Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Russian court practice on subsidiary liability of controlling persons in Russian bankruptcy against individual debtors: 2026 update

Stanislav Lastovsky · February 2026 · 8 min read

Russian courts are tightening subsidiary liability in individual insolvency cases. What foreign creditors need to know in 2026. Make an enquiry.

Following a sustained line of decisions handed down by Russian arbitrazh courts and the courts of general jurisdiction in 2024 and into 2025, the doctrine of subsidiary liability for controlling persons has undergone a material – and, for foreign creditors, consequential – development: its application to individual debtors in personal insolvency proceedings has been markedly expanded. Where Russian courts previously treated the individual debtor regime as a largely self-contained framework with limited scope for third-party liability claims, a more recent body of practice has applied the same controlling-person logic that creditors encountered in corporate insolvency proceedings to cases where the debtor is a natural person acting in a business capacity. For foreign trade creditors and institutional investors with Russian counterparty exposure, the practical implications of this shift are worth examining with some care.

What changed – and why it matters to creditors

The starting point is procedural architecture. Russian insolvency legislation draws a formal distinction between corporate insolvency – the rehabilitation and bankruptcy of legal entities – and individual insolvency, which governs natural persons including sole traders and former directors personally. The doctrine of subsidiary liability of controlling persons (broadly, the power of creditors to pursue those who exercised actual control over a debtor and whose actions caused or exacerbated insolvency) was well developed in the corporate track. Its migration into individual insolvency is the central development that creditors active in the Russian market should now map against their own portfolios.

What specifically shifted in the period under review? Russian courts, drawing on a body of practice that has built up since amendments to the personal insolvency framework came into effect, have increasingly permitted creditor applications to establish the subsidiary liability of persons who controlled the individual debtor's business activities – in cases where that individual operated a business, held assets through legal structures, or acted as the directing mind behind a legal entity that was itself formally insolvent. Courts have, in a growing number of instances, been willing to pierce through the formal status of "individual debtor" to examine the wider control structure, and to hold accountable those whose decisions – asset transfers, preferential payments, deliberate structuring ahead of insolvency – caused creditor loss.

The significance of this is not merely theoretical. A creditor whose claim in the individual insolvency estate is insufficiently covered now has a potential route to recovery from a controlling person who would previously have sat outside the reach of Russian insolvency claims. At the same time, the evidentiary threshold and procedural mechanics of these claims are still being defined in practice – making early creditor engagement with the process more important than ever.

If you are a foreign creditor seeking to assess your recovery options in a Russian individual insolvency — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Who is affected – and which creditors face the greatest exposure?

The development is most directly relevant to three categories of foreign creditor.

First, trade creditors whose counterparty was a sole trader or an individual operating an unincorporated business in Russia. These creditors often find that the individual insolvency estate is insufficient to cover their claims, and have historically faced limited options beyond lodging a claim in the estate. The expansion of controlling-person liability creates a procedural mechanism – not a guarantee – to pursue additional recovery.

Second, creditors whose counterparty was a legal entity that has itself been wound up through insolvency proceedings, but where the directing mind of that entity – typically a majority shareholder or the de facto manager – has subsequently entered personal insolvency. Courts have in several instances allowed creditors from the corporate insolvency to re-lodge and pursue subsidiary liability claims against the individual in the personal insolvency track, treating the two proceedings as connected. Foreign creditors who closed their corporate-insolvency files without exploring personal-track options may wish to revisit this analysis.

Third, creditors in EAEU member states and CIS jurisdictions whose claims involve cross-border elements. Where a controlling person holds assets across jurisdictions, the Russian insolvency court's findings on subsidiary liability can form the basis for recognition and enforcement proceedings in the debtor's home jurisdiction. This is procedurally complex, but practitioners who handled cross-border restructurings in the Baltic context prior to 2022 will recognise the structural logic.

One risk that creditors unfamiliar with Russian insolvency practice frequently underestimate: Russian insolvency legislation permits subsidiary liability claims to be brought in respect of acts going back three years before the date of the insolvency application. Creditors who allow time to pass without preserving evidence of the controlling person's acts – asset disposals, intercompany transactions, management decisions – risk losing the evidentiary foundation on which such claims depend.

"In a sequence of decisions that crossed into personal insolvency from the corporate track, Russian courts have applied controlling-person doctrine more broadly than the statute's text alone would have suggested – and the trend is clearly not reversed." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

What creditors should do now

The expansion of subsidiary liability into the individual debtor context does not deliver automatic recovery. It creates a procedural opportunity that must be identified, assessed, and pursued within the insolvency proceedings in a timely manner. For foreign creditors, the practical steps that follow from this development are these.

The first priority is claim registration. A foreign creditor who has not lodged its claim in the individual insolvency proceedings cannot participate in the creditors' committee and lacks standing to apply for a subsidiary liability claim against the controlling person. The registration deadline under Russian insolvency procedure is strict and non-extendable. Creditors who have received notice of insolvency proceedings against an individual counterparty – or whose counterparty has ceased trading without formal notice – should verify whether proceedings have been opened and act immediately.

The second step is evidential preservation. Controlling-person liability claims in the individual track, as in the corporate track, are contingent on demonstrating that the controlling person's acts caused or contributed to the insufficiency of the estate. Documents evidencing asset transfers, intercompany loans, management instructions, and ownership structures – to the extent a creditor holds them through prior due diligence or commercial correspondence – should be collected and preserved now. Russian courts have found against creditors where the factual record was thin.

The third consideration is jurisdictional. Where the individual debtor has assets – or the controlling person has assets – in a foreign jurisdiction, coordinating the Russian insolvency proceedings with parallel enforcement steps outside Russia requires careful sequencing. Instructions to local counsel should be given before the Russian proceedings reach a stage that forecloses options in the foreign jurisdiction.

The firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice has advised foreign creditors in subsidiary liability proceedings in the Russian courts. For further reading on how Russian courts approach the underlying doctrine, see How Russian courts approach subsidiary liability of controlling persons and Strategic considerations in subsidiary liability claims. Further matter examples are available on the firm's matters page.

If your Russian counterparty is an individual debtor in insolvency proceedings and you have not yet assessed your subsidiary liability options — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on subsidiary liability of controlling persons in individual insolvency cases?

A: Russian courts, particularly over 2024 and into 2025, have extended the controlling-person liability doctrine – previously well-established in corporate insolvency – into personal insolvency proceedings. Courts have permitted creditors to pursue individuals who exercised actual control over a debtor's business activities, where those activities caused or contributed to the insufficiency of the insolvency estate. The change is incremental rather than statutory: it reflects how courts have interpreted an existing framework, not a new piece of legislation. The practical effect is that the subsidiary liability route, previously used mainly in corporate bankruptcies, is now a live option in individual insolvency matters.

Q: Which foreign creditors are most affected by these developments, and how?

A: The development is most immediately relevant to creditors whose Russian counterparty was an individual operating in a business capacity – a sole trader, a former director now in personal insolvency, or an individual who was the controlling mind of a legal entity that has already been wound up. It is also relevant to creditors in EAEU and CIS member states where cross-border recognition of Russian insolvency findings may be sought. For any creditor holding an unsatisfied claim against a now-insolvent individual, the expansion means that recovery analysis should include a controlling-person dimension that may previously have been treated as unavailable.

Q: What should foreign creditors do to protect their recovery position in light of this development?

A: Three immediate steps are advisable. First, verify whether insolvency proceedings have been opened against the individual counterparty and register the claim without delay – the deadline is strict. Second, preserve all documentary evidence of the controlling person's acts, including asset transfers, management decisions, and corporate correspondence. Third, obtain legal advice on whether a subsidiary liability application is viable in the specific facts of the insolvency, and coordinate any cross-border enforcement steps with the Russian proceedings. The firm can assist with each stage.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry