Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

A practical guide to moratorium provisions in Russian insolvency legislation at the subsidiary liability claims stage for foreign companies

Stanislav Lastovsky · May 2026 · 11 min read

Russian insolvency moratoria freeze subsidiary liability claims against directors for years. What foreign creditors must do — and when. Make an enquiry.

Unlike the automatic stay provisions common in English or German insolvency law, the Russian moratorium in insolvency proceedings is not a single, uniform mechanism. It is a graduated instrument whose precise scope — and whose interaction with subsidiary liability claims against former controllers — depends on the stage of proceedings, the category of creditor, and decisions the insolvency administrator and the creditors' committee have already made. For foreign trade creditors holding claims against a Russian debtor whose directors or controlling shareholders may be personally exposed, understanding when the moratorium applies, when it does not, and what procedural steps preserve recovery options is the difference between a timely claim and one that is barred or diluted by later-arriving creditors.

Step 1 — Understand what the Russian insolvency moratorium is and when it applies

The moratorium under Russian insolvency legislation is the legal suspension of enforcement actions and certain creditor remedies that takes effect upon the initiation of a formal insolvency procedure. In its most consequential form, it activates at the observation stage and continues through, and typically until the conclusion of, the principal insolvency stages. Its practical effect for a foreign creditor is immediate: execution proceedings already running against the debtor are suspended, enforcement of pledges is halted, and the debtor's management cannot unilaterally satisfy individual creditor claims outside the statutory queue.

The moratorium covers obligations of the debtor entity. However, it does not — as a general rule — directly suspend proceedings against third parties, including controllers, directors, and beneficial owners who may face subsidiary liability claims. That distinction is critical, and its misapplication causes foreign creditors to delay subsidiary liability action on the incorrect assumption that the moratorium bars all parallel recovery routes.

For creditors whose underlying contractual claim is against the debtor, the moratorium triggers registration in the creditors' register — the mechanism through which claims are recognised and ranked. Failure to register within statutory periods produces consequences that cannot be undone. The moratorium is therefore not merely a procedural pause; it is a clock that reshapes the creditor's entire enforcement posture.

If your Russian counterparty has entered insolvency proceedings and you have not yet registered your claim, the registration window is time-critical — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What documents should a foreign creditor prepare before the moratorium deadline?

Before engaging with the Russian insolvency procedure, a foreign creditor should assemble: the underlying contract and all amendments; delivery records, invoices, and payment history; correspondence evidencing the debt and any default; any Russian-law or cross-border security documents; and, where relevant, documentation identifying the controllers or beneficial owners of the debtor. If the debt was evidenced in a foreign judgment or arbitral award already obtained, that document and any enforcement history should also be gathered. These materials serve dual purposes: they support the registration of the creditor's claim in the insolvency register, and they provide the evidentiary foundation for any subsequent subsidiary liability claim against former management.

Step 2 — Map the moratorium's specific effect on subsidiary liability claims

Subsidiary liability in Russian insolvency law is the mechanism by which a court may hold controllers — typically former directors, majority shareholders, or other persons whose instructions the debtor followed — personally liable for the debtor's obligations when their actions caused or contributed to the insolvency. This is a distinct claim, brought in the name of the debtor's estate, that runs against individuals or entities separate from the insolvent debtor itself.

The moratorium's direct reach does not extend to subsidiary liability proceedings in the same way it affects enforcement against the debtor. Russian courts have consistently treated subsidiary liability claims as estate assets — rights belonging to the estate to assert against third parties — rather than as obligations of the debtor suspended by the moratorium. As a result, the insolvency administrator (or, in certain circumstances, creditors acting collectively) may commence, continue, or prepare subsidiary liability proceedings during the moratorium period without the moratorium acting as a bar.

The practical tension arises from a different direction. While the moratorium does not bar subsidiary liability proceedings, several procedural requirements must be met before such a claim can be brought. The debtor's creditors' register must typically be closed or substantially complete. Evidence of controller fault must be documented and, where possible, obtained from the administrator through the court. And the insolvency stage — observation, financial rehabilitation, external management, or bankruptcy proceedings proper — determines which procedural route is available. A foreign creditor who has not registered in time loses standing to participate in the subsidiary liability claim, because standing flows from recognised creditor status.

Step 3 — Monitor creditor-specific exceptions and carve-outs from the moratorium's scope

Not all obligations are subject to the moratorium with equal force. Russian insolvency legislation recognises categories of current obligations — debts arising after the commencement of insolvency proceedings — that the debtor may and, in certain cases, must continue to service. These current obligations are not suspended by the moratorium and are satisfied ahead of pre-insolvency registered claims.

For a foreign creditor, the distinction between a pre-insolvency claim and a current claim has material consequences. If goods were delivered or services rendered after the insolvency petition was filed, or if the debtor entered into obligations after that date, those obligations may qualify as current claims and attract priority treatment. Creditors who fail to identify and categorise their claims correctly — registering a current claim as a pre-insolvency claim, or vice versa — expose themselves to ranking errors that reduce recovery.

At the subsidiary liability claims stage, controller misconduct relating to current obligations can be specifically relevant. Courts have examined whether controllers directed the debtor to accumulate current obligations it could not service, or to prefer certain creditors in violation of the moratorium's equal-treatment requirement. These fact patterns can strengthen subsidiary liability claims where they are established.

Step 4 — File your claim at the right procedural moment

Timing is the most consequential variable in a foreign creditor's Russian insolvency strategy. Under Russian insolvency legislation, preferential transfer claims — and the window within which controllers' conduct may be examined — can extend to transactions completed up to three years before the bankruptcy petition. Foreign creditors unfamiliar with Russian insolvency practice frequently underestimate this lookback, and consequently fail to preserve or gather evidence during the early stages of proceedings when it remains accessible.

For the underlying registered claim, deadlines run from the date of publication of the bankruptcy notice in the official gazette. Missing the initial registration period does not automatically extinguish the claim, but late-registered creditors are placed behind timely-registered creditors in queue ranking — a material difference in any distribution where assets are limited.

For subsidiary liability proceedings specifically, the application to the court is typically made during the bankruptcy proceedings stage rather than at observation or external management. The insolvency administrator has primary standing to bring the claim; individual creditors acquire independent standing once prescribed thresholds of creditor participation are met. A foreign creditor who has engaged qualified Russian insolvency counsel from the outset — attending creditors' meetings, voting on administrator mandates, and monitoring the administrator's conduct — is best positioned to exercise that standing.

For creditors who identify that the administrator is failing to pursue meritorious subsidiary liability claims, Russian insolvency procedure provides mechanisms to challenge that inaction. These mechanisms require active creditor participation in the proceedings and, in practice, coordinated action among multiple registered creditors. Foreign creditors acting alone rarely achieve sufficient procedural weight without coalition support or a formal creditor committee mandate.

For creditors considering a coordinated subsidiary liability strategy in Russian insolvency proceedings — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 5 — Navigate post-moratorium recovery and enforcement

When bankruptcy proceedings reach their conclusion and the debtor is formally liquidated, the moratorium's practical scope narrows — but it does not disappear entirely until the legal entity is struck from the register. Creditors whose registered claims were not satisfied in distribution retain the right to pursue subsidiary liability claims already commenced, and in some circumstances to initiate them within prescribed post-conclusion periods.

Enforcement of a subsidiary liability judgment runs against the controller as an individual or legal entity, not against the debtor estate. This distinction means that enforcement proceeds through ordinary civil execution channels — attachment of personal assets, real property, bank accounts, and shareholdings of the controller. For foreign creditors, where the controller holds assets across multiple jurisdictions, this stage may involve cross-border asset tracing and recognition proceedings in other legal systems.

Vetrov & Partners has acted for foreign trade creditors in subsidiary liability matters in Russian insolvency proceedings — including matters involving controllers with assets in Russia and other jurisdictions. In a recent engagement, the firm assisted a foreign creditor in establishing the evidentiary basis for a subsidiary liability claim during the observation and bankruptcy stages, resulting in a court finding of controller liability and a favourable distribution outcome.

The post-moratorium phase also brings limitation period considerations specific to subsidiary liability. The applicable limitations run from the moment the creditor knew or ought to have known of the basis for the claim — a fact-specific assessment that Russian courts make based on the creditor's participation record in the insolvency proceedings. Creditors who were passive during proceedings face argument that their limitation period began to run earlier than they assumed.

What to prepare — practical checklist for foreign creditors

Frequently asked questions

Q: Does the Russian insolvency moratorium prevent a foreign creditor from pursuing subsidiary liability proceedings against a director?

A: No, not as a direct bar. The moratorium suspends enforcement actions against the debtor entity and freezes the debtor's obligations, but subsidiary liability proceedings run against controllers as third parties — not against the debtor. Russian courts treat the right to bring subsidiary liability claims as an asset of the estate, not an obligation suspended by the moratorium. However, procedural standing to participate in or compel such proceedings flows from timely registration in the creditors' register. A creditor who has not registered a valid claim lacks the procedural standing to drive the subsidiary liability process, even if the moratorium itself is not the bar. The effective constraint, for most foreign creditors, is registration timing rather than the moratorium's direct reach.

Q: What happens to a foreign creditor's registered claim if the debtor's assets are insufficient to satisfy it in full?

A: In practice, full satisfaction from the debtor's estate is the exception rather than the rule in Russian insolvency proceedings. Most creditors recover a fraction of the registered claim — or nothing — from estate assets alone. This is precisely why subsidiary liability proceedings against controllers are of strategic importance: a successful claim produces a judgment against an individual or entity with separate assets, potentially including assets held outside Russia. The subsidiary liability route supplements — and in many cases exceeds in recovery value — what the registered creditor can expect from the estate. For foreign creditors, the subsidiary liability judgment may be enforceable through recognition proceedings in the controller's home jurisdiction or in the jurisdiction where assets are held.

Q: How long do Russian insolvency proceedings typically last, and how does this affect the moratorium's duration?

A: Russian insolvency proceedings are often multi-year processes. The observation stage alone commonly extends to six or seven months; bankruptcy proceedings proper can run for one to three years, and in complex matters with significant assets or contested subsidiary liability claims, proceedings may extend further. The moratorium tracks this timeline — its practical effect on registered creditors' ability to take unilateral enforcement action continues throughout. For foreign creditors this extended timeline has two implications: it amplifies the importance of early registration and active participation, and it provides a window during which subsidiary liability evidence can be gathered, administrator conduct can be monitored, and coalition creditor positions can be coordinated. Counsel engaged at the observation stage can use this window constructively; counsel engaged after the bankruptcy stage is well advanced faces a significantly constrained evidence and strategy landscape.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry