Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian arbitrazh court on cross-border insolvency recognition in Russia under Article 61.3 of the Insolvency Law: key takeaways

Stanislav Lastovsky · October 2026 · 6 min read

Russian courts have clarified Article 61.3 in cross-border insolvency proceedings. Essential reading for foreign creditors. Make an enquiry.

Advising foreign creditors in Russian insolvency matters over recent years, one question has recurred with growing urgency: when a Russian debtor enters insolvency and an insolvency administrator brings an avoidance claim targeting a payment made to a foreign counterparty, does the cross-border element of that transaction afford the foreign creditor any protection — or does the preferential transaction avoidance mechanism under Russian insolvency legislation operate identically regardless of where the creditor is domiciled? A recent decision by a Russian arbitrazh court has brought that question into sharper relief, with significant implications for foreign trade creditors and institutional investors holding claims against Russian entities.

Background

Cross-border insolvency recognition in Russia sits in an uncomfortable legal position. Russia has not adopted the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency, and there is no dedicated bilateral treaty framework that systematically governs the recognition of foreign insolvency proceedings in Russian courts, with the exception of limited arrangements within the CIS and EAEU frameworks. In practice, this means that when a Russian entity enters insolvency, the Russian insolvency administrator holds broad powers to review transactions completed in the period before the filing, and to bring avoidance claims targeting payments — including payments made to foreign creditors under foreign-law governed contracts.

The matter that prompted this commentary arose from precisely that situation. A foreign trade creditor — domiciled outside Russia and holding a receivable under a foreign-law supply agreement — had received payment from what later became the Russian debtor entity. That payment was made within the statutory look-back window under Russian insolvency legislation. The insolvency administrator subsequently brought a preferential avoidance claim, arguing that the payment had discharged a pre-existing debt and thereby conferred a preference on the foreign creditor over other members of the creditor community. The central legal question before the arbitrazh court was whether the preferential avoidance provision applied to the transaction, and if so, what standard of knowledge would be attributed to a foreign creditor operating under a foreign-law contract.

The decision

The court upheld the avoidance claim. In its reasoning, the court confirmed that the preferential transaction avoidance mechanism under Russian insolvency legislation is not confined to domestically domiciled creditors or to transactions governed by Russian law. The governing principle, as the court framed it, is the debtor's insolvency estate — and any transaction that diminishes or prejudices the ratable distribution of that estate to the general body of creditors falls within the ambit of the avoidance rules, regardless of the foreign domicile of the recipient or the foreign law applicable to the underlying contract.

On the knowledge standard, the court applied the test that has become the prevailing approach in Russian arbitrazh practice: the question is not whether the foreign creditor had actual knowledge of the debtor's financial difficulties at the time of payment, but whether, in all the circumstances, a creditor in that position ought to have known. The court held that the terms of the commercial relationship — specifically, payment delays, partial payments in the preceding period, and the circumstances of the final settlement — were sufficient to establish constructive knowledge.

"The court's application of a constructive knowledge standard to a foreign creditor receiving payment under a foreign-law contract is the most significant element of this decision — it removes a defence that foreign counterparties have sometimes assumed was available to them." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

The court declined to engage with the creditor's argument that recognition of the avoidance claim would be inconsistent with the foreign law governing the underlying contract. The court's position was that the avoidance mechanism is a matter of Russian insolvency law and operates independently of the governing law of the transaction being avoided.

For foreign creditors and their advisers with live matters pending in Russian insolvency proceedings, the implications of this reasoning are immediate.

If you are a foreign creditor facing an avoidance claim in a Russian insolvency — or monitoring a Russian counterparty for insolvency risk — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

The decision reinforces a position that the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice has flagged in previous commentary: foreign creditors should not assume that the cross-border character of a transaction, or the foreign governing law of the underlying contract, insulates a payment from avoidance in Russian insolvency proceedings. The avoidance mechanism, as interpreted by Russian arbitrazh courts, is applied as a matter of Russian public law with extraterritorial reach over assets and transactions connected to the Russian debtor's estate.

For creditors holding claims against Russian debtors — or monitoring counterparties for signs of financial distress — the practical consequences are threefold. First, any payment received from a Russian counterparty within the look-back period (which extends to one month, six months, or three years depending on the type of avoidance claim) should be assessed against the avoidance criteria at the time of receipt, not retrospectively when an administrator is appointed. Second, the constructive knowledge standard means that commercial signals of distress — payment deferrals, requests to restructure payment schedules, partial settlements — will be treated as notice, irrespective of whether the creditor formally acknowledged the debtor's difficulties. Third, the argument that a foreign-law contract immunises the payment from avoidance is, on the basis of this decision, unlikely to succeed before a Russian arbitrazh court.

Foreign creditors who have already received payment from entities now in Russian insolvency proceedings should take immediate steps to assess their exposure. Under the Russian insolvency framework, avoidance claims may be brought by the administrator throughout the duration of the insolvency procedure, and a successful claim will require the creditor to return the avoided payment to the estate — moving the creditor's position from a paid counterparty to an unsecured creditor in the queue for distribution. That shift, depending on the size of the estate and the composition of the creditor body, can represent a material recovery risk.

Practitioners advising foreign clients on cross-border insolvency recognition in Russia should treat this decision as a prompt to review current exposures, regardless of whether an avoidance claim has yet been filed.

To assess your position as a foreign creditor in a Russian insolvency — or to discuss a matter in confidence — contact us: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign creditors involved in Russian insolvency proceedings?

A: The ruling confirms that Russian arbitrazh courts apply the preferential transaction avoidance mechanism to payments received by foreign creditors under foreign-law contracts, without treating the foreign governing law of the underlying agreement as a bar to the claim. More significantly, the court applied a constructive knowledge standard — meaning that a foreign creditor who received commercial signals of the debtor's financial difficulty, such as payment deferrals or partial settlements, will be treated as having known of the debtor's insolvency risk at the time of payment. Creditors who had assumed that the foreign character of the transaction offered protection should reassess that position.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign companies that have received payment from Russian counterparties within the past three years — and where those counterparties are now in, or approaching, insolvency — should conduct an immediate review of those payments against the Russian avoidance criteria. The review should assess: the timing of the payment relative to any insolvency filing; whether the commercial relationship showed signs of debtor distress before payment; and the likely characterisation of the payment under Russian insolvency legislation. Where exposure is identified, early engagement with Russian insolvency counsel is advisable — both to assess the strength of any avoidance claim and to prepare a creditor's position within the insolvency proceedings should the payment be challenged.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry