Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Privilege and confidentiality in parallel import disputes under Russian law post-2022

Elizaveta Razina · July 2026 · 5 min read

Russian courts offer limited privilege protection in parallel import disputes — a critical gap in-house counsel managing Russian IP matters must address. Make an enquiry.

Unlike English or German law, which extends legal professional privilege broadly to in-house and external counsel communications alike, Russian procedural law recognises no equivalent doctrine. For in-house counsel at a foreign company now managing parallel import disputes under Russian law post-2022 — a category that expanded sharply after the legislative liberalisation of parallel import — this gap carries direct, practical risk. Documents that would be shielded from disclosure in an English High Court or a German Landgericht may be produced, inspected, and relied upon by opposing parties in Russian arbitrazh proceedings with minimal procedural resistance.

What does Russian law actually protect — and what does it not?

The operative distinction in Russian law runs not between privileged and non-privileged communications, but between the status of the legal professional who authored or received them. Practising advocates — lawyers holding an advocate certificate (адвокат) issued under Russian advocacy legislation — benefit from a defined sphere of professional secrecy. Under this regime, an advocate may, in general terms, decline to disclose communications with a client that are directly connected to the provision of legal advice. Courts and investigative bodies have, in practice, treated these protections with varying degrees of consistency, and the scope in civil and administrative proceedings tends to be narrower than in criminal procedure.

Corporate legal counsel employed directly by a company — the standard structure for most foreign subsidiaries and joint ventures operating in Russia — occupy a materially different position. Employed in-house lawyers hold no advocate status and attract none of the advocate secrecy protections. Correspondence between an in-house lawyer and company management, internal legal assessments, and strategic memoranda prepared by employed counsel are, as a general rule, producible documents in Russian arbitrazh litigation. The same applies to communications with external Russian counsel who are not advocates — a category that exists and is not uncommon in practice.

For parallel import disputes specifically, this matters acutely. Since the Government Resolution that came into force in April 2022 opened parallel import for goods originating in states designated as "unfriendly", rights-holder disputes have proliferated across multiple procedural tracks: civil IP infringement claims, Customs enforcement proceedings, and FAS Russia competition investigations. Each of these tracks involves document production or inspection in a forum where privilege cannot be assumed. An internal legal analysis commissioned to assess whether a distributor's parallel import activity constitutes infringement may, if held by an employed in-house lawyer rather than an advocate, find its way before the very tribunal it was prepared to advise on.

How does this operate in Russian parallel import proceedings in practice?

Disclosure in Russian arbitrazh proceedings is less expansive than common-law discovery, but it is not without teeth. A court may order a party to produce specific documents where the requesting party demonstrates that the documents exist, are held by the opposing party, and are relevant to the dispute. There is no broad disclosure obligation equivalent to English standard disclosure, but targeted document orders — particularly in IP enforcement matters and FAS proceedings — are a recognised procedural tool. The risks in parallel import disputes arise in three practical patterns.

First, internal assessments of infringement risk commissioned from in-house counsel are not protected. If such a document comes to light through witness evidence, disclosure during administrative proceedings, or simply through inadvertent production, it can be used to establish that the company had actual knowledge of the infringement — a factor relevant to damages and injunctive relief.

Second, correspondence with Russian external counsel who are not advocates carries the same vulnerability. Foreign companies routinely instruct local Russian counsel under arrangements that do not involve advocate status. Communications in such relationships should be treated as disclosable in the event of litigation or regulatory investigation.

Third, Customs enforcement proceedings — which have become a primary enforcement route for rights-holders opposing parallel imports — involve administrative rather than civil procedure. The scope for compelled disclosure in Customs proceedings is more limited, but documents voluntarily submitted in support of a Customs complaint may circulate across enforcement tracks.

Note: Where a Russian court or FAS Russia orders document production and a company withholds material on purported privilege grounds without a recognised legal basis, sanctions may include adverse inferences or procedural penalties. Companies should not rely on English-law privilege assumptions when responding to Russian procedural requests.

What should in-house counsel do to manage this exposure?

Three steps address the principal risk in parallel import disputes under Russian law.

First, structure external advice through advocates. Where a legal question is genuinely sensitive — an infringement risk assessment, a litigation strategy memorandum, an analysis of exposure under Russian IP legislation — instruct an external Russian advocate rather than, or in addition to, any employed in-house lawyer. Advocate communications attract the statutory secrecy protection; employed in-house communications, even where marked confidential, do not.

Second, segment documentation by function. Separating commercial analysis (market data, pricing rationale, procurement chain assessment) from legal analysis (infringement assessment, litigation exposure) limits the pool of documents that carry genuine risk if produced. Commercial documents prepared by non-legal staff are generally producible in any event; the additional harm comes when legal analysis is conflated with commercial commentary in a single document.

Third, review the instruction structure for Russian external counsel before a dispute crystallises. If the firm's current Russian external counsel relationship is not structured through advocates, consider whether the matter warrants restructuring — particularly if you are anticipating, or are already in, parallel import litigation or a FAS investigation in Russia.

For in-house counsel at a foreign subsidiary managing this exposure, early engagement with Russian IP enforcement counsel before proceedings are initiated is the practical priority. For context on recent legislative developments affecting parallel import rights-holders, see our regulatory update on parallel import disputes under Russian law and our analysis of parallel import exposure for foreign creditors.

To review how your current counsel structure addresses Russian privilege risk — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry