Russian courts tightened the standard for Article 61.2 transaction challenges under Article 61.11 in 2026. What creditors must know. Make an enquiry.
Through the first three quarters of 2026, Russian insolvency courts have continued to refine their approach to Article 61.2 transaction challenges — the principal statutory mechanism for unwinding suspicious transactions in Russian insolvency proceedings. What has shifted is not the statutory text, which remains unchanged, but the evidentiary standards courts apply when assessing whether a pre-bankruptcy transaction was conducted with intent to harm creditors, and how Article 61.11 of the Insolvency Law — governing the subsidiary liability of controlling persons — is being invoked alongside successful challenges. For foreign creditors holding claims against Russian debtors, understanding this evolving practice is no longer a secondary consideration: it directly determines whether value can be restored to the estate and, consequently, whether recovery is realistic at all.
Russian insolvency law has long provided two principal grounds for challenging transactions under Article 61.2. The first applies to transactions concluded at undervalue within one year before the bankruptcy filing — a relatively mechanical test. The second, more consequential and more litigated, covers transactions conducted with intent to harm creditors within three years of the filing date. It is in this second category that court practice has moved most significantly during 2025 and into 2026.
The central development is a tightening of the bad-faith standard applied to counterparties. Russian courts have moved toward requiring more substantive evidence that the counterparty knew, or ought to have known, of the debtor's intention to harm creditors — rather than relying on presumptions alone. In practice, this means that insolvency administrators and creditors pursuing challenges must now construct a more complete factual record: demonstrating the debtor's financial deterioration at the time of the transaction, the absence of equivalent countervalue, and the counterparty's awareness or constructive knowledge of those facts.
Courts in the Siberian and Ural circuits have also placed greater emphasis on the independence of the transaction from the debtor's ordinary course of business. Transactions that might superficially appear commercial — a disposal of real property at a modestly reduced price, or a debt repayment to an affiliated entity — are scrutinised more rigorously where the debtor's insolvency indicators were already present. The burden of demonstrating that a transaction was genuinely arm's-length has shifted further toward the respondent.
The second significant development concerns the procedural interplay between a successful Article 61.2 challenge and the pursuit of subsidiary liability under Article 61.11 of the Insolvency Law. Where a transaction challenge succeeds and assets are restored to the estate, courts have increasingly considered whether the controlling persons who authorised or facilitated the impugned transaction bear personal liability for any shortfall in the estate that the restoration does not cure. This dual-track approach — challenge the transaction and, in parallel, establish the liability of the controlling persons — is now a documented feature of creditor strategy in larger Russian insolvency proceedings.
"The 2026 court practice on Article 61.2 reflects a more demanding evidentiary threshold — which, counterintuitively, creates an opportunity for well-prepared creditors who invest in the factual record early." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners
The practical impact of these shifts falls unevenly across the foreign creditor population. Three categories of creditor face the most direct consequences.
Foreign trade creditors with unsecured claims stand to benefit most from a successful transaction challenge, provided that the restored assets are sufficient to improve their position in the priority waterfall. Where the debtor disposed of significant assets — real estate, equipment, intellectual property rights, or intercompany receivables — in the period up to three years before filing, the Article 61.2 challenge mechanism remains one of the few routes to meaningful estate augmentation. The enhanced evidentiary standard does not foreclose this route; it simply raises the cost of pursuing it without adequate preparation.
Foreign counterparties who received payments or assets from a now-insolvent Russian debtor face a different concern. A transaction challenge brought against a foreign entity raises questions of jurisdictional reach and cross-border enforcement that domestic creditors do not face. Russian insolvency courts assert jurisdiction over transaction challenges regardless of where the counterparty is domiciled, and a judgment restoring assets can be enforced through Russian state court proceedings against Russian-situs property or — in certain circumstances — through recognition proceedings in the counterparty's home jurisdiction. Foreign counterparties who received transfers from a Russian entity in financial difficulty within the relevant lookback periods should assess their exposure promptly.
Foreign institutional creditors and distressed investors who acquire claims against Russian insolvency estates should note that the viability of a challenge is now a material factor in claim valuation. Insolvency estates where significant pre-filing disposals are on record — but where the challenge has not yet been initiated or has been poorly prepared — carry a meaningful risk discount that is not always reflected in the acquisition price. Under Russian insolvency legislation, preferential transfer claims and undervalue challenges may be brought for transactions completed up to three years before the bankruptcy filing — a window that creditors unfamiliar with Russian insolvency procedure frequently underestimate when pricing claims.
For in-house counsel managing a Russian counterparty relationship that has entered, or appears to be approaching, insolvency, the procedural timetable for initiating a challenge is unforgiving. Delay in instructing insolvency counsel to assess the pre-filing transaction record translates directly into a weaker evidential position and, in some cases, into a missed window entirely.
If your entity holds claims against a Russian insolvency estate, or if you have received assets or payments from a Russian counterparty now in bankruptcy proceedings, the transaction challenge and subsidiary liability landscape warrants early legal review — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The practical response to the 2026 developments in Article 61.2 court practice divides into three areas: early-stage assessment, procedural positioning, and the parallel Article 61.11 track.
Early-stage assessment means identifying all pre-filing transactions between the debtor and related or unrelated parties within the three-year lookback window, and mapping them against the financial indicators of the debtor's condition at the time of each transaction. This exercise is more productive when conducted before the insolvency administrator has submitted their own challenge application, since creditors who actively monitor the administrator's work — and who are prepared to bring independent applications where the administrator is passive — tend to achieve better outcomes. Russian insolvency legislation grants creditors standing to bring transaction challenge applications independently; this right is under-utilised by foreign creditors who assume the administrator will act on their behalf.
Procedural positioning requires engagement with the insolvency administrator and the creditors' committee at an early stage. In proceedings where foreign creditors represent a material share of total claims, their participation in the creditors' committee is the primary lever for influencing how transaction challenges are prioritised and resourced. Committees dominated by affiliated or domestic creditors with different interests may deprioritise challenges that would benefit the foreign creditor class; active committee representation changes that dynamic.
The Article 61.11 subsidiary liability track is now most effectively pursued in parallel with, rather than after, the Article 61.2 challenge. Establishing that a controlling person authorised a transaction that is subsequently set aside — and that this caused a shortfall in the estate — requires a connected factual and legal narrative. Developing that narrative as a single integrated case, rather than sequentially, reduces the risk of procedural fragmentation and strengthens the evidentiary record for both claims.
Foreign advisers co-ordinating with Russian insolvency counsel should be aware that the substantive law and procedural rules governing Article 61.2 challenges and Article 61.11 liability proceedings are distinct, and that the Russian courts hearing these matters operate under the arbitrazh procedure code with its own timetables and evidential conventions. Instructing Russian counsel early — before the main creditors' meeting, and certainly before the administrator's challenge window closes — is the baseline requirement for a creditor seeking to protect its position.
Two areas of uncertainty in the current Article 61.2 and Article 61.11 practice are worth flagging for foreign creditors and their advisers.
The first is the treatment of transactions involving foreign-law-governed contracts or assets held outside Russia. Russian courts have, in practice, varying approaches to challenges where the impugned transaction was governed by English, German, or Dutch law, or where the asset transferred was sited abroad. The trend in the more recent decisions is toward a broader assertion of jurisdiction, but the enforceability of the resulting judgment — both in restoring the asset and in pursuing the controlling person — remains genuinely uncertain when the counterparty or the asset is offshore. This is an area where foreign counsel and Russian insolvency counsel need to work jointly from the outset.
The second open question concerns the interplay between Article 61.11 liability proceedings and the criminal liability provisions that may, in parallel, be engaged where a controlling person is accused of deliberate bankruptcy or asset stripping. Russian prosecutors and insolvency administrators sometimes pursue these tracks simultaneously, and the evidentiary record developed in civil insolvency proceedings can be material to the criminal investigation — and vice versa. Foreign creditors who hold evidence of deliberate pre-filing disposal of assets should take advice on how that evidence is best deployed across both tracks without prejudicing their civil recovery position.
The Restructuring & Insolvency practice at Vetrov & Partners monitors Russian court practice on Article 61.2 transaction challenges and Article 61.11 subsidiary liability on an ongoing basis. Related briefings are available at Navigating Article 61.2 Transaction Challenges in Russian Insolvency and Deep Dive: Article 61.2 Transaction Challenges in Russian Insolvency. For matters involving foreign creditors in Russian insolvency estates, see also the firm's Matters record.
Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on Article 61.2 transaction challenges in 2025–2026?
A: The substantive statutory provisions of Article 61.2 are unchanged. What has shifted is the evidentiary standard applied by Russian insolvency courts, particularly for the three-year intent-to-harm limb. Courts are now requiring more affirmative evidence that the counterparty knew or ought to have known of the debtor's intent to harm creditors — rather than relying primarily on statutory presumptions. Courts in several circuits have also placed greater weight on the independence of the challenged transaction from the debtor's ordinary course of business, and on the financial condition of the debtor at the time of the transaction. The practical consequence is that challenge applications need to be better evidenced at the point of filing than was typically required two or three years ago.
Q: Which foreign creditors are most directly affected by the Article 61.2 and Article 61.11 developments?
A: Three groups face the most immediate implications. First, foreign trade creditors with unsecured claims against a Russian insolvent debtor where significant pre-filing disposals occurred: for these creditors, a successful Article 61.2 challenge may be the primary source of estate augmentation. Second, foreign counterparties who received transfers from a Russian entity in financial difficulty within the three-year lookback window: they face potential respondent exposure in challenge proceedings regardless of their domicile. Third, foreign distressed investors or claim buyers: the viability and state of preparation of pending Article 61.2 challenges should be a material factor in claim valuation, and the Article 61.11 subsidiary liability track can represent additional recovery that is not always priced into the claim.
Q: What practical step should a foreign creditor take first when its Russian counterparty enters insolvency?
A: The immediate priority is a structured review of all transactions between the debtor and any connected or unconnected party in the three years before the bankruptcy filing date, assessed against the debtor's known financial condition at the relevant time. This assessment forms the factual basis for both the Article 61.2 challenge application and any parallel Article 61.11 controlling-person liability claim. It should be undertaken by Russian insolvency counsel before the principal creditors' meeting, since decisions made at that meeting — including the election of the creditors' committee and the mandate given to the insolvency administrator — directly affect how transaction challenges are subsequently resourced and pursued. Waiting for the administrator to act unilaterally is a common and costly error.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry