Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Strategic notes on Article 61.2 transaction challenges in Russian insolvency for cross-border practitioners

Stanislav Lastovsky · September 2026 · 5 min read

Article 61.2 challenges are the most demanding aspect of Russian insolvency for foreign counsel. Timing and forum strategy are decisive. Make an enquiry.

Foreign law firms instructing Russian insolvency counsel frequently encounter Article 61.2 of the Russian Insolvency Law as the central battleground of a bankruptcy matter – whether they are advancing a challenge on behalf of a creditor or defending a counterparty whose transaction is under attack. The provision governs the avoidance of transactions concluded on terms prejudicial to the creditor body or for unequal consideration, and its procedural mechanics differ materially from transaction avoidance regimes under English, German, or Dutch law. For cross-border practitioners, understanding where Russian court practice diverges from statutory text is as important as understanding the statute itself.

What the rule requires and where the complexity lies

Article 61.2 establishes two distinct avoidance grounds, each carrying a different suspect period and a different evidentiary threshold. The shorter period – broadly, one year before the filing date – applies to transactions involving unequal counter-performance: where the debtor received materially less than market value. The longer period – up to three years before filing – applies to transactions that intentionally or effectively caused damage to the general creditor body. Courts assess both the objective economic result of the transaction and the knowledge or constructive knowledge of the counterparty at the time of execution.

In practice, the distinction between the two grounds matters enormously for strategy. A challenge brought on the shorter-period ground is, in principle, easier to establish: the focus is on the transaction price relative to a verifiable market comparator. A longer-period challenge is analytically more demanding but correspondingly more powerful where the transaction is deeply value-destructive or where the counterparty had a relationship with the debtor that a court will scrutinise for bad faith.

Three procedural features consistently catch foreign instructing counsel by surprise. First, Russian courts assess the suspect period from the date of the bankruptcy petition's acceptance by the court, not from the date of any insolvency declaration or creditor vote – a distinction that shifts the relevant window and that, in some matters, excludes transactions that foreign counsel expected to fall within scope. Second, the evidentiary standard for establishing counterparty knowledge is objective rather than subjective in the longer-period cases: affiliation, common ownership, and commercially abnormal transaction terms are treated as giving rise to a presumption of awareness, without requiring proof of actual knowledge. Third, the burden of rebuttal falls on the counterparty once a prima facie case is established – a reversal of the usual allocation that can leave a defending party with an unexpectedly difficult disclosure problem if they did not anticipate the proceedings.

On the creditor side, the practical consequence is that an application under Article 61.2 must be structured from the outset around the available evidence of market pricing, the timeline of the debtor's financial deterioration, and any available indicia of counterparty awareness. Presenting these elements in the order and form that Russian arbitrazh courts expect – rather than in the form that would be natural in an English witness statement or German expert report – is a technical question for local counsel to lead on, but one that foreign instructing firms need to understand before the matter reaches the filing stage.

For a broader procedural map of Article 61.2 challenges in the context of ongoing insolvency proceedings, see Navigating Article 61.2 Transaction Challenges and Russian Supreme Court Clarification on Article 61.2.

How this affects cross-border coordination in practice

When foreign law firms instruct local Russian counsel in an Article 61.2 matter, the coordination risk concentrates at two points: the initial framing of the application and the management of evidence obtained outside Russia.

On framing: the grounds available under Article 61.2 do not map cleanly onto the conceptual vocabulary of foreign transaction avoidance regimes. An application structured around the concept of "preference" – a term familiar from English insolvency law – will not translate directly into Russian court practice, where the applicable concept is damage to the creditor body assessed against the economic position of those creditors at the date of the transaction. Foreign instructing counsel who draft their instructions in preference-vocabulary risk receiving an application that is procedurally accurate but strategically suboptimal for the specific Russian court practice they are engaging.

On evidence: documents obtained pursuant to foreign disclosure orders, letters rogatory, or foreign corporate filings require careful handling in Russian insolvency proceedings. Russian arbitrazh courts do not operate a disclosure regime analogous to common-law discovery. Evidence from foreign sources must be presented in Russian-language certified translation, notarised and, where applicable, apostilled. Timing matters: evidence submitted late – or in a form that the court does not recognise as properly authenticated – is frequently excluded rather than given reduced weight, which can be dispositive in a closely contested challenge.

A note on limitation: Article 61.2 applications are subject to time constraints running from the date at which the insolvency manager or the creditor concerned could reasonably have been expected to discover the transaction. In practice, this is a fact-specific determination that Russian courts do not apply mechanically – but instructing counsel should not assume that a transaction discovered late in the insolvency proceedings remains challengeable without analysis of whether the discovery-date argument is available and robust.

The firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice works regularly with foreign instructing firms on Article 61.2 mandates, from preliminary assessment of challenge prospects through to proceedings and enforcement of the avoidance judgment. Coordination with the instructing firm's timeline and client expectations is a standard feature of how these matters are structured.

For foreign law firms assessing an Article 61.2 challenge or coordinating with Russian insolvency counsel on a live matter, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry