Foreign companies facing trademark claims in Russia can invoke prior use rights under Article 1515 to reduce or eliminate compensation. Make an enquiry.
Unlike trade mark law in many common-law jurisdictions, where prior use typically confers automatic priority over a later registration, Russian law draws a sharper line: registration at Rospatent is the primary source of trade mark rights, and an unregistered prior user has no automatic entitlement to continue use simply because it was first in the market. For foreign companies operating in Russia — or those whose goods and brand identifiers reach Russian territory through distribution chains, parallel imports, or EAEU member-state channels — this creates a specific and practical vulnerability. When a compensation claim is brought under Article 1515 of the Civil Code, the question is rarely whether infringement occurred in a technical sense, but how the prior commercial history of the foreign brand intersects with the statutory compensation framework and what procedural tools are available to contest or reduce liability.
What to prepare before proceedings begin
The following documents and evidence categories form the foundation of a prior use rights argument in Russian trademark proceedings. Assembling them in advance, before any claim is served, materially improves the range of available defences.
These materials do not by themselves establish a prior use right under Russian law; they are the evidentiary infrastructure from which the legal argument is constructed.
The threshold question in any prior use rights analysis under Russian trademark law is not how long a foreign company has used its mark globally, but when and how it first used it in Russia or within the EAEU common market. Russian commercial courts assess prior use by reference to the date of the registered proprietor's Rospatent application, not the registration date itself. This distinction matters: a mark may have been registered two years ago but the application priority date may be significantly earlier, compressing the window within which prior use must be demonstrated.
Establish a precise chronology. Identify the earliest documented instance of use in Russia: the first invoice sent to a Russian buyer, the first customs entry, the first distributor agreement with a Russian counterparty. Cross-reference that date against the Rospatent application date of the conflicting registration — which can be verified through the Rospatent public register. If prior commercial use predates the conflicting application's priority date, the factual foundation for a prior use argument exists.
One important qualification: the use must be sufficiently continuous and commercially meaningful. A single invoice or isolated shipment is unlikely to satisfy the threshold. Russian courts have generally required a pattern of use that demonstrates genuine market presence, not merely preparatory activity. Foreign companies that entered the Russian market through distributors should trace the chain carefully — use by an authorised distributor under the foreign company's direction typically counts, but the evidentiary link between the distributor's activity and the foreign brand owner must be documented.
For a detailed analysis of how Russian courts assess the threshold of prior use, see Prior Use Rights in Russian Trademark Proceedings: An Overview.
Article 1515 of the Civil Code establishes the compensation framework that applies when a trade mark registration is infringed. Compensation under this provision operates as an alternative to damages — the claimant is not required to prove actual loss. This makes the provision particularly powerful in the hands of an aggressive registrant, including one who has registered a mark in bad faith after a foreign company's goods entered Russian territory.
The compensation options available to a claimant under Russian trademark law are structured in three ways. A claimant may seek a fixed statutory sum within the range prescribed by the provision. Alternatively, compensation may be calculated as a multiple of the retail value of the infringing goods. A third basis uses the value of the licence fee that would have been payable for authorised use. In practice, claimants often select the method that produces the largest figure given the facts, and courts have discretion to adjust the amount.
Prior use rights intersect with the Article 1515 framework in two distinct ways. First, evidence of genuine prior commercial use can inform the court's assessment of the claimant's standing and the legitimacy of the registration itself — particularly where the registered proprietor acquired the mark after the foreign company's goods were already known in the Russian market. Second, in cases where prior use does not defeat the claim entirely, documented prior use history is a factor that courts have taken into account when exercising their discretion over the compensation quantum. A company that has operated openly in Russia under an internationally recognised brand is in a materially different position from a defendant with no legitimate commercial history in relation to the mark.
Understanding how the IP Court and commercial courts at first instance approach this discretion is essential before selecting a litigation strategy. The IP Enforcement practice at Vetrov & Partners regularly advises foreign companies navigating this framework from the point of first notification through to cassation proceedings before the IP Court.
If your company has received a compensation claim under Article 1515 or a pre-litigation demand from a Russian trade mark registrant, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
In many prior use rights situations, the stronger strategic option is not to defend the compensation claim in isolation but to challenge the validity of the conflicting registration itself. Russian trade mark law, in line with EAEU regional norms, provides grounds for invalidating a registration where the applicant filed in bad faith. A registration filed by a party that was aware of the foreign company's earlier commercial presence — for example, a former distributor, a local agent, or a competitor who had encountered the brand in the Russian market — is a candidate for a bad-faith invalidity challenge.
The invalidity route and the compensation defence are not mutually exclusive. A foreign company can pursue an invalidity application before Rospatent's Chamber for Patent Disputes while simultaneously defending the compensation claim in the commercial courts. Coordinating these parallel tracks requires careful sequencing. A successful invalidity ruling removes the basis for the compensation claim prospectively, but it does not automatically extinguish a claim for infringement that occurred before the invalidity decision took effect. The interplay between the two sets of proceedings must be managed proactively.
Where the invalidity route is not available — for example, because the registration predates the foreign company's Russian market entry, or because the bad-faith evidence is insufficient — a prior use rights argument in the compensation proceedings remains the primary tool. Russian courts have generally accepted that a defendant's good-faith commercial history affects the proportionality of the compensation award, even where the technical infringement is not in dispute.
Assess both routes at the earliest opportunity. Foreign companies that delay this analysis risk having the compensation proceedings advance to a point where the tactical space is reduced. Under the standard Russian commercial litigation timetable, the window between first instance judgment and the deadline for filing an invalidity application can be narrow.
Procedural compliance in Russian trade mark proceedings carries consequences that are difficult to remedy after the fact. The following steps are mandatory in the majority of prior use rights cases, and each carries a risk of procedural waiver if not taken at the correct stage.
Note: Failure to raise a prior use defence at first instance in Russian commercial proceedings is, as a general rule, a procedural bar to raising it on appeal. The practical consequence is that by the time a compensation award is confirmed at appellate level, the defence has been lost. Foreign companies receiving a statement of claim should instruct Russian IP counsel without delay.
For in-house counsel managing a Russian trademark claim with a prior use dimension, the evidentiary and procedural deadlines are the critical early risk. Request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Obtaining a favourable outcome at first instance — whether a reduction in compensation, a dismissal of the claim, or a successful invalidity ruling — is the beginning, not the end, of the strategic process. Russian trade mark registrations that have been used aggressively against foreign companies typically reflect a broader pattern: the registrant may hold multiple marks across related classes, or the same filing strategy may be replicated in other EAEU member states such as Kazakhstan or Belarus.
Following the conclusion of the immediate proceedings, a foreign company should take the following steps to reduce future exposure.
First, file applications at Rospatent for the marks that are commercially important in the Russian market. Prior use rights, however well documented, remain a reactive tool. Registration is the structural protection. Foreign companies that have been operating in Russia through distributors without filing their own Rospatent applications — or whose earlier filings have lapsed — are disproportionately exposed to repeat claims.
Second, review the trade mark position across EAEU member states. EAEU regional trade mark registrations through the Eurasian Patent Organisation (EAPO) provide coverage across member states on a single application, which is more cost-effective than individual national filings for companies with consistent brand use across the region.
Third, document ongoing use systematically. Russian courts assess prior use on the evidence before them at the time of the proceedings. A company that maintains organised records of its Russian market activity — dated marketing materials, sales records, customs data — is substantially better positioned in future proceedings than one that must reconstruct its history retrospectively.
For a comprehensive analysis of evidentiary standards and litigation strategy in prior use rights disputes, the firm's detailed briefing is available at Prior Use Rights in Russian Trademarks: A Deep Dive.
To discuss the post-proceedings position for your company's Russian trade mark portfolio, or to review exposure across EAEU member states, speak to our team: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What is the earliest point at which a prior use rights argument should be raised in Russian trademark proceedings?
A: A prior use rights argument should be raised in the statement of defence at first instance — this is the procedurally correct and, in practice, the mandatory stage. Russian commercial courts apply a limited-review principle on appeal, meaning that arguments and evidence not introduced at first instance are generally inadmissible in subsequent proceedings. Raising the prior use argument at appeal or cassation stage for the first time will typically be rejected on procedural grounds. The practical consequence is that counsel must have the evidentiary foundation ready — documented commercial use predating the claimant's Rospatent application priority date — before the response deadline at first instance. Foreign companies that receive a statement of claim should treat the first-instance response deadline as the critical milestone and instruct Russian IP counsel immediately upon service.
Q: Does documented use in another EAEU member state strengthen a prior use rights argument in Russian proceedings?
A: Use in another EAEU member state — such as Kazakhstan, Belarus, or Armenia — can be relevant but does not automatically establish prior use rights in Russian proceedings. Russian commercial courts assess prior use primarily by reference to use within the Russian Federation. However, EAEU market presence can be material in two supporting ways. First, where a claimant is alleged to have filed in bad faith, evidence of wider EAEU regional brand recognition strengthens the argument that the registrant was aware of the foreign company's mark. Second, it can support an assessment of the mark's acquired distinctiveness and reputation, which courts may take into account when calibrating compensation under Article 1515. An EAEU regional filing through EAPO, if obtained, provides a cleaner structural solution than relying on prior use arguments across multiple national jurisdictions.
Q: What compensation amounts can a claimant realistically claim under Article 1515 of the Civil Code?
A: Article 1515 of the Civil Code establishes three alternative compensation bases, and claimants may select whichever method produces the highest figure on the facts: a fixed statutory amount within the range prescribed by the provision, a sum calculated as a multiple of the retail value of the goods bearing the infringing designation, or a sum equivalent to double the value of the licence fee that would have been payable for authorised use. In practice, claims brought against foreign companies distributing branded goods in Russia can generate compensation demands that are significant relative to the commercial turnover involved. Courts have discretion to reduce compensation below the amount claimed, and documented prior use history — including the defendant's legitimate commercial background and the absence of any intent to free-ride on the registered proprietor's reputation — is among the factors that may support a reduction. Foreign companies should not assume that the absence of actual loss to the claimant is a complete answer to a high compensation claim; the statute does not require proof of damage.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry