Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Navigating Article 61.3 preferential transaction clawbacks under Russian law in the technology and software sector: a step-by-step overview

Stanislav Lastovsky · February 2026 · 13 min read

Foreign creditors face clawback risk under Article 61.3 when a Russian tech debtor enters insolvency. Know your exposure and next steps. Make an enquiry.

In practice, the Article 61.3 preferential transaction clawback under Russian insolvency law catches foreign creditors off guard more reliably than almost any other provision in the Russian bankruptcy framework. A technology or software company that received payment from a Russian counterparty — whether for a software licence, a SaaS subscription, a maintenance agreement, or a hardware delivery — may find that payment challenged years after it was received, once the Russian entity enters formal insolvency proceedings. This guide sets out the five steps a foreign creditor in the technology and software sector should take from the moment it learns that a Russian counterparty has filed for, or been declared, insolvent, through to the stage at which its exposure to an Article 61.3 clawback claim is understood and, where possible, defended.

What to prepare before the first creditor committee meeting

Before taking any substantive step in the insolvency proceedings, a foreign creditor operating in the technology and software sector should compile the following:

These materials determine whether payments received within the relevant lookback window fall under Article 61.3 and, critically, whether the ordinary course defence is available.

Step 1. Understand the lookback windows and what they capture

Article 61.3 of Russian insolvency legislation establishes two distinct lookback periods, and the rules that apply within each window differ materially in what the claimant — typically the insolvency manager — must prove.

Transactions completed within one month before the bankruptcy petition was filed are subject to challenge if they resulted in one creditor receiving preferential treatment over others, regardless of whether either party had knowledge of the debtor's insolvency at the time. No knowledge element is required. The insolvency manager need only demonstrate that the transaction altered creditor priority — a threshold that payment of an overdue invoice, for example, will routinely meet.

Transactions completed between one and six months before the filing date are also challengeable under the six-month window, but the insolvency manager must additionally establish that the creditor knew, or should have known, of the debtor's insolvency at the time of receipt. In the technology and software sector, this knowledge question is frequently contested: a foreign licensor receiving a scheduled subscription payment may have had no basis to suspect that its Russian customer was approaching insolvency — particularly where the customer continued operating, renewing licences, and expanding usage.

The practical consequence for technology and software creditors is that the nature of their payment — a single large upfront licence fee versus a series of smaller monthly subscription charges — determines which window is more likely to apply and which defences are realistically available.

If you have received a clawback demand from a Russian insolvency manager, or if a Russian counterparty has recently filed for bankruptcy, obtaining an early assessment of your Article 61.3 exposure is the priority. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 2. Identify which payments are realistically at risk

Not every payment made by a Russian debtor in the pre-insolvency period will be challenged. Insolvency managers work under practical and resource constraints, and Article 61.3 claims require court proceedings. Understanding which payments attract the highest clawback risk enables a creditor to prioritise its response.

Payments most likely to be challenged are those that: (a) fall within the one-month window; (b) are materially larger than prior payments in the same category; (c) were made after the debtor's last annual financial statements showed deteriorating equity or current ratio; or (d) were made in response to specific collection pressure — an overdue notice, a formal demand, or a pre-litigation letter.

In the technology and software sector, the following transaction types appear with particular frequency in Article 61.3 proceedings: upfront annual licence renewals paid shortly before filing; accelerated payments of deferred licence fees following a renegotiation; payment of accumulated arrears under a maintenance agreement in a single consolidated transfer; and early termination payments or settlement amounts under a software agreement. Each of these shares a structural feature that the insolvency manager will highlight: the timing and amount deviate from the regular payment pattern that preceded the period of financial distress.

For creditors with smaller, regularly recurring subscription or SaaS payments, the risk profile differs. Where a debtor paid monthly fees on or near their scheduled due dates, and where the payment amounts were consistent with the contract and with prior periods, the ordinary course of business defence is considerably stronger — though it is not automatic, and Russian courts have applied it with varying degrees of generosity depending on the specific factual record.

Step 3. How does the ordinary course of business defence work in practice?

The ordinary course of business defence is the primary substantive argument available to a creditor seeking to defeat an Article 61.3 clawback claim. Under Russian insolvency legislation, a preferential transaction may not be set aside where the payment was made in the ordinary course of business of the debtor and the creditor, in accordance with the terms of the relevant contract, and did not materially deviate from the parties' established pattern of dealing.

In practice, establishing this defence before a Russian arbitrazh court requires more than pointing to a valid contract. The court will examine: whether the payment was made on or close to its contractual due date; whether the amounts corresponded to the contracted sum, without acceleration or aggregation; whether the payment method was consistent with prior practice; and whether the creditor had any contemporaneous information suggesting the debtor's financial position had deteriorated materially.

For technology and software companies, this analysis benefits from the nature of their commercial arrangements. Subscription and SaaS models, by their structure, generate regular, predictable, recurring payment obligations on fixed or near-fixed dates for consistent amounts. Where the payment history over the 12 to 24 months preceding the filing date shows this regularity, the ordinary course defence is well-supported by the factual record.

The more challenging position arises where a technology creditor accepted late payments, negotiated a revised payment schedule, or agreed to aggregate multiple overdue invoices into a single payment. In those circumstances, Russian courts have generally been less receptive to an ordinary course argument, on the basis that the creditor's own conduct — accepting irregular payment behaviour over an extended period — undermines the claim that the later challenged payment was part of a normal, consistent course of dealing.

"The Article 61.3 ordinary course defence succeeds or fails on the factual record — a technology creditor with well-documented subscription payment history is in a materially stronger position than one whose payment pattern had already broken down." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

Which foreign creditors in the technology sector are most affected?

The Article 61.3 clawback mechanism applies to any creditor that received value from the debtor in the relevant lookback period — irrespective of the creditor's nationality or jurisdiction. Foreign companies providing technology products or software services to Russian entities under commercial contracts are squarely within scope.

Foreign creditors operating through a Russian subsidiary or branch face a structurally different position from those contracting directly with the Russian entity from abroad. A foreign parent whose Russian subsidiary received payments from the debtor holds its exposure at the subsidiary level. A foreign licensor contracting directly — a common structure in software licensing — is a direct creditor of the Russian estate and will be named directly in any clawback proceedings brought before the Russian arbitrazh court with jurisdiction over the debtor's insolvency.

For creditors based in jurisdictions that are EAEU or CIS members, the enforcement and procedural landscape once proceedings have been initiated is governed by the relevant multilateral frameworks, which can affect the mechanics of service of process, recognition of procedural steps, and coordination between the foreign creditor's local counsel and Russian insolvency proceedings. The practical effect varies by jurisdiction; creditors should verify the applicable bilateral or multilateral arrangement early in the proceedings.

Firms advising foreign technology clients with Russian contractual counterparties will often need a confirmed Russian insolvency counsel relationship before proceedings advance beyond the initial creditor registration stage. Speak to our team: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 4. Register as a creditor without delay

The Article 61.3 clawback risk does not exist in isolation from the broader creditor registration process. A foreign creditor that fails to register its claim in the Russian insolvency proceedings within the applicable deadline forfeits its ability to participate as a creditor of record — and, critically, loses the procedural standing that would allow it to challenge the insolvency manager's clawback decisions and to contest the insolvency manager's actions before the arbitrazh court.

Under Russian insolvency legislation, the standard creditor registration window following publication of the insolvency notice is 30 calendar days. Publication occurs in the official insolvency register (Fedresurs) and in the official gazette. Foreign creditors are not exempt from this deadline, and Russian courts have generally declined to restore the registration period for foreign creditors who did not monitor the register. The window is short and runs from publication, not from the date the creditor independently learns of the insolvency.

Creditors facing Article 61.3 clawback risk should be registered before the insolvency manager files any challenge — not because registration is a precondition to defending a clawback claim, but because creditor status gives access to the creditors' committee, to the insolvency manager's reports, and to procedural mechanisms to contest the manager's conduct. A creditor defending a clawback claim from outside the proceedings, without registered status, is operating with significantly reduced procedural leverage.

Under Russian insolvency proceedings, the insolvency manager — appointed by the court — acts as both estate administrator and the principal initiator of clawback claims. The insolvency manager has a statutory obligation to identify and challenge transactions that meet the Article 61.3 criteria. The manager's incentives are aligned with maximising estate recovery: a foreign technology creditor that received substantial payments in the lookback period should anticipate, rather than react to, a clawback challenge.

Step 5. Respond to the clawback claim procedurally and substantively

Once an Article 61.3 clawback claim has been filed against a foreign technology creditor in the Russian arbitrazh court, the proceedings follow the standard commercial litigation timetable of the Russian arbitrazh court system. The claim is assigned to the insolvency judge handling the debtor's bankruptcy proceedings — Russian insolvency claims are heard by specialist judges within the general commercial court hierarchy, not by separate insolvency tribunals.

A foreign creditor served with an Article 61.3 claim has a response deadline set by the court — typically 15 to 30 days from service. Missing this deadline does not automatically produce a default judgment in the Russian system, but failure to respond weakens the creditor's procedural position and signals to the court that the defence is not actively maintained. Where a foreign creditor has no Russian-qualified counsel already engaged, the service of a clawback claim is a time-critical moment.

The substantive response to an Article 61.3 claim will typically combine three elements: a challenge to the timing analysis (disputing the filing date reference point or the payment date); an ordinary course argument supported by the payment history and contractual record; and, where the six-month window applies, a rebuttal of the knowledge element — demonstrating that the creditor had no contemporaneous information about the debtor's insolvency at the time of the payment.

In the technology and software sector, the contractual and payment documentation that creditors already maintain as standard operational records — CRM data, subscription management records, invoicing systems, bank statements, email correspondence about renewal and payment — is precisely the material that supports these three lines of defence. A creditor that retrieves and organises this documentation promptly, before the response deadline, is in a substantially stronger position than one that attempts to reconstruct its payment history under time pressure.

Creditors who delay initiating a defensive engagement after learning of a bankruptcy filing risk narrowing their options considerably: by the time a clawback claim arrives, the procedural window for creditor registration may already have closed, and the opportunity to position the clawback response as part of a broader creditor strategy will have been lost.

If a Russian counterparty in the technology or software sector has entered insolvency proceedings, or if you have received correspondence from a Russian insolvency manager regarding payments you received, our restructuring and insolvency team is available for an initial 30-minute meeting — complimentary. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long does an Article 61.3 clawback case typically take to resolve before a Russian arbitrazh court?

A: Timeframes vary depending on the complexity of the payment history and whether the ordinary course defence is contested in detail, but the majority of first-instance Article 61.3 proceedings in Russian insolvency cases resolve within six to twelve months of the claim being filed. Appeals at the cassation level can extend total proceedings to 18 months or longer. In the technology sector, where the payment record is typically well-documented and the commercial structure is straightforward, first-instance proceedings tend to run at the shorter end of the range — provided the creditor is represented and responds promptly to procedural steps. The insolvency manager controls the timing of the original claim, and there is no mechanism for a creditor to accelerate the process before the claim is filed.

Q: What documents should a foreign technology creditor gather immediately upon learning of a Russian counterparty's insolvency?

A: The priority documents are: the signed commercial contract or licence agreement with the Russian entity; all invoices issued and payment confirmations received for the 24 months preceding the bankruptcy filing date; bank records showing the dates and amounts of transfers; any correspondence with the debtor about payment terms, extensions, or financial position in the 12 months before filing; and any previous contracts or renewal documents that establish the long-term pattern of dealing. Russian arbitrazh courts rely heavily on contemporaneous documentation — retrospective reconstructions of payment history are less persuasive than original records. Foreign creditors should retrieve and preserve this material before engaging Russian counsel, as it will define the scope and strength of the available defences.

Q: What happens if the clawback claim succeeds — does the creditor lose the payment entirely?

A: If the arbitrazh court sets aside a payment under Article 61.3, the creditor is required to return the amount to the bankruptcy estate. However, the creditor does not lose that amount outright: the returned sum generates a claim against the estate in the same category as the creditor's other unsecured claims. The practical consequence is that an unsecured creditor in an insolvent Russian estate typically recovers a fraction of its claim through the distribution process. The net economic loss from a successful clawback is therefore the difference between the full payment originally received and the eventual distribution on the restored unsecured claim — which, in heavily insolvent estates, may be significant. This is why contesting the clawback at the liability stage, rather than accepting it and relying on the estate claim, is generally the more economically rational approach for a creditor with a strong ordinary course defence.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry