Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Private Wealth

Russian Supreme Court rules on family disputes involving Russian-situated assets: analysis and implications

Elizaveta Razina · February 2026 · 8 min read

The Russian Supreme Court clarified how family disputes over Russian-situated assets are resolved. Key implications for wealth planning. Make an enquiry.

Foreign families holding Russian-situated assets — real property, shareholdings in Russian entities, funds held in Russian financial institutions — have long operated on the assumption that a foreign divorce settlement or foreign court order would govern the division of those assets. A recent line of guidance from the Russian Supreme Court has tested that assumption directly. In cases where at least one party or the assets themselves fall within Russian jurisdiction, Russian courts have asserted the primacy of Russian family and civil law in determining how those assets are characterised, valued, and ultimately divided. The implications for internationally mobile families and their advisers are material, and they do not resolve in favour of the status quo.

Background

Family disputes involving Russian-situated assets occupy an uncomfortable intersection of Russian family law, Russian civil procedure, and the private international law rules that determine which court's analysis governs which assets. Under the prevailing framework, Russian courts hold jurisdiction over immovable property situated in Russia regardless of the nationality or domicile of the parties. For movable assets — shares in Russian companies, funds, and personal property located in Russia — the position is more nuanced: Russian courts have jurisdiction when either spouse is domiciled or habitually resident in Russia, or when the assets themselves are sufficiently connected to Russian territory to bring them within the court's competence.

Until recently, the standard practice for internationally structured families was to treat foreign divorce proceedings as the primary forum and to address Russian-situated assets within that framework, relying on the foreign court's order as the document that would ultimately be executed in Russia. Russian courts would then be asked, at most, to assist with enforcement. That approach is now under pressure.

The guidance under review arose from a series of cases in which one spouse sought recognition in Russia of a foreign court order dividing Russian real property and shareholdings. In each matter, the Russian Supreme Court addressed whether the foreign order — made without the participation of Russian courts and without the application of Russian substantive law — could be recognised and enforced in Russia in respect of those specific assets.

What did the court decide?

The Russian Supreme Court's analysis turned on two questions: first, whether the foreign court had competence over Russian-situated assets under Russian private international law; and second, whether the application of foreign substantive law to those assets produced a result incompatible with Russian public policy.

On competence, the court's position confirmed the principle of exclusive Russian jurisdiction over immovable property situated in Russia. A foreign court order purporting to divide Russian real property — whether awarding ownership, a share of equity, or a monetary equivalent calculated by reference to that property — was found, in the cases under review, to have been made without the competence recognised by Russian law. The consequence is not merely procedural: an order made without competence is not recognisable in Russia at all, regardless of its merits. The party relying on that order to obtain title or monetary recovery in Russia must begin again, in a Russian court, under Russian law.

On the public policy question, the court examined whether the substantive outcome — the division of marital assets as determined by the foreign court — was compatible with Russian concepts of joint marital property and equitable division. Where the foreign law applicable to the marriage produced a result materially different from the Russian regime of joint property of the spouses, the court identified the potential for a public policy objection. This analysis was not applied automatically: the court did not hold that all foreign-law outcomes are incompatible. However, it established that compatibility is not presumed, and that the party seeking recognition carries the burden of demonstrating it.

"What this guidance makes clear is that Russian-situated assets cannot be treated as a passive element of an internationally structured divorce. They require bespoke Russian-law analysis at the planning stage, not after a foreign court has already decided their fate." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

The decision also touched on valuation: where Russian assets are awarded a monetary equivalent by a foreign court and the valuation methodology used does not reflect Russian market values at the date of division, Russian courts may decline to treat that figure as binding.

For families and advisers managing cross-border asset structures that include Russian-situated property or shareholdings, early Russian-law analysis is the practical priority — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What does this mean for families with Russian assets?

The implications of this guidance depend on the structure of the family's Russian holdings and the stage of any dispute. Three categories of family are most directly affected.

The first is families in which Russian-situated assets were structured informally — direct ownership of Russian real property or shares by one or both spouses, without any intervening holding structure. For this group, the guidance makes the risk of forum conflict concrete. If one spouse initiates foreign divorce proceedings without first securing a parallel Russian process, the Russian assets may be excluded from any settlement reached abroad, because the foreign order will not be enforceable in Russia in respect of those assets. The result is a second set of proceedings — in Russia, under Russian law — that may produce a materially different outcome.

The second category is families who have structured their Russian assets through intermediate holding vehicles, typically Cypriot, Dutch, or other foreign holding companies. Here the analysis is more layered. If the foreign divorce proceedings address shares in the foreign holding company rather than the underlying Russian assets, there is a reasonable argument that exclusive Russian jurisdiction does not apply to those shares. However, Russian courts have shown a willingness, in some circuit-level decisions, to look through intermediate structures to the underlying Russian assets when the principal asset of the holding company is Russian real property or a Russian operating business. Advisers relying on a holding structure to insulate Russian assets from the exclusive jurisdiction rule should treat that position as requiring current legal verification, not a settled assumption.

The third category is families currently at the planning stage — where no dispute has yet arisen and the question is how to structure Russian assets to minimise future jurisdictional complexity. For this group, the guidance is most constructive, because the options available at the planning stage are wider than those available once proceedings have commenced. Structures that address the family law characterisation of Russian assets in advance — including the use of pre-nuptial or post-nuptial agreements governed by Russian law and registered with Russian authorities — may significantly reduce the risk of subsequent forum conflict.

For all three categories, the Private Wealth & Asset Protection practice requires a current assessment of how Russian-situated assets are held, how they are characterised under Russian family law, and whether existing foreign arrangements produce an enforceable result in Russia. Related analysis of the procedural framework for this type of matter is set out in our guide to family disputes involving Russian-situated assets and in the firm's practical guide to navigating family disputes involving Russian assets. A broader record of the firm's experience in this area is available on the Matters page.

For an initial assessment of how Russian-situated assets are positioned within an existing or potential dispute — discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for families with Russian-situated assets?

A: The guidance confirms that Russian courts treat immovable property situated in Russia as subject to exclusive Russian jurisdiction in family proceedings, regardless of where the marriage was contracted or the parties are domiciled. A foreign divorce order that divides Russian real property without the participation of a Russian court will not, as a general rule, be enforceable in Russia in respect of that property. For movable assets — shares in Russian companies, funds held in Russian accounts — the position turns on domicile and the nature of the assets, but the ruling signals that compatibility with Russian substantive law cannot be assumed. Families and advisers who have structured their affairs on the assumption that a foreign order would resolve Russian assets should treat that assumption as requiring current review.

Q: What should families and their advisers do in light of this decision?

A: The most practical response depends on the stage of any matter. For families where no dispute has arisen, this is a structuring question: how are Russian-situated assets held, and does the existing structure allow for orderly division under Russian family law if required? Pre-nuptial or post-nuptial agreements that address Russian assets expressly, governed by Russian law, are among the instruments available at this stage. For families in active proceedings abroad, the priority is to assess whether the Russian-situated assets are within the scope of the foreign proceedings and, if so, whether to initiate parallel proceedings in Russia before the foreign order crystallises. Doing so before a foreign order is made gives considerably more flexibility than seeking to challenge recognition afterwards.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry