Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Russian court practice on industry licensing requirements in Russia against state-related entities: 2026 update

Kristina Kornouhova · February 2026 · 8 min read

Russian courts are refining licensing obligations for state-related entities. What foreign subsidiaries need to know in 2026. Make an enquiry.

Russian courts have been steadily clarifying how industry licensing requirements apply when the counterparty to a regulatory or commercial relationship is a state-related entity — a category that encompasses state-owned enterprises, federal and regional unitary enterprises, and entities with substantial state participation. For in-house counsel at foreign companies with Russian subsidiaries, joint ventures, or supply chain exposure, the direction of court practice in the first quarter of 2026 has introduced specific compliance obligations that did not feature as prominently in earlier judicial reasoning. Understanding where the courts now draw the line between general licensing compliance and requirements specifically engaged by the state-related character of a counterparty is no longer a theoretical concern.

§ I. What has changed in Russian court practice on industry licensing?

Before the current period, Russian arbitrazh courts applied industry licensing requirements largely on the basis of the activity type alone. Whether a company held or needed a particular licence was determined primarily by what it did, not by who it contracted with. That position has shifted. The prevailing judicial approach in licensing-related disputes from late 2025 through early 2026 has been to treat the state-related character of a counterparty as a materially relevant factor in assessing both the scope of a licensing obligation and the consequences of non-compliance.

In practice, courts have increasingly held that where a Russian legal entity with state participation is a party to a services or supply contract, the licensing requirements applicable to the other contracting party may be assessed at a heightened standard. This means that the absence of a required licence — or the holding of a licence that does not fully cover the activity as performed for a state-related counterparty — has been treated by courts as a basis for invalidating the underlying contract, withholding payment under completed contracts, and, in a number of instances, referring the matter to the relevant licensing authority for enforcement action.

The key procedural shift is that state-related entities have been permitted, in contested proceedings, to raise the counterparty's licensing position as a substantive defence against payment claims. This marks a departure from earlier practice in which licensing non-compliance was more typically treated as an administrative matter handled separately from the civil enforcement of a contract.

"Russian courts have moved from treating a counterparty's licensing position as an administrative footnote to treating it as a substantive contract defence — a shift that foreign companies doing business with state enterprises need to price into their compliance review." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

If your company holds contracts with Russian state-related entities and you have questions about your licensing position, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which foreign companies and subsidiaries are most affected?

The impact of this development is not uniform across sectors. The judicial trend is most pronounced in industries where Russian law imposes activity-specific licensing requirements and where state participation in counterparty entities is structurally common. Based on available case law trends through Q1 2026, the sectors presenting the greatest exposure are: energy and utilities infrastructure, construction and engineering services, information technology and communications, pharmaceutical supply and distribution, and transport and logistics services involving federal infrastructure.

Foreign companies operating in Russia through a local subsidiary or joint venture should note that the licence is assessed by reference to the Russian legal entity performing the activity. Where the Russian subsidiary holds the licence and the foreign parent is involved in the operational delivery of the service under an intragroup arrangement, courts have shown willingness to look through the contractual structure to assess whether the licensed entity is genuinely the performing party. Intragroup arrangements that effectively route regulated activities through an unlicensed foreign entity are at heightened risk of challenge.

For companies that supply services to Russian state-related entities through a non-Russian contracting entity — a structure used historically for efficiency and consolidation — the threshold question is now whether the Russian courts will, on the particular facts, characterise the non-Russian entity as the relevant performer. The prevailing approach suggests courts will do so where the Russian counterparty is a state enterprise and where the subject matter of the contract corresponds to a licensed activity category under Russian law.

It is equally relevant for foreign creditors and investors who hold receivables arising from contracts with Russian state-related entities. Where the debtor raises a licensing defence in enforcement proceedings, the creditor must be in a position to demonstrate licensing compliance at the time of performance — not only at the time of the claim. Under Russian limitation period rules, this creates a retrospective compliance requirement with a window that in-house counsel frequently underestimate. Foreign companies that cannot demonstrate continuous licensing compliance throughout the performance period may find that a Russian state-related entity is able to resist a payment claim on grounds that would not be available to a private counterparty under most foreign legal systems.

For in-house counsel assessing legacy contracts with Russian state-related entities, request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should foreign companies do now?

The immediate compliance priority is a structured review of all active and recently completed contracts with Russian state-related counterparties. The review should assess three questions. First, does the Russian entity performing the relevant activity hold a current, appropriately scoped industry licence for that activity as performed — not as described in the contract title? Second, does any intragroup arrangement create an arguable basis for treating the licensed entity as other than the genuine performer? Third, for completed contracts where payment disputes are live or anticipated, is there documentary evidence of licensing compliance throughout the performance period?

For foreign companies that are members of the EAEU or have subsidiaries operating across CIS jurisdictions alongside their Russian operations, an additional consideration arises. Russian courts have, in some cases, applied Russian industry licensing requirements to activities partly performed in other EAEU member states when the contract is governed by Russian law and the counterparty is a Russian state entity. The EAEU dimension does not insulate a foreign or cross-border performer from Russian licensing requirements if the relevant activity is treated as having been performed within Russian jurisdiction.

Our Regulatory & Licensing practice advises foreign companies on mapping their Russian licensing exposure against current court practice and preparing the documentary record for any enforcement or contract dispute scenario. For background on the substantive licensing requirements across regulated sectors, our practical guide to industry licensing requirements in Russia sets out the framework by sector. A related analysis covering industry licensing requirements in Russia — a compliance overview addresses the threshold questions for foreign entities.

Where the review identifies a current licence gap or an arguable structural deficiency, the practical remediation path — whether through licence application, intragroup restructuring, or contractual documentation — depends on the sector, the specific counterparty type, and the stage of the commercial relationship. Early-stage remediation, before a dispute is commenced, preserves options that become unavailable once a state-related counterparty has initiated proceedings. Our Matters record includes mandates advising foreign companies at both the pre-dispute and active proceedings stage of licensing-related enforcement by state enterprise counterparties.

§ IV. Open questions — where court interpretation remains unsettled

Two questions remain without consistent resolution across Russian courts. The first is the standard of review applicable when a company holds a valid licence but the licensed scope is argued to be narrower than the activity as actually performed. Courts in different circuits have applied materially different standards, ranging from a formal assessment of the licence text to a substantive inquiry into whether the performed activity fell within the spirit of the licensed category. Foreign companies in sectors where licence categories are broadly drafted should not assume that formal licence holding resolves all exposure.

The second open question concerns the position of foreign companies that held a licence through a Russian subsidiary that has since been wound down or transferred. Where a payment claim arises after the subsidiary's liquidation, it is not yet settled whether the licensing defence can be raised retroactively by the state counterparty in a claim brought by the foreign parent as successor to the commercial relationship. The direction of arbitrazh court reasoning on successor liability in licensing contexts, while not uniform, has been moving toward a more expansive position — creating additional risk for foreign companies that restructured their Russian operations without full resolution of outstanding state-entity contracts.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on industry licensing in 2025–2026? A: Courts moved from treating licensing compliance as a standalone administrative matter to treating it as a substantive defence in civil proceedings. Where a state-related entity is a party, courts have held that the other contracting party's licensing position is directly relevant to the validity and enforceability of the underlying contract. This applies at both the payment enforcement and contract validity stages of proceedings.

Q: Which types of foreign companies are most affected by this development? A: Foreign companies most directly affected are those whose Russian subsidiaries or joint ventures supply services or goods to state-owned enterprises, federal or regional unitary enterprises, or entities with material state participation. The impact is most significant in sectors with mandatory activity licensing: energy infrastructure, construction and engineering, IT and communications, pharmaceutical distribution, and transport logistics. Companies using non-Russian contracting entities for Russian state-entity business face heightened structural exposure.

Q: What should foreign companies do now in light of this development? A: The immediate step is a licensing compliance audit covering all active and recent contracts with Russian state-related counterparties. The audit should confirm that the performing Russian entity holds a current, correctly scoped licence; that intragroup arrangements do not create an arguable unlicensed-performer argument; and that documentary evidence of licensing compliance throughout the performance period is preserved. Where gaps are identified, remediation is significantly easier before a dispute is filed than after proceedings have commenced.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry