Dutch creditor defeated Article 61.3 preferential clawback in Russian insolvency. Subsidiary liability dismissed at first instance. Make an enquiry.
Coordinated cross-border Article 61.3 preferential transaction clawbacks under Russian law matter — full recovery achieved
INSOLVENCY — RUSSIA / NETHERLANDS — Coordinated cross-border Article 61.3 preferential transaction clawback: creditor's defence and preservation of recovery position
Client. A Dutch trading company holding a secured claim in Russian insolvency proceedings against a long-standing commercial counterparty operating in the Siberian Federal District.
Background. The insolvency trustee brought coordinated proceedings under Russian insolvency legislation seeking to characterise a series of pre-insolvency payments received by the creditor as preferential transactions subject to avoidance. Simultaneously, the trustee initiated a subsidiary liability claim against the creditor, alleging that it had exercised controlling influence over the debtor's conduct in the period preceding the bankruptcy filing. The combination of a clawback application and a subsidiary liability action — pursued in parallel before the arbitrazh court — created compounded exposure for the creditor: a successful clawback would have required repayment to the estate, while a finding of subsidiary liability would have exposed the creditor to the debtor's remaining balance-sheet shortfall. The Dutch parent required coordinated advice across both proceedings to protect the creditor's recovery position and manage Dutch-law reporting obligations.
Our role. The firm was instructed as Russian insolvency counsel at first instance. Counsel analysed the transactional timeline in detail and established that the payments at issue did not meet the statutory criteria for avoidance under Russian insolvency legislation: the debtor had not been insolvent at the date of the relevant payments, and the creditor had not received preferential treatment over other creditors of equal rank. The subsidiary liability claim — premised on the creditor's alleged influence over the debtor's pre-insolvency conduct — was contested on both factual and jurisdictional grounds, with particular focus on the absence of any documented decision-making authority exercised by the Dutch entity over Russian operational matters.
Outcome. The subsidiary liability claim was dismissed at first instance. The clawback application was withdrawn by the trustee following the evidentiary hearing. The creditor's recovery position in the insolvency proceedings was preserved in full. Total duration from instruction to decision: 11 months.
Discuss a similar matter — info@vetrovpartners.com
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry