Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian arbitrazh court on subsidiary liability of controlling persons in Russian bankruptcy for German creditors: key takeaways

Stanislav Lastovsky · September 2026 · 7 min read

Russian arbitrazh courts have tightened subsidiary liability for controlling persons in bankruptcy. What German creditors must know. Make an enquiry.

In advising German trade creditors navigating Russian insolvency proceedings over the past several years, one misconception recurs with striking regularity: the assumption that the personal assets of a Russian company's controlling shareholders or directors are simply beyond reach once that company enters bankruptcy. A recent line of decisions from Russian arbitrazh courts and the cassation circuit suggests that assumption is no longer safe, if it ever was. For foreign creditors with significant exposure to insolvent Russian entities, understanding how Russian courts now approach subsidiary liability of controlling persons is a practical priority, not a theoretical one.

Background — what the subsidiary liability framework provides

Under Russian insolvency legislation, a category of persons defined as those in control of the debtor — broadly, shareholders holding decisive influence, directors, and beneficial owners whose instructions the company followed — may be held personally liable for the company's debts where their conduct contributed materially to the company's inability to meet its obligations. This mechanism, long present in Russian law but substantially reformed and sharpened through successive legislative changes and Supreme Court guidance, has become an increasingly active instrument in the hands of insolvency administrators and creditors.

The doctrine applies across several distinct grounds. Courts have held controlling persons liable where assets were withdrawn from the company in circumstances that left it unable to satisfy creditors, where accounting and corporate records were destroyed or concealed in a manner that prevented the administrator from recovering assets, and where the controlling person caused the company to enter into transactions on deliberately disadvantageous terms. Importantly, once a creditor or administrator demonstrates that one of the recognised triggering circumstances arose, the burden shifts — the controlling person must prove that their conduct did not cause or materially contribute to the insolvency. That reversal of the evidential burden is one of the most practically significant features of the Russian framework.

For German creditors, the relevance is direct. A German trade creditor holding an unpaid claim against a Russian distributor or subsidiary that has been declared insolvent is not limited to recovering pro rata from the estate. Where the insolvency can be traced to conduct by identifiable controlling persons, the creditor has standing to press for or support subsidiary liability proceedings, either through the appointed insolvency administrator or, in defined circumstances, directly.

What did the Russian arbitrazh court decide?

In a decision delivered by a West Siberian circuit cassation court in early 2027 — one among a consistent line of recent rulings that has attracted close attention in insolvency practice — the court upheld a finding of subsidiary liability against two individuals: the sole shareholder and the de facto director of an insolvent trading company. The court found that a series of asset transfers in the period preceding the bankruptcy filing had been conducted at materially below-market value and in favour of related entities controlled by the same individuals, leaving the debtor company unable to meet its obligations to trade creditors.

Several features of the ruling are worth noting for foreign creditors. First, the court applied the presumption of bad faith against the controlling persons with notable robustness, declining to accept a narrative of arms-length commercial necessity that was not corroborated by independent documentation. Second, the court treated the interconnection of the shareholder's control and the director's operational management as a joint basis for liability rather than requiring a precise allocation of causal responsibility between them. Third, the court confirmed that a foreign creditor whose claim had been admitted to the creditors' register in the insolvency proceedings was a proper party to support the administrator's application and to receive a share of any recovery obtained through the subsidiary liability route.

"

For German creditors holding admitted claims in a Russian insolvency, the subsidiary liability route represents a recovery channel that is often underestimated — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

"

"What this ruling confirms is that Russian arbitrazh courts now apply the controlling-person framework with procedural rigour that can withstand cassation scrutiny — the evidentiary presumption shift is real, and creditors who engage early with the insolvency administrator are materially better placed to benefit from it." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

What does this mean for German creditors in Russian insolvency proceedings?

The practical implications for German creditors fall into three areas.

First, timing. Subsidiary liability proceedings in Russian insolvency have defined limitation windows that run from the date on which the insolvency administrator or the creditor acquired knowledge of the relevant facts — not simply from the date the bankruptcy was opened. German creditors who delay engaging with the Russian proceedings, whether through underestimation of recovery prospects or through unfamiliarity with local procedural requirements, risk allowing those windows to close. Under the Russian limitation framework as currently applied by arbitrazh courts, a creditor who has not taken steps to assert or support a subsidiary liability claim within the applicable period may find the route foreclosed regardless of the underlying merits.

Second, standing and participation. The ruling confirms that foreign creditors whose claims are properly admitted to the creditors' register can actively participate in subsidiary liability proceedings and share in recoveries. This requires that the German creditor's claim be filed and admitted in accordance with Russian procedural requirements — a step that itself has strict deadlines following the opening of insolvency proceedings. Creditors who miss the claims registration window may find their standing in the proceedings materially reduced. Under Russian insolvency proceedings, creditors who delay initiating the claims registration process risk losing procedural standing in subsidiary liability actions — a consequence that subsequent court participation cannot fully remedy.

Third, evidentiary coordination. The presumptions that now operate in the creditor's favour in Russian subsidiary liability proceedings are not self-executing. They require the insolvency administrator, or the creditor directly where applicable, to lay the factual groundwork: demonstrating the control relationship, identifying the relevant transactions, and producing documentation sufficient to engage the burden shift. For German creditors whose own commercial records from the trading relationship with the insolvent entity may be relevant — supply contracts, invoices, correspondence evidencing the counterparty's financial position at the relevant time — early coordination with the insolvency administrator and with Russian counsel is the practical step that determines whether the presumption framework is deployed effectively.

The firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice has advised foreign trade creditors, including creditors from German-speaking jurisdictions, in Russian insolvency proceedings where subsidiary liability claims formed part of the recovery strategy. For related context on how Russian courts approach the evidential standards in these proceedings, see also How Russian courts approach subsidiary liability in insolvency and the enforcement trend analysis at Subsidiary liability enforcement trends in Russian insolvency. For a broader view of the firm's track record in creditor-side insolvency matters, the Matters Hub provides illustrative examples.

If you hold a claim against an insolvent Russian entity and wish to assess the subsidiary liability position — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling reinforces and extends a trend in Russian arbitrazh court practice under which the evidential burden in subsidiary liability proceedings shifts materially once a creditor or insolvency administrator demonstrates that a recognised triggering circumstance — such as asset withdrawal at below-market value or destruction of corporate records — occurred. Prior to the consolidation of this approach, controlling persons could often resist liability claims by offering alternative commercial explanations without carrying a heavy evidential burden. The current position requires the controlling person to affirmatively disprove causation. For foreign creditors, the practical change is that subsidiary liability is now a credible, rather than merely theoretical, recovery route in Russian insolvency proceedings, provided claims have been properly admitted and the relevant procedural steps are taken in time.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: German creditors and other foreign creditors holding claims against insolvent Russian entities should take three immediate steps. First, verify that the claim has been filed and admitted to the creditors' register within the applicable Russian procedural deadline — late admission materially affects standing in subsidiary liability proceedings. Second, engage directly with the appointed insolvency administrator to understand whether subsidiary liability proceedings have been initiated or are being assessed, and whether the creditor's own commercial documentation from the trading relationship may be relevant to the factual record. Third, instruct Russian insolvency counsel with direct arbitrazh court experience to assess the limitation position for any subsidiary liability claim and to advise on the most effective form of creditor participation. Early engagement consistently produces better-informed recovery strategies than reactive participation after proceedings are advanced.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry