Russian courts now define sanctions compliance obligations for foreign companies in Russia. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.
In a period of sustained judicial activity that has materially affected how Russian courts analyse the compliance frameworks of companies with cross-border exposure, the Russian Supreme Court has issued guidance clarifying the legal obligations of Russia-linked businesses operating under competing regulatory environments. For foreign companies maintaining subsidiaries, joint ventures, or contractual relationships within Russia, the direction of this guidance matters: it confirms that Russian courts will assess compliance conduct through the prism of Russian law exclusively, without deference to foreign regulatory instructions, and that this assessment carries direct consequences for contractual performance, liability, and enforcement. In-house counsel advising on Russia-linked operations who have not reviewed their compliance arrangements against this standard should treat this as an urgent gap to close.
Russia-linked businesses have long operated in a tension between the requirements of their home-jurisdiction regulators and the demands of Russian civil and commercial law. Foreign-headquartered groups that maintain Russian subsidiaries or that continue to perform contracts with Russian counterparties face an environment in which operational decisions taken for compliance purposes in one jurisdiction may give rise to claims or liability in another.
Over the past several years, Russian commercial courts have encountered an increasing volume of disputes in which a party sought to justify non-performance, contractual suspension, or unilateral exit on the basis that compliance with obligations imposed by a foreign regulatory authority required the breach. The legal question these cases pose is fundamental: does a Russian court recognise a foreign compliance obligation as a valid legal basis for departure from Russian contractual or regulatory duties?
The Supreme Court's guidance, developed through its supervisory practice and reflected in the approach now consistently applied by arbitrazh courts across the Russian circuits, answers that question in clear terms. Russian law does not, as a general rule, treat obligations imposed by foreign authorities as force majeure, as grounds for contractual frustration, or as a defence to non-performance claims brought in Russian proceedings. The precise legal analysis varies by case type, but the prevailing approach across courts has been to apply Russian civil and contract law as the governing framework and to decline to characterise foreign compliance instructions as legally cognisable grounds for non-performance.
The most significant aspect of the Supreme Court's emerging position is its treatment of the concept of supervening impossibility of performance. Under Russian civil law, impossibility of performance may excuse a party from contractual obligations in defined circumstances. Courts have generally held, however, that regulatory constraints originating from a foreign jurisdiction do not, of themselves, constitute the type of impossibility that Russian law recognises. For impossibility to be invoked successfully, the obstacle must typically be one arising under Russian law, imposed by a competent Russian authority, or attributable to circumstances entirely outside the party's control as assessed by Russian legal standards.
Foreign companies that restricted or suspended performance on the basis of home-jurisdiction compliance requirements, without obtaining a parallel Russian legal basis for that restriction, have found themselves exposed to breach of contract claims, damages assessments, and in some instances, liquidated damages provisions that Russian courts have been willing to enforce. The Supreme Court's guidance reinforces this: characterising compliance conduct as legally mandated under foreign law does not, under the prevailing Russian approach, satisfy the conditions for legal excuse of non-performance in Russian proceedings.
Equally significant is the approach taken to corporate liability within Russia-linked group structures. Where a foreign parent has directed the conduct of a Russian subsidiary for compliance purposes, Russian courts have in certain cases been willing to analyse whether the directing conduct itself engages liability under Russian corporate law. The guidance suggests that the corporate separateness of a Russian entity will not always insulate the broader group from scrutiny in Russian proceedings, particularly where the Russian entity's non-performance is the direct consequence of instructions from outside Russia.
"The practical consequence for foreign groups is that compliance decisions taken abroad have a legal footprint inside Russia that Russian courts are increasingly prepared to examine on their own terms." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners
If your group has taken compliance decisions affecting Russia-linked operations and has not assessed their exposure under Russian law, a structured review is advisable before proceedings are initiated. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
For in-house counsel managing Russia-linked operations, the most immediate practical implication is the need to distinguish between what a company's home-jurisdiction compliance programme requires and what that programme's implementation means under Russian law. These are separate analytical exercises, and conflating them creates precisely the exposure that the Supreme Court's emerging guidance has identified.
Foreign subsidiaries operating in Russia should have their contractual obligations reviewed for provisions that a compliance-driven suspension or modification of performance would trigger. Standard force majeure language, which many companies assume would cover a regulatory instruction from a home-jurisdiction authority, has not, in the prevailing approach of Russian courts, been interpreted to extend to foreign compliance obligations. Where contracts contain Russian-law governing clauses, this analysis is particularly important.
The corporate governance dimension is equally material. Where a Russian subsidiary has relied on group-level instructions in declining to perform, or where its management has followed directives that resulted in non-performance toward Russian counterparties, the question of where liability sits within the group is one that Russian courts are prepared to examine. Groups that have not documented the basis on which performance decisions were made, and the legal authority under Russian law on which those decisions rested, face a more difficult evidentiary position if proceedings are brought.
For companies that have already faced claims in Russian courts arising from compliance-driven non-performance, the question is how to engage with those proceedings in a manner that reflects the current judicial approach. The answer is not to rely on foreign regulatory necessity as a defence, but to identify whether any basis exists under Russian law for the conduct in question and to build the evidentiary record accordingly.
The firm's broader Regulatory & Licensing analysis sets out how Russian courts approach the relationship between foreign and domestic compliance obligations across the range of Russia-linked business contexts. Those advising on these matters should also consider the framework set out in Sanctions Compliance for Russia-Linked Business Operations and the procedural recommendations in A Practical Guide to Sanctions Compliance for Russia-Linked Operations. Related matters are catalogued at the firm's Matters Hub.
To discuss how this guidance applies to your group's specific Russia-linked arrangements, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What does this ruling change for foreign companies with Russia-linked operations?
A: The Supreme Court's emerging guidance does not introduce a new legal framework — it clarifies and reinforces how Russian courts have been applying existing Russian civil and contract law to compliance-driven conduct. The change it consolidates is the confirmation that foreign regulatory obligations do not, under the prevailing approach of Russian courts, constitute a legally valid basis for non-performance of Russian-law-governed obligations. For foreign companies that had previously assumed that home-jurisdiction compliance requirements would be recognised as a defence in Russian proceedings, this requires a reassessment of both contractual exposure and the basis on which performance decisions are documented.
Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?
A: In-house counsel should carry out three immediate steps. First, identify all Russia-law-governed contracts under which performance has been modified, suspended, or terminated for compliance reasons, and assess whether any Russian-law basis for that modification was established and documented at the time. Second, review the corporate governance trail for instructions given to Russian subsidiaries from outside Russia that resulted in non-performance toward Russian counterparties. Third, seek Russian legal counsel before responding to any claim or pre-claim correspondence that touches on compliance-driven non-performance, since the framing of a defence at an early stage materially affects the options available later in proceedings.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry