Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

A practical guide to related-party transaction challenges in Russian bankruptcy against privately held Russian companies for foreign companies

Stanislav Lastovsky · March 2026 · 12 min read

Foreign creditors in Russian insolvency often overlook related-party transaction challenges as a recovery tool. What counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

In the course of advising foreign creditors on Russian insolvency proceedings, a recurring observation stands out: the related-party transaction challenge is consistently the most under-utilised recovery tool available. Foreign trade creditors and institutional investors entering Russian bankruptcy proceedings as unsecured creditors often assume the debtor's estate is fixed at the moment of filing. It is not. Russian insolvency legislation provides creditors and the bankruptcy trustee with broad powers to challenge and unwind transactions that transferred value away from the estate – particularly those concluded with affiliated or connected parties – and to claw back assets into the bankruptcy estate for pro-rata distribution. For creditors pursuing recovery against privately held Russian companies, where pre-insolvency asset stripping through related-party dealings is a documented pattern, understanding how to deploy this mechanism is often the difference between a nominal dividend and a meaningful recovery.

What to prepare before filing a challenge

Before initiating any related-party transaction challenge in Russian insolvency proceedings, a foreign creditor's counsel should assemble the following materials. Gaps in this preparation are the most common cause of challenge applications being dismissed on procedural grounds at first instance.

What to prepare – checklist:

Note: Russian insolvency legislation establishes distinct look-back periods for different categories of related-party transaction challenge. Transactions with affiliates may be challenged over a longer window than transactions with unconnected counterparties. Creditors who delay lodging challenge applications risk losing access to the most valuable look-back period – a window that, once missed, cannot be extended by court discretion. Early instruction of Russian insolvency counsel is essential.

Foreign creditors preparing to initiate related-party transaction challenges in Russian insolvency proceedings should seek early specialist advice. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 1 – Identify which transactions are challengeable in Russian bankruptcy

The starting point is identifying, from the available documentary record, which pre-insolvency transactions fall within the scope of Russian insolvency legislation's avoidance provisions.

Russian insolvency law distinguishes two primary categories relevant to foreign creditors pursuing recovery against privately held Russian companies. The first covers transactions that are suspect by reason of the debtor's financial position at the time of the dealing – the debtor was insolvent or became insolvent as a result of the transaction, and the counterparty was aware, or should have been aware, of that financial condition. The second and more powerful category for related-party cases covers transactions that harmed creditors' interests by transferring assets at undervalue or on terms that no arm's-length counterparty would have accepted.

For privately held Russian companies, the second category is frequently the operative one. Pre-insolvency dealings between a company and its owners, directors, or their connected entities – including asset sales at below-market values, loans on non-commercial terms, pledge grants securing related-party debts, and distribution of profits during financial distress – are all candidates for challenge. The critical threshold is demonstrating that the counterparty qualifies as a related party under Russian law, which uses an affiliation analysis covering both formal and functional control.

Counsel should note that Russian courts have applied the affiliation concept expansively in recent insolvency practice, finding affiliation where counterparties share economic interests even absent formal corporate links. The Federal Tax Service guidance on related-party transactions in insolvency has reinforced this broader reading and is directly relevant to how courts assess affiliation arguments in bankruptcy proceedings.

Step 2 – Establish the affiliation or control link

The second step – and the one most frequently contested by respondents in privately held company insolvencies – is establishing that the counterparty to the challenged transaction is a related party within the meaning of Russian insolvency legislation.

For formal affiliates – entities where the debtor company holds a participation interest, or where a common parent exists – this is a documentary exercise. Corporate registry extracts and shareholders' agreements will ordinarily suffice as a starting evidential position. The harder work arises in the common pattern for privately held Russian companies: informal control structures, nominee arrangements, and undisclosed beneficial ownership.

In practice, Russian insolvency courts have accepted several categories of indirect evidence to establish affiliation. These include: concurrent service of the same individual as director of both the debtor and the counterparty; common registered address or accounting services; recurring transactions on non-commercial terms that make economic sense only on the assumption of common ownership; and evidence from the Federal Tax Service's own records of related-party treatment between the entities for tax purposes. Creditors' counsel should proactively request the trustee to obtain disclosure from the tax authority, as the Federal Tax Service's transaction monitoring records can be a significant source of affiliation evidence that is not otherwise accessible to private parties.

Where affiliation cannot be proved conclusively, Russian courts have demonstrated willingness, in appropriate cases, to shift the evidential burden to the respondent once a creditor establishes a prima facie case of suspicious dealing. This makes the threshold for initiating a challenge lower than the threshold for establishing it at final hearing – a distinction that matters for timing strategy.

For a more detailed treatment of how Russian courts have analysed the affiliation question in specific challenge scenarios, see the deep-dive analysis of related-party transaction challenges.

Step 3 – Who can bring a challenge, and does it matter?

A question that frequently arises in practice: who has standing to bring a related-party transaction challenge in Russian insolvency proceedings, and does the identity of the applicant affect the prospects of success?

Standing to bring a challenge application belongs primarily to the bankruptcy trustee, acting on behalf of the estate. Individual creditors also have a qualified right to bring challenges, but this is subject to conditions that vary depending on the stage of proceedings and the size of the creditor's claim relative to the total creditors' register. In practice, creditors holding a sufficiently large registered debt – which in the context of foreign trade creditors can include the principal, interest, and contractual penalties admitted to the register – will commonly meet the threshold.

The identity of the applicant can matter in a secondary way: trustee-initiated challenges carry a stronger presumption of procedural regularity and tend to generate fuller disclosure from the debtor's records. Creditor-initiated challenges may face more procedural scrutiny at the admissibility stage but can be prosecuted independently where the trustee is passive, conflicted, or subject to influence from the debtor's connected parties.

For foreign creditors dealing with privately held Russian companies, trustee passivity on related-party challenges is a documented risk. Where the trustee was proposed by the debtor's own creditors – a structural feature of Russian bankruptcy that allows the debtor's connected creditors to influence trustee selection – the trustee may have limited appetite for challenging transactions that benefit the debtor's principals. In these circumstances, the foreign creditor's right to bring independent challenge applications is a critical protection, and early engagement with an independent Russian insolvency counsel is the mechanism through which that right is effectively exercised.

For foreign creditors navigating trustee dynamics in Russian insolvency proceedings involving privately held companies, specialist early advice makes a practical difference. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 4 – Building and presenting the challenge application

A related-party transaction challenge in Russian insolvency is an adversarial application brought before the insolvency court presiding over the bankruptcy. The application must set out the factual basis of the challenge, the legal grounds relied upon, and the relief sought – which is typically rescission of the transaction and return of the transferred asset or its monetary equivalent to the estate.

The application is served on the respondent – typically the affiliated entity that received the transferred asset – and on the bankruptcy trustee. Hearings on challenge applications are substantive proceedings: witnesses may be examined, documentary evidence is evaluated, and expert opinion on valuation is admissible where the challenge rests on an undervalue argument.

Several practical considerations arise in the context of challenges against privately held Russian companies. First, respondents will commonly argue that the challenged transaction was market-priced, which places valuation evidence at the centre of contested hearings. Creditors' counsel should anticipate the need for independent valuation evidence and instruct a Russian-qualified valuation expert at an early stage. Second, respondents will challenge the affiliation case, and the preparation carried out at Step 2 will be tested in full. Third, the debtor's former management and related parties will, in many cases, contest the creditor's standing to bring the application.

Interim measures are available. Where there is a credible risk that the respondent will dissipate the contested asset or transfer it further before the challenge is determined, the insolvency court has power to grant provisional measures – effectively freezing the asset pending final determination. Applications for interim measures are heard on an expedited basis and can be filed simultaneously with the main challenge application. In practice, the availability of interim relief significantly affects the tactical dynamics of the challenge process and is an important reason why challenge applications should be prepared with urgency once the factual basis is identified.

For an overview of the firm's experience in cross-border asset recovery connected to Russian insolvency proceedings, see /matters/ and the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice page. For matters involving cross-border tracing of assets moved via related-party dealings into third jurisdictions, the Cross-Border Disputes practice is also relevant.

Step 5 – What happens if the challenge succeeds?

A successful related-party transaction challenge in Russian bankruptcy has two primary consequences, and foreign creditors should be clear on both before assessing whether the effort is warranted.

The first consequence is reinstatement: the challenged transaction is unwound and the transferred asset – or its monetary equivalent where the asset has been further disposed of or cannot be restored in kind – is returned to the bankruptcy estate. This increases the distributable estate available to all creditors, pro-rata, in accordance with their priority.

The second consequence, specific to related-party transactions, is that the respondent counterparty's own claims against the debtor – if any – are subordinated. Under Russian insolvency legislation, the counterparty to a successfully challenged transaction loses its priority in the creditors' register and is pushed to the lowest tier of distribution. For privately held Russian companies, where the related counterparty is typically also a creditor of the debtor (the debtor having granted loans or pledges that generate claims held by the connected entity), subordination can be as commercially significant as the reinstatement of the asset itself, because it directly reduces the share distributed to connected creditors and increases the proportionate recovery of independent creditors including foreign trade creditors.

The practical recovery impact depends on the size of the challenged transaction relative to the estate, the tier in which the foreign creditor sits in the creditors' register, and the extent of other liabilities. However, in privately held Russian company insolvencies where pre-insolvency value extraction through related-party dealings has been substantial, successful challenges can materially alter recovery ratios. This makes the related-party transaction challenge a structurally important tool for foreign creditors – not an ancillary procedural step, but a primary recovery mechanism that warrants the same analytical effort as the underlying claim.

For foreign companies assessing recovery prospects in Russian insolvency proceedings against privately held companies, a complimentary initial meeting with our Restructuring & Insolvency team can clarify the options. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long does a foreign creditor have to bring a related-party transaction challenge in Russian insolvency proceedings?

A: The time available depends on the category of challenge and the date of the underlying transaction. Russian insolvency legislation establishes different look-back windows for different types of suspect dealing, with longer windows available for transactions involving affiliated parties. The limitation period for bringing a challenge application runs from a creditor's awareness of the grounds, but is capped. In practice, foreign creditors should treat the issue as time-sensitive from the moment they become aware of a potentially challengeable transaction – and certainly from the moment they receive their first substantive disclosure from the trustee. Delay in instructing Russian insolvency counsel to review potential challenges is the most common and most avoidable source of limitation risk.

Q: What documents does a foreign creditor need to support a challenge application?

A: The core documentary foundation is addressed in the checklist above. In addition to the materials listed, creditors should obtain – where accessible – the debtor's internal correspondence, management accounts, and any prior audit or valuation reports that address the assets involved in the challenged transaction. In privately held Russian company insolvencies, the trustee is the principal source of internal documentation. Foreign creditors should file formal requests for trustee disclosure at the earliest practicable stage, as trustee disclosure obligations are enforceable and can be pursued through the insolvency court if the trustee is uncooperative.

Q: Can a foreign creditor pursue a related-party transaction challenge if the transferred asset has already been moved out of Russia?

A: This is one of the more complex scenarios in cross-border Russian insolvency. The challenge application itself is filed in the Russian insolvency court and is governed by Russian insolvency legislation – the location of the asset does not affect the Russian court's jurisdiction to unwind the transaction and order reinstatement of its monetary equivalent into the Russian estate. Enforcement of the reinstatement order against assets held abroad is a separate and more complex question, which may require recognition proceedings in the relevant foreign jurisdiction and coordination with local counsel. The firm has experience of coordinating this type of cross-border enforcement in conjunction with trusted counsel in the relevant jurisdictions and can advise on the procedural architecture for each jurisdiction involved.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry