Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian court practice on Article 61.2 transaction challenges in Russian insolvency for US creditors: 2027 update

Stanislav Lastovsky · October 2026 · 10 min read

Russian courts sharpened Article 61.2 scrutiny in 2027. US creditors in Russian insolvency face tighter challenge windows. Make an enquiry.

Following a discernible shift in the way Russian arbitrazh courts have applied Article 61.2 of Federal Law No. 127-FZ on Insolvency over the course of 2026 and into 2027, US creditors with claims in Russian insolvency proceedings face a materially altered risk landscape. The provision, which enables insolvency administrators to challenge transactions completed before a bankruptcy filing as suspicious, has always carried significant reach — covering transactions within one year for inadequate consideration and up to three years for those structured with intent to harm creditor interests. What has changed is the interpretive posture of the courts: the threshold for demonstrating the debtor's awareness of creditor harm has been progressively lowered, procedural grounds for resisting challenges have narrowed, and the practical window for a foreign creditor to respond effectively has compressed. For US creditors holding claims against Russian entities, understanding the current state of Article 61.2 practice is not an academic exercise — it is a live creditor-side concern.

§ I. What changed in Russian Article 61.2 practice in 2027?

For the better part of a decade, Article 61.2 challenges operated on a relatively predictable framework. The one-year limb — targeting transactions at an undervalue — required an administrator to demonstrate a disparity in consideration, while the three-year limb required additional evidence of the debtor's intent to harm and the counterparty's awareness of that intent. The body of circuit-level case law developed around these requirements was sufficiently settled that experienced Russian insolvency practitioners could assess challenge risk with reasonable confidence.

The current period disrupts that predictability in three concrete respects.

First, Russian courts have increasingly held that a counterparty's awareness of potential creditor harm may be inferred from circumstantial indicators — including the counterparty's commercial relationship with the debtor, the timing of the transaction relative to the debtor's financial deterioration, and any departure from arm's-length pricing, even where that departure is modest. Courts that previously required affirmative evidence of the counterparty's knowledge now more readily draw adverse inferences from the transaction structure itself.

Second, the threshold for establishing the debtor's insolvency at the time of the transaction — a required element under the three-year limb — has been applied more expansively. Courts have accepted that balance-sheet insolvency need not be formally established: patterns of delayed payment to creditors, outstanding tax arrears, or deteriorating liquidity ratios have been treated as sufficient proxies in a number of circuit-level decisions over the past year.

Third, and of particular practical consequence, the scope of transactions treated as constituting a "harm to creditor interests" has broadened. Asset disposals, security arrangements, and intra-group transfers that would previously have required additional contextual evidence to satisfy the harm threshold are now more readily captured, particularly where the transaction resulted in the debtor losing an asset without a corresponding reduction in its liabilities.

"The trend across multiple circuits is consistent: Russian courts are treating Article 61.2 as a broad tool for reversing pre-insolvency asset movements, and the doctrinal restraints that once limited its reach have weakened considerably." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

§ II. Which US creditors are most affected, and why?

The heightened application of Article 61.2 does not affect all creditor classes equally. Its primary impact falls on parties that either participated in transactions with the debtor in the one-to-three-year period before filing, or whose recovery position is diluted by the reversal of third-party transactions.

For US creditors, three categories warrant particular attention.

US trade creditors that received payment from a Russian counterparty in the period before insolvency are directly exposed to Article 61.2 reversal claims. Where the administrator characterises that payment as preferential — or as a transaction that depleted estate assets to the detriment of the remaining creditor body — it may seek to claw back the amount received, converting the US creditor from a satisfied claimant into a respondent in avoidance proceedings. In the current interpretive environment, payments made in the three months before filing, and in some cases beyond, are being scrutinised more aggressively than in prior years.

US institutional creditors and distressed investors that acquired claims or participated in refinancing arrangements with a Russian borrower are also exposed. Where such arrangements involved security, guarantees, or asset transfers, the administrator may characterise elements of the transaction as falling within the three-year limb, particularly if the debtor's financial position was already deteriorating at the time of execution. The broadened treatment of "insolvency indicators" described in § I makes this risk more acute.

US creditors that are themselves unsecured claimants in a Russian insolvency proceeding — seeking to maximise recovery from the estate — are affected differently. Successful Article 61.2 challenges by the administrator can restore assets to the estate and, in theory, improve recovery for the creditor body as a whole. However, the procedural complexity of these challenges, and the delays they introduce into proceedings, means that a US creditor relying on estate recovery through administrator-led challenges should not assume that additional assets will be restored on any predictable timeline.

The cross-border dimension compounds each of these risks. US creditors operating through holding structures with Russian subsidiaries, or holding Russian assets through intermediate jurisdictions, may find that transaction avoidance proceedings cut across those structures in ways that are difficult to anticipate from outside the jurisdiction. For a broader structural analysis, see our practice overview on Restructuring & Insolvency and the detailed treatment at Navigating Article 61.2 Transaction Challenges.

If your US entity has received payments from a Russian counterparty in the past three years, or holds claims in Russian insolvency proceedings, make an enquiry — info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should US creditors do now to protect their position?

The practical implication of the current Article 61.2 environment is that defensive awareness must precede the insolvency filing — not follow it. Once an administrator is appointed and begins to map the debtor's pre-filing transactions, the creditor's ability to shape the narrative is limited.

There are four steps that US creditors holding Russian exposure should take or have in place.

Transaction audit. Any payment, security arrangement, or asset transfer involving the Russian entity within the past three years should be reviewed against the current Article 61.2 framework. The review should assess both limbs — inadequate consideration (one year) and intent to harm (three years) — and should account for the broadened approach to insolvency indicators and counterparty awareness described in § I. Documentation supporting the commercial rationale and the arm's-length character of each transaction is the primary defence.Monitoring of debtor financial position. US creditors with ongoing Russian exposure should maintain a monitoring protocol that tracks publicly available indicators of the Russian counterparty's financial health — including filing of accounts, tax arrears, and court records of pending claims. Under Russian insolvency legislation, creditors who initiate proceedings promptly after a debtor's default are better positioned than those who wait; and the insolvency filing date determines the look-back period that governs Article 61.2 exposure.Claim registration strategy. Where insolvency proceedings against a Russian counterparty have already been initiated, US creditors should assess whether they have registered their claims in the creditor register, and whether the registration was made within the prescribed window. Late registration — a common outcome for foreign creditors unfamiliar with Russian procedure — affects creditor voting rights and priority in distribution. Our analysis at Deep Dive: Article 61.2 Transaction Challenges covers the procedural mechanics in detail.Engagement with the administrator. Where a US creditor anticipates exposure to a reversal claim, early engagement with the administrator — through properly appointed Russian counsel — remains the most effective procedural tool. Administrators do not universally pursue all challengeable transactions; creditors that can demonstrate a robust commercial basis for the relevant transaction are more likely to avoid the expense and delay of contested avoidance proceedings.

Under Russian insolvency legislation, preferential transfer claims may be brought for transactions completed up to three years before the bankruptcy filing — a window that US creditors unfamiliar with Russian insolvency law frequently underestimate when assessing their exposure after a counterparty's default.

For a creditor-side assessment of your Article 61.2 exposure in Russian proceedings, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Open questions in the current Article 61.2 framework

The 2027 environment is one of heightened judicial activity rather than settled re-codification. Several questions remain open in Russian court practice and warrant monitoring.

The extent to which circuit courts will align on the standard for inferring counterparty awareness — or whether divergence between, for example, the Moscow and Siberian circuits persists — is not yet resolved. US creditors whose Russian counterparties operated in different federal districts may face materially different risk profiles depending on the forum in which insolvency proceedings were filed.

The treatment of foreign-currency transactions and US-dollar-denominated instruments in Article 61.2 avoidance proceedings is also developing. Where the consideration received by a creditor was denominated in US dollars and the court assesses the adequacy of that consideration in roubles at the exchange rate prevailing at the time of the transaction, significant valuation questions arise — particularly given exchange rate volatility over the relevant look-back periods.

Finally, the coordination between Article 61.2 proceedings and cross-border recognition of Russian insolvency proceedings remains unresolved. The United States does not have a reciprocal recognition framework with Russia, and questions about the enforceability of Article 61.2 judgments against US entities outside of Russia have not been authoritatively addressed. US creditors should seek domestic US legal advice on the implications of Russian avoidance claims for their US-held assets.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Article 61.2 practice in Russian courts in 2027?

A: Russian arbitrazh courts have in the current period applied Article 61.2 of the Russian insolvency legislation with a measurably lower evidential threshold than was common in prior years. Courts have more readily inferred a counterparty's awareness of creditor harm from the structure and timing of the transaction itself, without requiring affirmative evidence of the counterparty's subjective knowledge. The indicators courts will accept as evidence of the debtor's insolvency at the time of the transaction have broadened — delayed payments, tax arrears, and deteriorating liquidity ratios have been treated as sufficient in a number of recent circuit-level decisions. The category of transactions treated as harmful to creditors has also widened. The cumulative effect is a more expansive and administratively applied challenge mechanism than existed even two to three years ago.

Q: Which US creditors are most affected by the current Article 61.2 environment, and how?

A: US trade creditors that received payments from a Russian counterparty within the three-year look-back period face direct exposure to administrator-led reversal claims. US institutional creditors and distressed investors that participated in refinancing or security arrangements during the debtor's financial deterioration are exposed under the three-year limb of the provision. US unsecured claimants in ongoing Russian insolvency proceedings are affected indirectly: administrator-led challenges may improve estate recovery but introduce procedural delays. Creditors operating through complex holding structures involving Russian subsidiaries or intermediate jurisdictions face additional risk of challenge claims cutting across those structures in ways that are not predictable without specialist Russian insolvency advice.

Q: What should a US creditor do now to protect its position in Russian insolvency proceedings?

A: The most effective steps are pre-insolvency: a structured audit of transactions with the Russian entity within the past three years, documentation of commercial rationale and arm's-length pricing, and active monitoring of the debtor's publicly available financial indicators. Where insolvency proceedings have already been filed, timely registration of claims in the Russian creditor register is essential — late registration affects voting rights and distribution priority under Russian insolvency legislation. US creditors with active Article 61.2 exposure should also obtain advice from US counsel on the domestic implications of any Russian avoidance claim. Early engagement through Russian insolvency counsel, before the administrator has concluded its challenge strategy, remains the most cost-effective protective measure available.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry