Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Restructuring & Insolvency

Drafting issues in pre-packaged restructuring options under Russian law: common pitfalls

Stanislav Lastovsky · September 2026 · 5 min read

Drafting flaws in Russian prepackaged restructuring proposals cause plan rejections. A practitioner note for instructing counsel. Make an enquiry.

Pre-packaged restructuring proposals under Russian insolvency legislation are rejected by courts and creditor assemblies more often than practitioners unfamiliar with Russian procedure expect. The drafting standards applied by Russian arbitrazh courts are exacting, and a plan that would satisfy the threshold requirements in a German or English insolvency process will frequently fall short when measured against Russian court practice. This note identifies the most consequential drafting failures encountered in practice and is directed at foreign law firms instructing Russian counsel on behalf of creditors or debtor entities in cross-border restructuring matters.

What the drafting requirements demand

Under Russian insolvency legislation, a restructuring proposal — whether presented as part of a financial rehabilitation regime or as a pre-agreed plan submitted to the court-supervised procedure — must satisfy a series of formal and substantive requirements that go beyond a simple statement of repayment mechanics.

The plan must contain a credible cash-flow analysis demonstrating that the debtor can service restructured obligations over the proposed term. Russian courts have consistently required this analysis to be grounded in documented assumptions, not projections unsupported by financial statements or independent assessments. Where the debtor is a subsidiary of a foreign group, Russian courts will typically expect the financial analysis to reflect the subsidiary's standalone position in Russia, not consolidated group figures.

Creditor consent requirements under Russian insolvency legislation operate on a class-voting basis. The threshold for plan adoption — and the precise scope of the creditor classes whose assent is required — depends on the specific procedural stage and on whether secured creditors are separately classified. A plan that correctly maps consent thresholds in English or German terms will still fail if it mis-describes the Russian class structure or inadvertently excludes a creditor class whose negative vote could defeat confirmation.

The plan must also address the position of the insolvency administrator. Under the standard interpretation applied by Russian courts, the administrator has an independent duty to assess the plan's viability and to report to the court. Plans that do not account for this role — or that assume the administrator will be passive — encounter resistance at the court confirmation stage.

Note: Where the plan contemplates a moratorium on enforcement actions, the scope of that moratorium under Russian insolvency legislation is defined by the statute, not by the plan. Drafting that seeks to extend or modify the statutory moratorium is typically disregarded by Russian courts rather than invalidated, which can create a gap between what the plan promises creditors and what Russian law actually delivers. Instructing counsel should identify this mismatch at the drafting stage rather than at the confirmation hearing.

Where the common pitfalls arise

In practice, the following drafting failures account for the majority of plan rejections and confirmation delays observed in Russian insolvency proceedings.

Mischaracterisation of the procedure type. Russian insolvency legislation distinguishes between several rehabilitation mechanisms, and the drafting obligations are specific to each. Plans drafted for one procedure type are sometimes submitted — without adaptation — under a different regime. Russian courts will not cure this defect; they will return the plan or decline to confirm it.

Failure to specify the monitoring mechanism. Russian courts have generally required that restructuring plans include a defined monitoring or reporting obligation enforceable within the proceedings. Plans that treat post-confirmation compliance as an external matter, governed solely by contract between the debtor and creditors, are vulnerable to rejection on this ground.

Inconsistency between the plan and the creditor register. The creditor register in Russian insolvency proceedings is a court-maintained document. A plan that references debt amounts, priority rankings, or creditor classes that do not correspond precisely to the register as of the filing date will be treated as defective. Where the register is in dispute — which is common in cross-border matters involving intercompany claims or foreign-law security arrangements — the plan must either acknowledge the dispute and contain fallback provisions, or await register stabilisation before submission.

Inadequate treatment of Russian-law governed security. Foreign creditors holding pledges or mortgages over Russian assets are separately classified in Russian insolvency proceedings. Plans that fail to identify and correctly classify these creditors, or that propose treatments inconsistent with the statutory priority afforded to secured creditors under Russian insolvency legislation, will not be confirmed.

Translation and notarisation defects. Where supporting documents originate outside Russia, Russian courts require certified translation and, in some cases, apostille or legalisation. Plans submitted with uncertified translations or with foreign-language annexes that have not been formally rendered into Russian are routinely returned on procedural grounds — a delay that can be critical if the moratorium is time-limited.

What instructing counsel should verify

For foreign law firms instructing Russian counsel on a restructuring matter, the following verification steps are advisable before a draft plan is submitted to the Russian court or presented to the creditor assembly.

Confirm that the plan has been prepared specifically for the procedural stage as it currently stands in the Russian proceedings — not adapted from a template used in a prior or parallel foreign proceeding. Russian procedural stages are sequential and their documentary requirements differ materially.

Confirm that the creditor register has been reviewed in its current form and that the plan reflects the register accurately, including any claims under appeal. Where intercompany claims are registered, confirm that the plan's treatment of those claims is defensible under the arm's-length standard applied by Russian courts.

Confirm that all annexes — financial models, valuation reports, consent resolutions — have been prepared in Russian or accompanied by certified translations, and that the originals bear the authentication required for foreign-origin documents.

Russian court practice in restructuring confirmation hearings varies by circuit. Practitioners in the Siberian Federal District and Ural circuit — jurisdictions frequently involved in matters with natural-resource or industrial-sector debtors — have observed that judges in these circuits apply particularly close scrutiny to the financial modelling section of a restructuring plan. This is a relevant consideration when instructing local Russian counsel: the standard of drafting that passes without challenge in Moscow courts may require additional substantiation in Siberian or Ural proceedings.

For firms instructing Russian counsel on prepackaged restructuring options and seeking a reliable local procedure note, the Restructuring & Insolvency practice page sets out the firm's approach to creditor-side mandates.

See also the related briefings on legislative developments affecting pre-packaged restructuring in Russia: Legislative amendment affecting pre-packaged restructuring options and Pre-packaged restructuring options under Russian law.

To discuss a cross-border restructuring matter or request a procedure review for a specific Russian filing — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry