Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Private Wealth

Case comment: Russian inheritance law for foreign beneficiaries

Elizaveta Razina · June 2026 · 8 min read

Russian courts apply strict succession rules to foreign beneficiaries of Russian assets. What advisers need to know in 2027. Make an enquiry.

In advising family offices and private clients on the protection of Russian assets held by internationally mobile families, one pattern stands out: foreign beneficiaries frequently discover that the structural assumptions underpinning their succession arrangements do not survive contact with Russian law. A recent decision by a Russian court of general jurisdiction – heard on appeal at the regional level – has brought this tension into sharper focus, confirming how Russian courts approach inheritance claims where the beneficiaries are foreign nationals and the assets are sited in Russia.

Background

The matter concerned the estate of a Russian national who had resided abroad for a substantial period prior to death. The estate included immovable property and a participation interest in a Russian limited liability company, both located and registered in Russia. The deceased had prepared a will under the law of the country of residence, naming two foreign-national beneficiaries – one an EU-resident family member, the other a non-EU resident – as sole heirs to the Russian-sited assets.

Following the death, both beneficiaries initiated steps to claim the Russian assets through the notarial inheritance procedure. The notary declined to process the application on the basis that the will had not been drawn up in the form required under Russian civil law and that the mandatory share provisions applicable under Russian succession rules had not been observed in favour of a close relative of the deceased who was resident in Russia.

The beneficiaries challenged the notary's refusal before a Russian court of general jurisdiction. At first instance, the court upheld the notary's position. On appeal at the regional level, the court affirmed the first-instance ruling, holding that Russian succession law – not the law of the deceased's country of residence – governed the form and substantive validity of the will with respect to the Russian-sited immovable property and, by extension, required strict compliance with mandatory share provisions recognised under Russian law.

The participation interest in the Russian company raised a separate procedural question. The court confirmed the prevailing approach: succession to a participation interest in a Russian limited liability company is subject to Russian law as the law of the place of incorporation, and the company's constitutional documents may impose additional conditions on the transfer of such an interest to an heir who is not already a participant.

The decision

The appellate court's reasoning rested on two principles that are well-established in Russian private international law and that courts have consistently applied when foreign beneficiaries assert inheritance rights over Russian-sited assets.

First, the court confirmed that immovable property located in Russia is governed by Russian law for succession purposes. The law of the deceased's habitual residence – which the foreign-prepared will purported to invoke as the governing law – has no direct application to the form or substantive content of a testamentary disposition affecting Russian real property. A will that is formally valid under a foreign legal system will not, as a matter of course, be recognised as valid under Russian succession rules if it does not comply with Russian formal requirements or if it fails to accommodate the mandatory share entitlement recognised by Russian law.

Second, the court addressed the mandatory share question with particular clarity. Russian succession law provides that certain categories of close relative – including disabled spouses, children, and parents of the deceased who were financially dependent at the time of death – are entitled to a minimum share of the estate regardless of testamentary disposition. The court held that this entitlement cannot be defeated by a will drawn up under foreign law, even where that law would permit full testamentary freedom. Advisers who have structured succession arrangements on the assumption that a foreign will is sufficient to protect the intended distribution may need to revisit that assumption where the estate includes Russian assets and where the deceased had qualifying dependants in Russia.

"Russian courts apply a territorial logic to succession that advisers accustomed to common-law or civil-law systems with more permissive conflict-of-laws rules may not anticipate – the Russian situs of an asset is frequently the dominant connecting factor." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

A subsidiary point of practical significance: the court's analysis of the participation interest confirmed that the company's articles of association had a role to play independently of the succession ruling. Where the articles require the consent of existing participants before a new participant may join, an heir – including a foreign beneficiary who has successfully obtained a Russian inheritance certificate – cannot compel admission to the company without that consent. The court did not resolve the valuation question that arises when consent is withheld, but the ruling reinforces the importance of reviewing company constitutional documents as part of any pre-succession planning exercise.

If your clients hold Russian assets and their succession arrangements were structured under foreign law alone, the structural gap identified by this ruling warrants early attention. Discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign beneficiaries and their advisers

For family offices and wealth advisers with clients who have Russian-sited assets – whether immovable property, participation interests in Russian companies, or bank-held assets with a Russian nexus – this decision reinforces three practical points that the firm has observed across its Private Wealth & Asset Protection instructions.

The first is that the place of situs is the governing connecting factor for Russian immovable property, regardless of the deceased's nationality or habitual residence. A foreign will, however well-drafted under the law of another jurisdiction, does not displace Russian succession law with respect to assets located in Russia. Any succession plan that relies solely on a foreign testamentary instrument should be reviewed for Russian-law compliance by Russian-qualified counsel.

The second point concerns the mandatory share. This is not a procedural technicality that can be negotiated around after death. It is a substantive entitlement under Russian law, and the categories of qualifying relative are broader than many clients and their advisers initially expect. Where a client has dependants or close relatives resident in Russia, the exposure to a mandatory share claim should be quantified and addressed structurally before the succession event, not during it.

The third concerns corporate assets. The transfer of a participation interest on succession is subject both to Russian succession law and to the company's constitutional documents. Both layers must be examined. The firm has acted for foreign beneficiaries who obtained a valid Russian inheritance certificate only to find that the company's articles imposed a consent requirement that effectively transferred control of the outcome to the surviving participants. That scenario is avoidable with appropriate pre-succession structuring.

It is worth noting that the principles affirmed in this case apply with equal force to EAEU-resident beneficiaries and CIS-national heirs: membership of regional frameworks does not modify the application of Russian private international law to succession over Russian-sited assets.

For advisers working with international families whose wealth includes a Russian dimension, we would also recommend reviewing our analysis at Navigating Russian inheritance law for foreign clients and the broader framework set out in Russian Supreme Court clarification on succession rights in Russia. Both pieces address the legislative and judicial background that contextualises this ruling.

Families who have not yet taken advice on the Russian dimension of their succession arrangements face a structuring risk that grows in proportion to the value of Russian-sited assets and the time remaining before a succession event. Early engagement allows for a range of structural solutions – including dual-instrument testamentary arrangements, pre-succession corporate restructuring, or the use of Russian-law compliant formalities alongside existing foreign instruments – that are unavailable once probate has opened.

To discuss the implications of this ruling for a specific client situation, contact our Private Wealth & Asset Protection team in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign beneficiaries of Russian assets?

A: The ruling does not introduce new law; it confirms and applies established principles of Russian private international law with particular clarity. Its significance lies in the appellate court's unambiguous restatement that Russian succession law governs the form and substantive validity of testamentary dispositions affecting Russian-sited immovable property, irrespective of the law under which a foreign will was prepared. For foreign beneficiaries, the practical change is one of awareness: advisers who have assumed that a foreign will is self-sufficient for Russian-sited assets should treat that assumption as unverified until Russian-law compliance has been confirmed.

Q: What should foreign families and their advisers do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, identify whether any existing succession arrangement for a client with Russian-sited assets relies solely on a foreign testamentary instrument. If so, that instrument should be reviewed by Russian-qualified counsel to assess whether it meets Russian formal requirements and adequately addresses the mandatory share exposure. Second, map any qualifying dependants or close relatives of the client who are resident in Russia – this determines the scope of the mandatory share risk. Third, for clients holding participation interests in Russian companies, review the company's articles of association to establish whether a consent mechanism applies to the transfer of that interest on succession. These steps are most straightforward when taken as part of pre-succession planning; they become considerably more complex and less certain in outcome once a succession event has occurred.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry