Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian judicial practice on bankruptcy administrator duties and creditor oversight in Russia for US creditors — commentary

Stanislav Lastovsky · January 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts clarify what creditors can demand of bankruptcy administrators. Key rulings affecting US creditors in Russia. Make an enquiry.

When a US creditor discovers that its Russian counterparty has entered insolvency proceedings, the central operational question quickly shifts from whether a claim exists to how effectively it can be enforced against a bankruptcy administrator who may have competing loyalties, limited resources, and uncertain obligations. Russian courts have been developing their supervisory approach to administrator conduct in creditor-facing situations, and a series of recent rulings clarifies — with greater precision than was previously available — the threshold at which creditor oversight rights become actionable, and the conditions under which administrator failures create grounds for challenge, removal, or damages claims. For US creditors navigating Russian insolvency proceedings without in-country representation, understanding these developments is a prerequisite to recovering anything at all.

What is a bankruptcy administrator's duty to creditors under Russian insolvency law?

The position of the bankruptcy administrator — the арбитражный управляющий — is structurally ambiguous under Russian insolvency legislation. The administrator is appointed by the court, nominated in practice by the creditor or creditors who hold the relevant majority at the first creditor meeting, and formally subject to obligations running simultaneously to the insolvent estate, to secured and unsecured creditors, and to the regulatory authority that licenses insolvency practitioners.

In the context of creditor oversight, the key obligations courts have consistently identified are: the duty to maintain the creditor registry in an accurate and timely manner; the duty to report on estate assets and on the progress of realisation; the duty to act independently when managing claims against third parties connected to the debtor; and the duty to provide substantive responses — not merely formal acknowledgements — when creditor queries concern potential asset dissipation or preferential transactions.

The legal question at the heart of recent judicial practice is whether these duties are enforceable as individual creditor rights, or whether they function only as regulatory obligations enforceable by the courts and the supervisory body for insolvency practitioners. For US creditors whose claims are registered but who hold no seat on the creditor committee, this distinction has practical consequences: it determines whether a creditor acting alone can compel an administrator to produce documents, account for specific assets, or justify a decision not to pursue an avoidance claim.

If your claim is registered in a Russian insolvency proceeding and you are uncertain whether the administrator is acting in the estate's — and your — interest, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

The decision

In a decision handed down in the second half of 2025, a cassation court of the arbitrazh system examined a challenge brought by a foreign trade creditor against a bankruptcy administrator's failure to pursue a set of preferential transfer claims against parties connected to the debtor's former management. The administrator had acknowledged, in correspondence with the creditor committee, that the transfers appeared to fall within the statutory claw-back period and that documentation existed to support a challenge. The administrator nonetheless declined to initiate proceedings, citing the cost of litigation relative to the probable recovery.

The court found that the administrator's cost-benefit analysis, while permissible in principle, was required to be conducted transparently and to be disclosed to registered creditors in a form that enabled them to challenge the assessment before the creditor meeting. Conducting the analysis internally and communicating only the conclusion — without the underlying reasoning or the documentary evidence reviewed — was held to be insufficient. The court drew a distinction between the administrator's discretion over the ultimate decision and the administrator's obligation to make the decision-making process accountable to creditors. On that basis, the administrator's conduct was found to be in breach of the creditor oversight standard, and the ruling opened a path for the creditor to seek damages from the administrator personally.

"This ruling materially raises the bar for how administrators document decisions not to pursue avoidance claims — and gives individual creditors a procedural foothold they did not reliably have before." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

The court also addressed the question of which creditors have standing to bring such a challenge. The administrator had argued that the claimant, as a creditor holding less than ten per cent of the total registered claims, lacked the procedural standing to challenge administrator conduct independently of the creditor committee. The court rejected this argument, holding that Russian insolvency legislation confers an individual right to challenge administrator actions on any registered creditor where the challenge relates to a breach of the information and accountability duties specifically — as distinct from challenges to substantive commercial decisions, where higher threshold requirements apply.

What does this ruling mean for US creditors in Russian insolvency proceedings?

The practical implications for US creditors with registered claims in Russian proceedings run across three areas: information access, creditor committee strategy, and the conditions for personal liability of the administrator.

On information access, the ruling reinforces that creditors do not need to await the creditor meeting to demand transparency from the administrator. Where the administrator has identified a potential avoidance claim or asset recovery opportunity and has communicated about it — even informally — registered creditors can request the documentary basis for any subsequent decision not to act. US creditors who have been receiving only high-level progress reports should consider whether more substantive disclosure requests are now available to them.

On creditor committee strategy, the threshold finding on individual standing does not eliminate the value of committee participation. Creditors who hold a sufficient proportion of registered claims to influence committee composition retain procedurally stronger tools — both for compelling administrator action and for initiating removal proceedings. US creditors with significant claims who have not yet sought representation on the creditor committee risk losing practical leverage over the administration's direction. Under Russian insolvency legislation, the window for influencing committee composition narrows materially as proceedings progress, and creditors who delay past the early stages of the process frequently find that this lever is no longer available.

In a recent matter, the firm acted for a European trade creditor in a mid-sized Russian industrial insolvency, assisting in a challenge to the administrator's asset realisation strategy that resulted in a revised distribution schedule improving the creditor's recovery position. The matter took approximately eleven months from the initial challenge filing to resolution.

On administrator liability, the ruling clarifies that damages claims against an administrator personally — which Russian insolvency practice treats as a remedy of last resort — are not confined to cases of outright fraud or gross negligence. Procedural failures of the kind identified here, where the administrator's conduct fell short of the accountability standard without necessarily involving bad faith, can support a damages claim if the creditor can demonstrate a causal link between the breach and a reduction in recovery. For US creditors whose claims are being administered, this is a meaningful development: it creates an additional pressure point in negotiations with administrators over disclosure and procedural conduct.

For more on the Restructuring & Insolvency framework and related creditor-side practice, see also Court practice shifts on bankruptcy administrator conduct in Russia and Key risk points in bankruptcy administrator disputes.

If you hold a registered claim in a Russian insolvency proceeding and need to assess whether the administrator's conduct meets the legal standard — or whether a challenge or liability claim is available — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling establishes that a bankruptcy administrator's duty of transparency to registered creditors extends beyond formal reporting obligations to cover the decision-making process underlying significant estate management choices — including the decision not to pursue an avoidance or preferential transfer claim. Previously, administrators had discretion to communicate conclusions without substantiating their reasoning. Courts are now requiring that the basis for such decisions be disclosed in a manner that gives creditors a genuine opportunity to assess and, if warranted, challenge the reasoning. The ruling also clarifies that individual creditors — not only the creditor committee — have standing to raise challenges concerning information and accountability failures, provided their claim is registered in the proceedings.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: US creditors and other foreign companies with registered claims in Russian insolvency proceedings should take two immediate steps. First, review what information the administrator has communicated regarding potential asset recovery actions — avoidance claims, preferential transfer challenges, or third-party liability — and identify whether any decisions not to pursue those actions have been explained or merely announced. Second, assess whether the creditor committee composition gives adequate representation to their interests. The firm advises foreign creditors on both the procedural challenge mechanisms now available following this ruling and on the broader strategy for protecting and advancing claims in Russian insolvency proceedings. For an initial assessment, contact info@vetrovpartners.com.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry