Russia's Supreme Court has sharpened tax due diligence standards for corporate targets. What in-house counsel must verify before closing. Make an enquiry.
In practice, the most consequential surprises in a Russian corporate acquisition rarely originate in the commercial terms — they emerge from the target's tax history. In the course of 2025, Russia's Supreme Court issued a ruling that has materially sharpened the standard of tax due diligence required for Russian corporate targets, clarifying what it means to act with the care that the Russian tax authorities and courts expect from a diligent acquirer. For foreign companies with Russian assets or Russian acquisition targets, and for the in-house counsel advising them, the decision narrows a margin of comfort that many practitioners previously assumed was wider than it was.
Tax due diligence for Russian corporate targets has long been structured around a concept that Russian tax law identifies as the "unjustified tax benefit" — a doctrine that Russian courts and the Federal Tax Service developed over the better part of two decades to address artificial arrangements designed to reduce the tax base. The practical consequence for acquirers is that a target company's historic transactions can attract retrospective reassessment if the tax authorities conclude that the counterparties in those transactions lacked genuine economic substance, or that the target itself failed to verify their substance adequately before entering into commercial relationships.
The evolution of this doctrine accelerated when the Russian legislature codified general anti-avoidance rules into the Tax Code in 2017. Since then, the Federal Tax Service has conducted audits using a more structured and aggressive methodology, and the courts — including the circuit and cassation courts — have generally aligned with the tax authorities' approach in cases where substance verification was inadequate. What had remained somewhat unsettled, however, was the question of the standard of verification: precisely what steps a taxpayer, or a company inheriting tax exposure through an acquisition, is required to have taken in order to demonstrate genuine due care.
The Supreme Court's ruling addressed this question directly, in proceedings involving a commercial entity whose right to deduct input VAT was challenged by the Federal Tax Service on the grounds that its counterparty lacked the business operations and personnel that the transaction nominally required. The lower courts had taken divergent positions on whether the taxpayer's verification steps — which included checking the counterparty's public registration details and reviewing available commercial filings — were sufficient. The Supreme Court resolved the divergence.
The ruling establishes, in terms that Russian courts at all levels are now expected to apply, that the standard of diligence required of a taxpayer in verifying its counterparties is contextual and proportional to the risk profile of the transaction. A counterparty that represents a significant commercial relationship — whether by transaction volume, by the nature of the services or goods supplied, or by the specific regulatory context of the industry — requires more than a routine check of registration data. The Supreme Court held that a taxpayer who confines its verification to publicly available registry information, without making reasonable enquiries into the counterparty's operational capacity to perform the contract, cannot be said to have discharged the standard of care that the legislation demands.
The court elaborated that the assessment is not binary. It is not enough for a taxpayer to demonstrate that it performed some verification; nor will the absence of any verification automatically lead to disallowance. The court directed lower instances to apply a proportionality analysis: the more substantial the commercial relationship and the higher the inherent risk of fictitious supply, the more extensive the verification steps that a diligent taxpayer would have taken. Relevant factors include the value of the transaction, the existence of any market benchmark for the price, the practical plausibility of the counterparty's operational capacity, and whether the taxpayer had any indicators that something was commercially irregular.
"This ruling matters because it converts an informal expectation – that larger transactions require deeper counterparty analysis – into a judicially articulated standard. In-house counsel and acquirers who relied on a basic registry check as sufficient should revisit that assumption across the target's material supply chain." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners
The practical consequence for acquirers is that the ruling provides the Federal Tax Service with a more robust analytical framework for challenging historic VAT deductions and income tax positions at target companies – and the courts with a cleaner doctrinal basis on which to uphold those challenges. Tax exposure that a target's management might have regarded as manageable or unlikely to be pursued now carries a higher probability of crystallisation, particularly where the target's counterparty verification records are thin or have not been systematically maintained.
For in-house counsel managing a Russian acquisition or reviewing the tax exposure of an existing Russian subsidiary, the window between the Supreme Court ruling and the next Federal Tax Service audit cycle is the right moment to assess exposure. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Foreign companies approaching Russian corporate targets — whether through direct acquisition, joint venture restructuring, or the assumption of an existing Russian entity into a group structure — should treat this ruling as a signal to recalibrate the scope and depth of tax due diligence. The standard assumption that tax due diligence for a Russian target means reviewing the results of Federal Tax Service audits already on record, and assessing open limitation periods, remains necessary but is no longer sufficient on its own.
The ruling elevates the significance of the counterparty verification records held by the target itself. A well-prepared target will have maintained documented evidence of the due diligence it conducted on its own supply chain: commercial agreements supplemented by information about counterparty operations, correspondence or meeting records that establish the counterparty's capacity to perform, and — for larger relationships — some form of documented analysis that went beyond registry checks. Where those records are absent or thin, the acquirer inherits not just the quantified tax risk but the uncertainty about how a future audit would be framed and what documentation could be produced in response.
For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary that has already been acquired, the ruling creates a practical compliance task: reviewing the subsidiary's existing counterparty verification procedures and updating them to reflect the proportionality standard now articulated by the Supreme Court. A target company that continues to apply a uniform, registry-only verification process to all counterparties irrespective of transaction volume is operating below the standard the courts now expect. Under the trajectory of Federal Tax Service audit activity in the years following the codification of anti-avoidance rules, acquirers who delay that internal review risk facing a reassessment at a point when the limitation period for the most exposed years has not yet closed.
The ruling also has implications for the structure of representations and warranties in Russian M&A transactions. Sellers who have managed their counterparty verification diligently will be in a position to make more confident tax representations; those who have not should expect more granular warranty requests and, in some cases, price adjustments or escrow arrangements tied to open tax risk periods. Foreign acquirers instructing Russian counsel on legal due diligence should ensure the scope of the tax review specifically addresses counterparty verification records — not merely the aggregate tax provision and audit history.
Our detailed analysis of tax due diligence for Russian corporate targets and practical guide to conducting tax due diligence in Russia address the operational framework in depth.
Foreign companies with Russian acquisition targets or an existing Russian subsidiary should consider a structured tax exposure review in light of this ruling. To discuss your matter in confidence — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What does this ruling change?
A: Before this ruling, Russian courts applied varying standards when assessing whether a taxpayer had performed adequate counterparty verification — leaving acquirers and in-house counsel with limited predictability about what level of diligence would be considered sufficient. The Supreme Court's decision establishes a proportionality principle: the required depth of verification scales with the significance and risk profile of the counterparty relationship. A routine registry check is no longer sufficient for material transactions. This is the first time the Supreme Court has articulated the proportionality framework in sufficiently clear terms for lower courts to apply consistently, and it will inform Federal Tax Service audit methodology going forward.
Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?
A: Foreign companies with Russian corporate targets should extend their tax due diligence scope to include a review of the target's own counterparty verification records and procedures — not merely the target's audit history and open tax periods. Where those records are inadequate, the risk position should be reflected in transaction pricing, warranty scope, or escrow arrangements. Companies that have already acquired Russian subsidiaries should conduct an internal review of the subsidiary's current counterparty verification processes and bring them into alignment with the proportionality standard. Both steps are most effectively carried out with Russian legal counsel who understands both the Federal Tax Service audit methodology and the evidentiary standards now confirmed by the Supreme Court.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry