Russian arbitrazh courts are applying Article 122 tax penalties more strictly in 2026. Foreign subsidiaries face heightened exposure. Make an enquiry.
Alert: Russian development affecting tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts under Article 122 of the Tax Code Effective: January 2026
Russian arbitrazh courts have in recent months applied a noticeably stricter standard when assessing whether tax underpayments under Article 122 of the Tax Code are attributable to ordinary error or to intentional conduct. This distinction is material: the standard penalty for non-payment or underpayment is 20% of the unpaid amount, but courts that classify the underpayment as intentional are authorised to impose a penalty of 40%. In a number of recent proceedings, courts have reclassified underpayments that companies characterised as inadvertent into the higher bracket, substantially increasing the financial exposure beyond what the initial Federal Tax Service assessment indicated.
Foreign subsidiaries, joint ventures with foreign participation, and Russian entities whose ultimate beneficial ownership is abroad are among those most directly affected. In practice, cross-border transfer pricing arrangements, intercompany loan structures, and royalty payments to foreign affiliates have attracted particular attention in the current audit cycle. Where the Federal Tax Service characterises these arrangements as generating intentional underpayment, the case proceeds to arbitrazh court with a 40% penalty demand already on record — and courts have shown a reduced willingness to substitute the lower rate on the basis of taxpayer good faith alone.
Separately, the pre-trial mandatory appeal procedure that must be exhausted before an arbitrazh claim can be filed has, in the current environment, added procedural delay while the exposure continues to accrue. Companies that have received a Federal Tax Service decision and are assessing their litigation options should factor this timeline carefully into their response strategy.
Recommended action:
Review any open Federal Tax Service audit or outstanding tax demand to assess whether the underpayment characterisation is contested or likely to be contested.Obtain a legal assessment of the intentionality threshold as courts are currently applying it — specifically whether existing documentation is sufficient to rebut an intentionality finding.If a pre-trial appeal is pending or imminent, confirm the mandatory procedural timeline before instructing arbitrazh proceedings.
For advice on tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts and the implications of Article 122 of the Tax Code for your Russian operations, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Further reading: Tax Controversy | Tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts | A practical guide to tax litigation before Russian courts
-- Kristina Kornouhova Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead -- Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners vetrovpartners.com/kornouhova/
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry