Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian arbitrazh court clarifies Article 61.3 preferential transaction clawbacks under Russian law: key takeaways

Stanislav Lastovsky · February 2026 · 6 min read

Russian courts tighten the Article 61.3 preferential clawback test. Key takeaways for foreign creditors in Russian insolvency. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign creditors active in Russian insolvency proceedings over recent years, one question recurs with particular urgency: when a payment or security interest received before the debtor's bankruptcy filing can be set aside as preferential, and what standard Russian arbitrazh courts now apply when assessing that question. A recent ruling from the cassation tier of the arbitrazh court system has sharpened that analysis materially — and the implications for foreign creditors holding claims against Russian debtors are directly practical.

Background

The clawback mechanism under Russian insolvency legislation — specifically the provision commonly referred to as Article 61.3 — allows a bankruptcy administrator to challenge transactions completed by the debtor in the period preceding the filing date. The rule targets transactions that confer a preference on one creditor over others: a repayment of a loan, a transfer of assets in satisfaction of a debt, or the grant of a pledge or mortgage at a time when competing creditor claims were already present. The look-back period depends on the nature of the transaction and the administrator's basis for challenge, but typically extends to one month for straightforward preference cases and to six months where the counterparty is shown to have known of the debtor's financial difficulties.

The proceeding giving rise to the ruling under discussion involved a trade creditor — a counterparty that had received payment of an overdue receivable in the months immediately before its customer entered formal insolvency. The bankruptcy administrator challenged that repayment on preferential grounds. The lower instance courts disagreed on the applicable test, and the case reached the cassation court for resolution. The legal question at the centre of the dispute was whether the counterparty's knowledge — or constructive knowledge — of the debtor's insolvency was a required element of the Article 61.3 preferential claim, or whether the mere fact of preference (payment to one creditor while others remained unpaid) was sufficient for the transaction to be set aside.

The decision

The cassation court issued a clarification of material significance. On the core question of knowledge, the court drew a careful distinction between two categories of preferential transaction challenge. For challenges brought on the basis that the transaction was completed within the shorter look-back window, the court confirmed that knowledge of the debtor's financial position is not a required element: the preference itself — the fact that the creditor received satisfaction while other creditors did not — is sufficient to ground the challenge. For challenges involving the extended look-back window, the court affirmed that the administrator must establish that the counterparty either knew or should have known, at the time of receiving the payment or security, that the debtor was insolvent or facing insolvency.

The ruling further addressed the evidentiary standard. The court held that a creditor wishing to resist a clawback on the basis that it lacked knowledge must do more than assert ignorance; it must demonstrate that the debtor's public-facing conduct — its financial disclosures, payment behaviour, and commercial representations — gave no reasonable grounds to suspect financial distress. Crucially, the court indicated that creditors in ongoing commercial relationships with the debtor are held to a higher standard of awareness than arm's-length counterparties receiving a single payment.

"What this ruling does is clarify that the longer the commercial relationship, the less credible a claim of ignorance becomes — Russian courts are now explicitly raising the bar for counterparties seeking to defend preferential transactions on the basis of good faith." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

If your company has received payment from a Russian counterparty now in insolvency proceedings, the preferential clawback risk should be assessed before the administrator issues a formal challenge — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign creditors

For foreign trade creditors and institutional investors holding claims in Russian insolvency proceedings, this ruling has three direct consequences. First, the distinction between the two look-back windows is now sharper and more consequential. A creditor who received payment within the shorter period faces a strict-liability style clawback exposure — the administrator need not prove that the creditor knew anything about the debtor's condition. This is particularly relevant for foreign creditors in supply-chain relationships who received payment in the ordinary course and may have had no reason to interrogate their customer's financial health.

Second, the elevated knowledge standard for the extended window places a practical evidential burden on the creditor, not just the administrator. Foreign creditors who wish to defend a clawback claim on the basis of good faith will need to assemble contemporaneous evidence of what they knew — or what they could reasonably have been expected to know — at the time of receipt. Email correspondence, commercial meeting records, credit assessments, and financial statement reviews become relevant defence materials. Foreign creditors who do not document their commercial due diligence as a matter of course are more exposed than they may realise.

Third, the ruling signals a broader tendency in Russian arbitrazh courts toward tightening the procedural protections available to preference-payment recipients. Creditors who delay engaging Russian insolvency counsel after learning of a counterparty's bankruptcy filing risk losing the opportunity to prepare an adequate defence before the administrator's challenge crystallises. Under Russian insolvency legislation, administrators may bring clawback claims throughout the proceedings — a window that, in complex matters, may remain open for several years.

For creditors holding distressed Russian assets, the practical implication is this: a payment received in the months before a counterparty's bankruptcy filing is not safe simply because it was received in the ordinary course of business. Russian courts are now explicit that ordinariness is a mitigating but not determinative factor, and that an ongoing commercial relationship is itself a source of constructive knowledge. Early legal review — before an administrator's challenge is formally filed — remains the most effective means of assessing and limiting preferential clawback exposure.

Creditors who have received prior payments from a Russian entity now in insolvency should not treat the question as one for later — the window for preparing a substantive defence is limited. Discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign creditors with claims in Russian insolvency proceedings?

A: The ruling sharpens the existing two-limb preferential transaction framework under Russian insolvency legislation. It confirms that, for transactions within the shorter look-back period, the administrator need not prove creditor knowledge — the preference itself is sufficient. For the extended period, it raises the evidential bar for knowledge-based defences, particularly for creditors in ongoing commercial relationships with the debtor. Foreign creditors should treat this as a reason to obtain a clawback risk assessment at the earliest stage of any Russian counterparty insolvency.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign creditors who received payments or security from a Russian counterparty in the period before its bankruptcy filing should take three steps without delay. First, identify whether the relevant payment falls within the shorter or extended look-back window under Russian insolvency legislation. Second, gather contemporaneous evidence of the commercial relationship and the creditor's knowledge position at the time of receipt. Third, engage Russian insolvency counsel before the bankruptcy administrator formally files a clawback claim — the pre-challenge period is the most effective time to assess and structure a defence.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry