirements are met, the resulting right is not transferable except as part of an enterprise (essentially, the business undertaking to which it is tied). A US company that establishes prior use rights in Russia cannot subsequently assign those rights to a third party independently. In-house counsel should factor this constraint into any acquisition, restructuring, or brand transfer involving Russian assets — inattention to this point has caused commercial loss in several cross-border transactions handled by the firm.

If you are uncertain whether your company's Russian activities are sufficient to found a prior use claim — or whether a third party may assert one against your registered mark — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 3. Building your evidence file: what US companies need to prepare

The evidentiary standard in Russian IP proceedings is document-intensive by US litigation standards. Russian courts and the Rospatent appeal board rely primarily on written evidence; witness testimony carries limited weight unless supported by contemporaneous documents. For a US rights holder, this means that the quality of the commercial record kept in the ordinary course of business — invoices, contracts, correspondence, customs declarations, and marketing materials — largely determines the strength of the position.

Useful evidence in prior use proceedings typically falls into four categories. Documents evidencing the date of first use: the earliest invoice addressed to a Russian counterparty, the earliest distribution agreement governed by Russian law or providing for delivery into Russia, the earliest website or catalogue in Russian language. Documents establishing continuity: a transaction history showing regular activity across the relevant period, without extended gaps that a court might characterise as abandonment. Documents defining scope: materials that specify the goods or services under the designation, establishing the territorial and product contours of the prior use right. Third-party corroboration: customs records, Russian tax filings of a local distributor, trade press coverage, or evidence filed in earlier Russian proceedings involving the same mark.

US rights holders frequently face a practical difficulty here: business records held in the United States may need to be translated, apostilled, and notarised before they are accepted in Russian proceedings. Russian procedural law requires foreign documents to be submitted with a certified Russian translation, and some authorities have additionally required apostille certification of the original documents. Apostille requirements under the Hague Convention apply to documents originating in the US; the standard translation and notarisation protocol should be verified with Russian counsel at the outset of any proceeding, since requirements can vary between the Rospatent appeal board and state courts.

See also the firm's detailed analysis of prior use rights evidence requirements for a more granular treatment of document standards.

Step 4. How prior use rights are raised in proceedings before Rospatent and the Russian IP Court

Prior use rights arise as a substantive issue in at least three distinct types of Russian trademark proceedings, and the procedural vehicle differs in each.

In administrative invalidation proceedings before the Rospatent appeal board, a party seeking to cancel a registered trademark on grounds of bad faith may assert that the applicant was aware of the prior user's rights at the time of filing. Prior use is therefore relevant not merely as a defensive right, but as evidence that the registration itself was made in bad faith. These proceedings are initiated by filing a challenge before the Rospatent appeal board within a five-year period from publication of the registration; beyond that window, a challenge must be brought before the Russian IP Court.

In civil infringement proceedings before the Russian Arbitrazh courts — commercial courts handling IP disputes between legal entities — a defendant may raise prior use rights as a defence to a claim of trademark infringement. The defence, if successfully established, does not void the registered mark but negates the infringement finding and bars the registered owner from enjoining the prior user's continued activity within the established scope. Evidence must be submitted with the statement of defence, and Russian procedural rules impose strict deadlines on the presentation of new evidence; a US defendant relying on prior use should ensure all relevant documents are translated and available before the hearing schedule begins.

In disputes before the Russian IP Court acting as a court of first instance — which hears certain categories of IP dispute including challenges to Rospatent decisions — prior use evidence is assessed on the same substantive criteria as in commercial courts, but the procedural timetable and document submission requirements are governed by the rules of that court specifically. The Russian IP Court has developed a significant body of case law on prior use, and its published decisions are the primary interpretive source for assessing how a new matter is likely to be analysed.

Where a US rights holder is the registered owner defending against a prior use claim, the strategic objective is typically to challenge the three cumulative requirements discussed in Step 2: demonstrate that use began after the priority date, that it was not in good faith, or that its territorial or product scope was too narrow to found the right claimed. The firm's experience in proceedings before both the Rospatent appeal board and the Russian IP Court informs this approach. Further analysis of the litigation strategy appears in the deep-dive on prior use rights in Russian trademark proceedings.

For companies already in prior use proceedings — or facing an infringement claim where prior use may be a relevant defence — our IP team advises on both attack and defence positions. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 5. Does prior use under US law translate to Russia?

It does not, and the distinction is commercially significant for US brands operating in both markets.

Under US trademark law, use in commerce is constitutive of rights: a company that has used a mark in commerce across US states acquires rights by that use, independently of federal registration. First-to-use priority is the foundational principle of US trademark law, even if registration provides substantial procedural advantages. Many US in-house counsel instinctively apply the same logic to Russian markets — assuming that years of US market use, or US federal registration, provide at least some basis for Russian prior use arguments.

Russian law does not follow that reasoning. Prior use rights under Russian trademark legislation require use specifically in Russia — use in the United States, however extensive and however well-documented, does not by itself establish a prior use right in Russian proceedings. A US company that sold only to US customers, distributed only through US retail channels, and whose product never entered the Russian market prior to the conflicting filing date has no prior use defence in Russia, regardless of its global brand history.

There is, however, a partial qualification for companies that participated in international trade fairs held in Russia, exported goods into Russia through third-party distributors, or whose products reached Russian consumers through parallel importation channels. Each of these scenarios may, on the specific facts, contribute to a prior use argument — but each requires careful analysis of whether the use was sufficiently commercial, sufficiently directed at the Russian market, and attributable to the US rights holder rather than to an independent distributor operating on its own account. The Rospatent appeal board and the Russian IP Court have examined all of these factual patterns, and outcomes vary considerably on the evidence.

The practical implication for US in-house counsel is to audit Russian market activity at the earliest opportunity — before a competing registration creates a limitation period problem — and to instruct Russian IP counsel to advise on whether any historical activity in Russia is capable of founding a prior use position. Early assessment significantly widens the range of options available. The Vetrov & Partners Matters page records anonymised examples of cross-border IP matters handled by the firm, including trademark enforcement mandates with a US dimension.

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long before the priority date must a US company have been using a mark in Russia to qualify as a prior user?

A: Russian trademark law does not prescribe a minimum duration of prior use. What matters is that use began before the priority date of the conflicting registration and that it was genuine, commercial, and conducted in good faith. A single day's priority over the filing date is theoretically sufficient, but in practice courts examine the volume, continuity, and commercial character of use over the preceding period to assess whether the activity rises above preparatory acts or token use. For US companies whose Russian market entry was gradual — beginning with distributor shipments before formal establishment of a local entity — the documentary record of the earliest transactions is the critical evidentiary asset. There is no safe minimum period; the analysis is always fact-specific.

Q: What documents does a US brand owner need to prove prior use in Russian trademark proceedings?

A: The core evidence is contemporaneous commercial documentation: invoices addressed to Russian counterparties, distribution or supply agreements providing for delivery into Russia, customs declarations, and marketing materials directed at Russian consumers bearing the relevant designation and an identifiable date. Russian procedural rules require foreign-origin documents to be submitted with a certified Russian translation, and apostille certification of US-origin documents is generally required before Russian courts and Rospatent will accept them. Additional supporting evidence — trade press coverage in Russian publications, participation records from Russian trade exhibitions, or website metadata establishing Russian-language content and dating — can strengthen the primary document record. Evidence assembled after proceedings begin is harder to use; the preparation of the evidence file should begin as early as the dispute is identified.

Q: What happens if a prior use claim succeeds: does it cancel the registered mark, or only limit enforcement against the prior user?

A: A successful prior use defence in Russian infringement proceedings limits enforcement only — it does not cancel the registered mark. The registered owner retains the registration and may enforce it against other parties; the effect of a successful prior use defence is that the registered owner cannot use that registration to prohibit the specific prior user's continued activities within the established scope of prior use (the specific goods, services, and territory demonstrated by the evidence). Separately, if the prior use evidence also supports a finding that the registration was obtained in bad faith — for example, because the registrant was aware of the prior user when it filed — an administrative invalidation challenge before the Rospatent appeal board, or a court action for cancellation, may be available. These are distinct proceedings with distinct standards, and in-house counsel should consider both routes in parallel.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry