Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

A practical guide to related-party transaction challenges in Russian bankruptcy for Korean creditors

Stanislav Lastovsky · September 2026 · 11 min read

Korean creditors face related-party transaction challenges in Russian insolvency that can erode recovery positions materially. Make an enquiry.

In the past several years of advising creditors in Russian insolvency proceedings, one pattern recurs reliably: Korean trade creditors and investors arrive with strong contractual positions and then discover that their Russian debtor completed a series of asset transfers to affiliated parties in the months before bankruptcy was filed. Under Russian insolvency legislation, those transfers can be challenged and reversed — but only if the creditor understands the mechanism, moves quickly, and assembles the right evidentiary package. This guide sets out the steps a Korean creditor should follow to identify, assess, and pursue related-party transaction challenges in Russian bankruptcy proceedings.

What to prepare before engaging in related-party transaction challenges

Before initiating any challenge, a Korean creditor — or its Russian counsel — should assemble a baseline documentation set. Missing materials cannot always be recovered once insolvency proceedings are under way, and the creditor who moves first in evidence-gathering tends to hold the stronger position throughout.

What to prepare:

Creditors who cannot produce this baseline at the outset of proceedings will depend on the insolvency manager to request it through court-assisted disclosure. That process adds time and introduces uncertainty about what the insolvency manager will actually pursue. For Korean creditors whose recovery strategy depends on clawing back transferred assets, early independent document assembly is the practical priority.

If you are a Korean creditor assessing exposure in Russian insolvency proceedings — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 1. Identify which transactions are challengeable under Russian law

The first analytical step is to determine whether any specific transfer is susceptible to challenge under Russian insolvency legislation. The relevant legal framework provides two principal grounds.

The first ground is the preferential payment — a transfer that gave one creditor a better position than it would have received in a standard insolvency distribution, made within a defined look-back period before the bankruptcy petition was filed. The look-back period for preferential payments to related parties is significantly longer than for arms-length transactions. This asymmetry is one of the most practically important features of the Russian framework for Korean creditors: a payment made to an affiliate two or three years before the petition date may be reachable, whereas the same payment to an unrelated creditor may not be.

The second ground is the suspicious transaction — a transfer made at an undervalue or with no genuine commercial rationale, causing harm to the general body of creditors. Suspicious transactions are assessed against the debtor's financial state at the time of the transfer: was the debtor insolvent, or did the transfer render it insolvent? Was the counterparty aware of that financial position? For related parties, Russian courts apply a rebuttable presumption of awareness — a feature that considerably shifts the burden of proof in the creditor's favour.

Korean creditors should note that the definition of "related party" under Russian insolvency legislation is broad. It covers not only direct shareholders and subsidiaries but also entities under common beneficial ownership, directors who sit on multiple boards, and in some circumstances, counterparties connected through contractual relationships that effectively give the other party control over the debtor's decisions. An assessment of relatedness is therefore a prerequisite to the rest of the challenge process and should not be assumed from corporate structure diagrams alone.

For detailed analysis of how Russian courts have interpreted related-party status in recent proceedings, see Deep-dive: related-party transaction challenges in Russian insolvency.

Step 2. Assess the look-back periods — and why timing determines everything

Related-party transactions in Russian bankruptcy are subject to materially different look-back windows than ordinary commercial transactions. For a Korean creditor, the practical consequence is that the date on which the bankruptcy petition was filed — not the date proceedings were formally opened — determines which transactions fall within scope.

Under the look-back framework applicable to suspicious transactions involving related parties, the window extends to three years before the petition date in cases involving transfers that caused harm to creditors. For preferential transfers to related parties, the applicable window under current practice is typically one year, though the specific period depends on the legal basis invoked. The insolvency manager and participating creditors may invoke multiple legal bases in a single challenge — it is standard practice to plead each available ground in the alternative.

The consequence of missing the limitation periods applicable to challenge applications is irreversible. Russian courts do not apply equitable tolling, and the insolvency manager's failure to act within time does not prevent a participating creditor from bringing its own challenge application — provided the creditor has the requisite standing and the application is filed within the applicable period. Korean creditors who have not yet engaged Russian counsel and who are aware of asset transfers made by their debtor in the two to three years preceding the petition should treat the limitation clock as live from the date they first obtained knowledge of the transfer.

Step 3. Participate effectively in the creditors' committee

For a Korean creditor to have standing to bring its own related-party transaction challenge — rather than relying entirely on the insolvency manager — it typically needs to be enrolled on the register of creditors and, in larger proceedings, to hold a threshold share of the total creditor claims. The creditors' committee is the primary procedural vehicle for this.

Enrolment on the creditor register requires the creditor to file its claim within the period set by the court in the order opening the insolvency proceedings. This period is short — typically two months from publication of the insolvency notice — and is measured from the date of publication in the official register (the Fedresurs system), not from the date the creditor actually becomes aware. Korean creditors who receive notice late — because they did not monitor Fedresurs or because notice was sent to an address that was not current — have limited remedies once the enrolment window has closed. The practical lesson is to monitor Fedresurs proactively for any Russian debtor with whom the creditor has material outstanding exposure.

If your Russian debtor has filed or been threatened with insolvency proceedings — speak to our team: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Once enrolled, a creditor holding at least ten per cent of the total claims — or a combination of creditors acting collectively — may bring a challenge application to the arbitrazh court directly if the insolvency manager declines or fails to act. The ten per cent threshold is calculated against the full register of enrolled creditors, not against the debtor's total liabilities. For a Korean creditor whose claim is large relative to the enrolled base, this standing requirement may be met comfortably. For those with smaller claims, forming a voting bloc with other foreign or domestic creditors is often the practical approach.

For context on how the Federal Tax Service — itself a major participating creditor in many Russian insolvencies — approaches related-party challenges and what Korean creditors can learn from FTS practice, see Federal Tax Service guidance on related-party transactions in insolvency.

Step 4. Build and present the challenge application

The challenge application is filed with the arbitrazh court handling the insolvency proceedings. It is not a separate action — it is a procedural motion within the existing case. The court that has jurisdiction over the insolvency has jurisdiction over all challenge applications arising from it, regardless of where the challenged transaction was executed or where the assets are located.

A well-constructed challenge application for a related-party transfer includes: a precise identification of the transaction and parties, a quantification of the loss suffered by the creditor body, the legal basis for challenge (ideally pleaded in the alternative), the evidentiary basis for the claimed relatedness, and any available evidence of the debtor's financial position at the date of transfer. The respondent in the challenge is the party who received the transferred asset — not the debtor — and that party has the right to submit a full defence. Courts will commonly order oral hearings in contested challenge applications.

In most circuits, the hearing timetable from filing to first substantive hearing is between three and six months. Enforcement of a successful challenge order — compelling the return of the asset or a monetary substitute — occurs within the same insolvency proceedings and typically does not require a separate writ of execution. The recovered asset or sum re-enters the insolvency estate and is distributed according to the statutory priority waterfall.

Korean creditors should be aware that the arbitrazh court may also consider whether Korean bilateral investment treaty protections are engaged by the facts of a particular matter — particularly where the challenged transfer involved assets that formed part of a Korean-owned investment in Russia. The intersection of Russian insolvency procedure with investment treaty protections is a developing area that warrants specific legal assessment on a case-by-case basis.

The firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice has acted for Korean and other foreign trade creditors in related-party transaction challenge proceedings before Siberian and Ural circuit arbitrazh courts. The firm is based in Novosibirsk, with direct procedural access to courts across the Siberian Federal District — a region where Korean manufacturing and trading interests have historically been concentrated.

Step 5. Enforce the outcome and manage post-challenge recovery

A successful challenge order does not automatically translate into cash in the creditor's account. The asset returned to the estate — whether physical property, a receivable, or a cash sum — re-enters the priority waterfall. For Korean creditors holding ordinary unsecured claims, this means that secured creditors and preferential statutory claims (tax authorities, employees) are satisfied first. The practical value of a challenge therefore depends heavily on the size and composition of the senior-ranking claims.

This dynamic explains why challenging related-party transactions is most valuable when combined with a broader creditor strategy — which may include challenging the basis of competing secured claims, seeking to have certain preferential claims recharacterised, or participating in the plan of restructuring if the debtor proposes one. In complex cross-border insolvencies involving Korean creditors, the Russian insolvency proceedings are often only one element of a multi-jurisdictional recovery, which may extend to EAEU member states where the debtor has assets.

Two further points bear emphasis. First, Korean creditors should assess whether any assets of the debtor are located outside Russia — in other EAEU member states or third-country jurisdictions — and whether parallel proceedings or recognition applications are available in those jurisdictions. Second, the timeline for the entire challenge-and-recovery cycle is rarely under twelve months and commonly extends to two years or more in heavily contested proceedings. Creditors who plan their liquidity management around an early recovery will need to revise those assumptions.

For Korean creditors seeking to understand recovery prospects in a specific Russian insolvency matter — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long does a related-party transaction challenge typically take in Russian insolvency proceedings?

A: The timeline from filing a challenge application to a first-instance court decision is typically between six and twelve months, depending on the complexity of the dispute and the circuit. Cassation appeals — available to both the applicant and the respondent — add a further three to six months in most cases. Heavily contested challenges involving multiple transactions or disputed relatedness findings can extend beyond two years from application to final resolution. Korean creditors should treat the challenge process as a medium-to-long-term recovery mechanism rather than an expedient route to cash.

Q: What documents does a Korean creditor need to support a related-party transaction challenge in Russia?

A: The core evidentiary requirements are: documentary proof of the transaction itself (contract, payment records), evidence establishing the relatedness of the counterparty to the debtor, documentation of the debtor's financial position at the date of the transfer, and evidence of the market value of the transferred asset. Corporate registry extracts, financial statements, and communications evidencing knowledge of insolvency are all material. Korean creditors who cannot produce the full evidentiary package from their own records can request court-assisted disclosure, though this adds time and depends on the insolvency manager's cooperation or the court's willingness to compel disclosure from the respondent.

Q: What happens if the insolvency manager refuses to bring a related-party transaction challenge?

A: A creditor — or group of creditors — with the requisite standing may bring a challenge application directly if the insolvency manager declines to act. The threshold for direct standing is typically ten per cent of the total enrolled creditor claims. If the creditor's claim is below that threshold, coordinating with other creditors to meet the collective threshold is the standard approach. Where the insolvency manager's refusal appears to reflect a conflict of interest — for example, where the manager was appointed at the initiative of a connected creditor — the creditor may also apply to the court to have the manager replaced.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry