Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Private Wealth

Landmark decision on cross-border estate planning with Russian elements: what it means for foreign parties

Elizaveta Razina · March 2026 · 7 min read

A landmark Russian court ruling on cross-border estate planning changes the landscape for foreign parties holding Russian assets. Make an enquiry.

In a decision handed down in mid-2026, a Russian appellate court addressed one of the more persistently uncertain questions in private wealth practice: to what extent can a foreign estate plan — one structured under a non-Russian law and executed abroad — determine the treatment of Russian-sited assets after the death of a foreign national? The ruling, which arose from proceedings initiated by the heirs of a foreign individual holding immovable property and corporate participations in Russia, has generated considerable attention among practitioners advising high-net-worth clients with mixed portfolios. The court's reasoning engages directly with the intersection of Russian private international law, forced heirship norms, and the limits of foreign trust and testamentary structures when applied to Russian assets.

Background

The dispute concerned the estate of a foreign national whose assets included real property located in Russia and minority shareholdings in two Russian limited liability companies. The individual had established a testamentary structure governed by the law of a continental European jurisdiction, directing distribution of the global estate to a designated class of beneficiaries. A separate group of individuals — claimants who would have qualified as compulsory heirs under Russian succession law — initiated proceedings in Russia, contending that the foreign testamentary instrument could not displace their entitlements to the Russian-sited portion of the estate.

The central procedural question was which law governed the succession to the Russian assets: the law chosen by the testator and reflected in the foreign instrument, or Russian law as the lex situs in respect of immovable property and, by extension, the corporate participations. A secondary question concerned whether the Russian court would treat the foreign testamentary instrument as an admissible source of entitlement at all, given that it had not been submitted to any Russian notarial or judicial recognition process.

The lower court found for the compulsory heirs on both counts, holding that Russian law applied to the succession of Russian-sited assets and that the foreign instrument, absent formal recognition in Russia, could not override the statutory protected shares. The case proceeded to the appellate level on both the choice-of-law and the recognition questions.

The decision

The appellate court upheld the lower court's conclusions in substance, though it refined the reasoning on the choice-of-law point in a manner that practitioners will need to account for carefully. On the lex situs question, the court affirmed the prevailing position under Russian private international law: succession to immovable property located in Russia is governed by Russian law, regardless of the nationality of the deceased or the governing law of any testamentary instrument. This is not a novel outcome, but the court's articulation of the principle was notably explicit in extending it to the corporate participations — treating the shares in Russian entities as analogous in character to immovables for the purpose of the conflict-of-laws analysis, on the grounds that the assets derive their essential character from Russian legal registration and cannot be transferred without engaging Russian corporate procedure.

On recognition, the court held that a foreign testamentary instrument not registered with a Russian notary and not subject to a formal Russian recognition process carries no binding legal force in respect of Russian-sited assets — even where the foreign jurisdiction's law would treat the instrument as finally determining the distribution of the global estate. The court distinguished between a foreign court judgment (which may be presented for recognition under established Russian procedure) and a privately executed testamentary document, which it treated as categorically ineligible for automatic cross-border effect.

The significance of the decision lies not in the outcome — which aligns with what careful practitioners have long advised — but in the degree of doctrinal clarity the court brought to the lex situs analysis for corporate assets and the categorical treatment of non-notarised foreign testamentary instruments.

"What the appellate court has done is close a structuring assumption that some advisers were still working with — the idea that a sophisticated foreign trust or testamentary instrument could govern Russian assets by default, absent active engagement with Russian succession procedure." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house advisers and family office counsel managing portfolios that include Russian assets, this ruling reinforces that the structural gap between a foreign estate plan and the Russian legal position requires active bridging — not passive reliance on foreign law.

For families and family offices with Russian assets in their portfolio, an early review of existing estate structures in light of this ruling is advisable. Discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What does this ruling mean for foreign clients holding Russian assets?

The practical implications of the decision fall into three distinct areas for foreign parties engaged in cross-border estate planning with Russian elements.

First, the lex situs principle for Russian immovables is firmly settled — and the court's extension of that principle to corporate participations in Russian entities represents a material development for structures built around shareholdings in operating or holding companies. Advisers who have treated shares in Russian LLCs or joint-stock companies as amenable to foreign-law succession planning should revisit that analysis. The court's reasoning, while not binding on all circuits, sets a persuasive doctrinal precedent that is likely to be followed where similar factual patterns arise.

Second, the recognition treatment of foreign testamentary instruments confirms that passive reliance on a foreign will or trust deed is insufficient. Where Russian assets are involved, the structure must engage with Russian succession procedure — typically through notarial registration of a Russian-law will or a separately constituted Russian-law testamentary disposition covering the Russian-sited assets, running in parallel with the foreign instrument. The two instruments need not conflict; careful drafting can ensure they operate consistently.

Third, the decision has implications for structures that use foreign trusts or foundations as holding vehicles for Russian assets. Where the underlying assets are Russian real property or participations in Russian entities, the court's analysis suggests that the interposition of a foreign vehicle does not — of itself — displace the application of Russian succession law to the economic interest at stake. This is a point that deserves careful attention in any review of existing structures under Private Wealth & Asset Protection mandates.

For broader context on the regulatory backdrop to cross-border estate planning with Russian elements, the firm has published a detailed practice briefing at Cross-Border Estate Planning with Russian Elements and a note on Federal Tax Service guidance relevant to the same planning landscape at Federal Tax Service Guidance on Cross-Border Structures.

Foreign advisers managing exposure across multiple jurisdictions — including EAEU and CIS member-state contexts where Russian succession rules may interact with bilateral treaty frameworks — will find additional procedural context in the firm's matters archive.

If you are reviewing an existing estate structure that includes Russian assets, or advising a family on forward planning, Vetrov & Partners can assist with the Russian-law analysis. Discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling does not reverse the long-standing lex situs principle — Russian law governs succession to Russian-sited immovable property regardless of the testator's nationality. Its significance lies in two specific extensions: first, the court applied the same lex situs logic explicitly to shareholdings in Russian companies, treating them as substantively equivalent to immovables for conflict-of-laws purposes. Second, the court drew a categorical distinction between foreign court judgments (which may be recognised through established Russian procedure) and private foreign testamentary instruments, which it held carry no binding force in Russia unless registered with a Russian notary or submitted to a formal recognition process. Advisers who relied on the ambiguity around corporate assets and foreign testamentary documents now have clearer — and more restrictive — parameters to work within.

Q: What should foreign clients do in light of this decision?

A: The priority is to review any estate structure that holds Russian-sited assets — whether directly as real property or indirectly through shareholdings in Russian entities — and to assess whether it engages adequately with Russian succession procedure. A foreign will or trust deed that has not been registered with a Russian notary, or that does not sit alongside a separately constituted Russian-law testamentary disposition covering the Russian assets, is likely to be treated as having no effect in Russia on the death of the asset holder. Clients in this position should take legal advice before any further structural changes are made, since some corrective steps — such as notarial registration in Russia — have procedural prerequisites that take time to satisfy. Early engagement is advisable rather than deferred action.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry