Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Recent Russian judicial practice on cross-border coordination with UK and German counsel in Russian insolvency — commentary

Stanislav Lastovsky · February 2026 · 8 min read

Russian courts are increasingly defining how foreign insolvency counsel may engage. What the emerging practice means for creditors. Make an enquiry.

In the past two years of advising foreign creditor groups in Russian insolvency proceedings, one pattern has become increasingly clear: the question of how UK and German insolvency counsel interact with Russian arbitrazh courts is no longer a theoretical one. A series of decisions handed down by Russian arbitrazh courts — including at the cassation level — has begun to define, in meaningful detail, what cross-border coordination between foreign insolvency practitioners and Russian proceedings actually looks like in practice, and what it does not. For foreign creditors holding distressed Russian assets, or pursuing debt recovery through Russian insolvency proceedings, understanding where these decisions draw the line is now an operational priority.

Background

The cases that form the basis of this commentary arose from insolvency proceedings involving Russian debtor entities with creditor groups that included UK-based institutional creditors represented by English solicitors and a German trade creditor group represented by German Rechtsanwälte. In each instance, foreign counsel sought to participate in, or to support, the Russian insolvency process in some coordinated capacity — submitting documentation, asserting claims based on English-law security arrangements or German-law pledge instruments, and in one instance, requesting that the Russian arbitrazh court take account of parallel restructuring steps already under way in a foreign jurisdiction.

The legal questions raised were not novel in isolation. Russian insolvency legislation has long addressed the registration of foreign creditor claims, the evidentiary requirements for foreign-law instruments, and the standing of creditors in the creditors' meeting. What made these cases significant was their procedural context: the explicit involvement of foreign law firms as coordinating advisers, the documentary submissions prepared in multiple languages with legalised translations, and — most materially — the requests that the Russian court acknowledge the existence and status of foreign insolvency or restructuring proceedings affecting the same debtor group.

The debtors in these matters were Russian legal entities. None of the proceedings involved a cross-border insolvency mechanism of the kind contemplated by the UNCITRAL Model Law, which Russia has not adopted. The courts were therefore applying Russian insolvency legislation within its existing domestic framework, without any formal treaty basis for recognising foreign proceedings.

The decision

The arbitrazh courts' response to these coordinated submissions was neither uniform nor, in some respects, predictable. On the core question of foreign creditor standing, the courts affirmed, as they have consistently done, that foreign creditors are entitled to register claims and participate in Russian insolvency proceedings on the same formal basis as Russian creditors — subject to documentary requirements, certified translations, and compliance with Russian procedural timelines. This position is well established and was not materially advanced by these decisions.

The more significant aspect of the rulings concerned the courts' treatment of foreign-law security instruments. In one matter, the court declined to recognise the priority position claimed by a creditor under an English-law pledge, on the basis that the relevant assets were located in Russia and the pledge had not been registered in accordance with Russian law. The court acknowledged the English-law instrument in its reasoning but held that its effect in the Russian insolvency was governed by Russian law, not by the law chosen by the parties in the original security agreement. This is consistent with the general approach of Russian courts to in rem rights over Russian-sited assets, but the explicit engagement with the English-law document — and the court's willingness to analyse it on its own terms before reaching its conclusion — represents a degree of cross-border analytical engagement that has not always been present in earlier decisions.

In the matter involving parallel proceedings in a foreign jurisdiction, the court was more circumspect. It declined to stay the Russian proceedings or to defer to any outcome reached in the foreign forum, and it expressly noted that Russian insolvency legislation does not provide a mechanism for recognising foreign insolvency proceedings. However — and this is the point that has attracted attention among practitioners — the court did not disregard the foreign proceedings entirely. It acknowledged their existence as a factual matter and, in assessing the overall financial position of the debtor group, treated documentation produced in the foreign proceedings as admissible evidence of the debtor's assets and liabilities, subject to standard evidentiary requirements. The result is not recognition. But it is something more than complete indifference.

"What these decisions signal is that Russian arbitrazh courts are developing a working vocabulary for cross-border insolvency fact patterns — not a framework for recognition, but a readiness to engage with foreign proceedings as a factual reality, provided the documentary groundwork is correctly laid." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

For creditors with claims in Russian insolvency proceedings where foreign counsel are involved — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For UK and German creditors — and for the law firms advising them — these decisions offer both encouragement and a clear limit. The encouragement is that Russian arbitrazh courts are demonstrably willing to engage with sophisticated cross-border submissions, to analyse foreign-law instruments on their own terms, and to treat foreign proceedings as evidentially relevant. The limit is equally clear: none of this translates into the recognition of foreign proceedings, the portability of foreign security priorities, or any derogation from Russian law as the governing framework for the Russian insolvency.

The practical implication for creditors pursuing debt recovery through Russian insolvency proceedings is that the quality and preparation of cross-border submissions matters considerably. Courts that are willing to engage analytically with English-law pledge documents or German-law instrument analyses will also notice when those documents are inadequately translated, incorrectly legalised, or submitted outside the procedural windows Russian law prescribes. Foreign creditors who instruct local Russian counsel only after their claim has already been filed — or after procedural deadlines have passed — will find that the courts' analytical openness does not extend to remedying procedural failures.

The decisions also have a specific implication for how UK and German counsel structure their coordination with Russian practitioners. The courts' receptiveness to coordinated documentary submissions appears to be conditional on those submissions being routed through, and verified by, Russian counsel who can attest to their conformity with Russian procedural requirements. Submissions that bypass local counsel — or that seek to replicate foreign procedural conventions in a Russian forum — have fared less well. Foreign creditors who delay establishing a confirmed Russian counsel relationship risk arriving at a point in the proceedings where the window for meaningful participation has narrowed materially. Under Russian insolvency legislation, the deadline for registering claims in the first creditors' meeting is fixed and does not bend to the complexity of cross-border coordination.

The Restructuring & Insolvency practice at Vetrov & Partners acts exclusively on the creditor side in Russian insolvency proceedings and has direct experience coordinating with UK and German law firms on matters of this kind. Further analysis of the regulatory framework governing foreign creditor participation is set out in our regulatory update on cross-border coordination and in our briefing on foreign creditors and cross-border coordination. A record of representative creditor-side matters is available at /matters/.

If you are advising a foreign creditor with a claim in Russian insolvency proceedings — speak to our team to discuss how cross-border coordination is handled in practice: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The decisions mark a shift in how Russian arbitrazh courts engage with the cross-border dimension of insolvency proceedings involving foreign creditor groups. Prior to this line of decisions, courts tended to treat foreign-law instruments and foreign proceedings as either irrelevant or admissible only in narrow evidential terms. The recent decisions indicate a greater analytical willingness: courts have examined English-law security documents on their own terms before applying Russian law to determine their effect, and have admitted documentary evidence generated in foreign insolvency proceedings as relevant to the factual picture of the debtor's position. This does not create a recognition regime — Russian insolvency legislation provides none — but it does mean that well-prepared cross-border submissions, coordinated through local counsel, are more likely to receive substantive engagement than to be summarily set aside.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign creditors and their advisers should take three practical steps. First, establish a confirmed Russian counsel relationship before the insolvency filing occurs or, at the very latest, immediately upon becoming aware of it — the deadlines for registering claims in Russian insolvency proceedings are statutory and cannot be extended by judicial discretion. Second, ensure that all foreign-law security instruments and evidentiary documentation are prepared for Russian court submission from the outset: correctly translated, appropriately certified, and verified by Russian counsel for procedural conformity. Third, structure the coordination between foreign counsel and Russian practitioners so that all submissions to the Russian court are routed through local counsel — courts have shown less receptiveness to submissions that seek to replicate foreign procedural conventions directly. For creditors already in proceedings, an immediate review of filed claim documentation against current Russian court expectations is advisable.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry