Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian court practice trend: subsidiary liability of controlling persons in Russian bankruptcy — 2026 update

Stanislav Lastovsky · February 2026 · 9 min read

Russian courts tightened subsidiary liability standards for controlling persons. Foreign creditors face new risks and new openings. Make an enquiry.

Over the past several years, Russian arbitrazh courts have progressively expanded the reach of subsidiary liability for controlling persons — known in Russian insolvency practice as KDL (kontroliruyushcheye dolzhnika litso) — making it one of the most consequential developments in distressed assets and Russian insolvency law for foreign creditors. The trajectory accelerated through 2024 and into 2025–2026, with courts consistently holding that the burden of proof on a respondent controlling person is more demanding than previously understood, and that evidential standards for establishing control have widened considerably. For foreign creditors holding claims in Russian bankruptcy proceedings, this shift creates both new enforcement opportunities and heightened exposure for any foreign entity that may itself qualify as a controlling person under Russian insolvency legislation.

What changed in Russian court practice on controlling person liability?

The concept of subsidiary liability for controlling persons is not new to Russian insolvency law — the statutory framework has been in place for some years, and the Supreme Court issued clarifying guidance that courts across Russia were expected to follow. What has changed, and what makes the current period significant, is the manner in which lower-instance arbitrazh courts have applied that framework in practice.

Three interconnected shifts define the 2025–2026 trend.

First, courts have progressively relaxed the threshold for establishing that a respondent qualifies as a "controlling person" in the first instance. The prevailing approach no longer requires formal legal control — direct shareholding at or above the statutory threshold — as the sole qualifying criterion. Courts have consistently found control on the basis of factual influence: instructions given informally, economic dependency relationships, and shared beneficial ownership arrangements. For foreign entities operating through Russian subsidiaries or holding minority stakes in joint ventures, this broadening of the control concept carries direct implications.

Second, once control is established, courts have increasingly applied a presumption of causation between the controlling person's conduct and the debtor's insolvency. The burden of rebutting this presumption falls on the respondent, and Russian courts have raised the evidential bar for that rebuttal substantially. It is no longer sufficient for a controlling person to demonstrate that decisions were commercially reasonable at the time they were taken — courts have required respondents to show, affirmatively, that those decisions did not contribute to the debtor's financial deterioration. In practice, this is a difficult standard to meet without detailed contemporaneous documentation.

Third, and of particular relevance for foreign creditors who are themselves contemplating KDL claims, the time horizon for KDL liability has been interpreted broadly. Transactions and decisions falling within a period of up to three years before the bankruptcy filing may be scrutinised, and courts have shown willingness to draw inferences from a pattern of conduct rather than a single impugned transaction. This is consistent with the general direction of the Supreme Court's guidance but goes further in its practical application than many practitioners anticipated two or three years ago.

"The courts' approach to controlling person liability in 2025–2026 reflects a structural shift: factual control, not formal legal title, is now the operative test in the majority of Russian insolvency proceedings." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

Which foreign creditors and investors are most affected?

The shift in court practice is not uniform in its impact. Its significance varies considerably depending on the foreign creditor's position in the insolvency and its prior relationship with the debtor.

For trade creditors holding unsecured claims against a Russian corporate debtor, the expanded KDL framework is primarily an enforcement opportunity. Where a Russian debtor's insolvency can be linked to decisions made by an identifiable controlling person — a majority shareholder, a dominant beneficial owner, or a holding company that directed the debtor's financial conduct — the insolvency administrator (or, in some circuits, creditors themselves in certain procedural postures) may pursue those persons for the shortfall in the estate. Foreign trade creditors who have historically written off Russian receivables as irrecoverable should consider whether the present court environment makes a KDL claim a viable avenue for recovery. In the firm's experience advising creditors in Siberian and Ural circuit proceedings, the most recoverable situations are those where the controlling person retains identifiable assets in Russia — real property, participatory interests in other entities, or claims against third parties.

For foreign investors holding equity interests in Russian operating companies, the picture is more complex. A foreign shareholder — even one holding a minority stake — that exercised de facto influence over the Russian entity's strategic or financial decisions may, depending on the documented evidence available to an insolvency administrator, face exposure as a KDL respondent. The evidential standards described in § I apply with equal force when the respondent is a foreign entity. Russian arbitrazh courts have not hesitated to issue judgments against foreign respondents in absentia where jurisdiction can be established on the basis of the debtor's registered seat, and there is a body of practice — primarily in the Moscow and Siberian circuits — in which foreign holding companies have been held subsidiarily liable in Russian proceedings.

Foreign distressed investors acquiring Russian debt at a discount should also weigh the KDL landscape carefully before assuming that the debtor's former shareholders or directors are beyond reach. The expanded interpretation of control, and the broad time horizon applied by courts, means that pre-acquisition due diligence on the debtor's governance history is not merely procedural — it is the basis for assessing whether a KDL claim represents a meaningful contribution to the recovery thesis.

For creditors who delay initiating or supporting enforcement proceedings in an active insolvency, the risk of KDL claims becoming time-barred or the relevant assets becoming unreachable increases materially — a practical consideration that the current court environment makes more, not less, pressing.

If you hold claims in a Russian insolvency and are assessing whether a KDL claim is viable, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What should foreign creditors and distressed investors do now?

The practical implication of the 2025–2026 court practice trend is that KDL liability is no longer a fringe enforcement mechanism — it is a mainstream tool in the Russian insolvency administrator's and creditor's arsenal, and one that requires active attention from the first stages of a creditor's involvement in Russian proceedings.

Three priorities merit attention.

First, identify and document control relationships early. If your claim arises from a transaction with a Russian entity that is now insolvent or at risk of insolvency, early analysis of the debtor's governance and ownership history — who actually directed the debtor's financial decisions, and when — is essential groundwork for any KDL claim. This analysis is most effective when undertaken before the insolvency administrator has completed their own investigation, because the administrator's findings will shape the court's factual record.

Second, assess your own KDL exposure if you have held any form of influence over the Russian debtor. Foreign investors and holding companies that provided financing, guaranteed obligations, or gave operational instructions to a Russian subsidiary should obtain a specific KDL exposure assessment before becoming active participants in the insolvency — whether as creditors, committee members, or otherwise. Participation in proceedings does not itself create KDL exposure, but it may generate a documentary record that an administrator or competing creditor uses against you.

Third, evaluate the practical enforceability of any KDL judgment in the relevant jurisdiction. A judgment against a foreign controlling person, issued by a Russian arbitrazh court, will need to be recognised in the jurisdiction where that person's assets are located. This cross-border dimension requires coordination between Russian insolvency counsel and local counsel in the relevant foreign jurisdiction — an area in which the firm works with trusted counsel internationally. For further context on the strategic dimensions of KDL proceedings, see Strategic considerations in subsidiary liability proceedings and the firm's practice overview on how Russian courts approach subsidiary liability.

The Restructuring & Insolvency practice at Vetrov & Partners advises foreign creditors and distressed investors on creditor-side strategy in Russian insolvency proceedings, including KDL claim assessment, participation in creditors' committees, and cross-border enforcement coordination. For matters touching on the asset recovery dimension, the firm's cross-border disputes practice works alongside insolvency counsel where relevant. A selection of representative creditor-side matters is available at /matters/.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on subsidiary liability of controlling persons in 2025–2026?

A: The change is not a legislative amendment but a shift in how arbitrazh courts apply the existing statutory framework. Courts have broadened the concept of "control" beyond formal shareholding thresholds to include factual influence; applied a presumption of causation between the controlling person's conduct and the debtor's insolvency that is harder to rebut; and construed the look-back period for impugned conduct broadly, typically encompassing transactions and decisions taken up to three years before the bankruptcy filing. Taken together, these developments make KDL claims both more accessible for creditors pursuing them and more consequential for foreign entities that may themselves qualify as controlling persons.

Q: Which foreign creditors and investors face the greatest exposure or benefit from the shift in KDL practice?

A: The creditors most directly positioned to benefit are unsecured trade creditors whose Russian debtor's insolvency can be linked to identifiable decisions by a dominant shareholder, beneficial owner, or holding company. The entities most exposed are foreign investors — including minority shareholders in joint ventures — who exercised de facto influence over the Russian entity's financial or operational decisions, particularly if that influence is evidenced by internal communications, guarantees, or shared governance arrangements. Distressed investors acquiring Russian debt at a discount should treat governance due diligence on the debtor's pre-insolvency history as an integral part of the investment case, not a post-acquisition refinement.

Q: What is the recommended first step for a foreign creditor assessing a KDL claim in a Russian insolvency?

A: The first step is a structured factual analysis of the debtor's ownership and governance history: who held formal and de facto control, what decisions were taken during the three-year pre-insolvency period, and what documentary evidence of those decisions is likely to be available or discoverable in the proceedings. This analysis should be completed before the insolvency administrator's own investigation concludes, since the administrator's report to the court will shape the evidential record on which any KDL claim is built. Russian insolvency proceedings move on defined statutory timetables, and early engagement with creditor-side counsel — including at the creditors' committee stage — is consistently the more effective posture.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry