Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Landmark decision on criminal tax liability interface under Article 199 of the Russian Criminal Code: what it means for foreign parties

Kristina Kornouhova · September 2026 · 5 min read

Russian courts have clarified the criminal tax liability interface under Article 199. Foreign subsidiaries should review their exposure. Make an enquiry.

In a decision handed down in the second quarter of 2027, a Russian cassation court addressed a question that in-house counsel at foreign subsidiaries have monitored with sustained concern: at what point does a tax dispute with the Federal Tax Service cross from an administrative matter into criminal liability exposure under Article 199 of the Russian Criminal Code. The ruling refines the criteria governing this transition and clarifies procedural conditions that courts had applied inconsistently across circuits. For general counsel managing Russian operations, the implications are concrete.

Background

The liability regime under Article 199 of the Russian Criminal Code targets deliberate non-payment or underpayment of corporate taxes at scale. The provision applies where the unpaid amount exceeds a prescribed statutory threshold, assessed either as an absolute figure or as a proportion of the total tax liability over a defined accounting period. In practice, the pathway to criminal exposure runs through a Federal Tax Service field audit: FTS inspectors identify the alleged underpayment, issue a notice of arrears, and — where the amount satisfies the statutory criteria — refer the matter to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation.

The complication for foreign-owned companies arises at this interface. The audit proceeds against the Russian legal entity; the criminal referral names individuals responsible for the company's tax compliance, typically directors or chief accountants. For foreign shareholders whose Russian subsidiaries are managed by locally appointed directors, the question of where ultimate criminal exposure lies had not, before this ruling, been answered consistently by Russian courts. Lower courts across different circuits had reached divergent conclusions on two related points: whether the intentionality element of Article 199 could be established by conduct short of personal document signing, and whether civil tax proceedings had to be exhausted before criminal proceedings could commence.

What did the court decide?

In the matter under review, the cassation court considered an appeal arising from a tax enforcement case in which earlier courts had confined criminal liability to those who directly signed the relevant tax declarations. The challenge argued that effective control — exercised through corporate governance structures rather than direct signing authority — should be sufficient to satisfy the intentionality element that Article 199 requires.

The cassation court upheld the broader interpretation. In its reasoning, the court confirmed that intentionality may be established by reference to conduct demonstrating knowledge of the underpayment and a decision not to rectify it, regardless of whether the individual personally signed the relevant submission. Critically, the court further held that civil tax proceedings between the company and the FTS do not need to reach a final resolution before criminal proceedings are commenced — a position that had divided lower courts and that carries immediate procedural significance for companies managing an active FTS dispute.

"This ruling shifts the risk calculus for any in-house counsel overseeing an FTS audit. The parallel-track question — civil enforcement and criminal referral running simultaneously — is no longer a theoretical edge case." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing an active FTS audit or monitoring criminal exposure risk in a Russian subsidiary, early legal engagement can determine what options remain available. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What does this ruling mean for foreign clients?

For general counsel advising a foreign parent with a Russian subsidiary, the practical effect falls across three areas.

The first concerns governance documentation. If effective control — rather than formal signatory authority — can satisfy the intentionality element, then internal records showing that a foreign parent approved or directed a tax position become potentially relevant to a criminal investigation. Subsidiaries operating under consolidated tax instructions from a head office should consider how those instructions are documented, communicated, and retained.

The second concerns the sequencing of disputes. The ruling confirms that a criminal investigation is not contingent on the exhaustion of civil remedies. FTS and the Investigative Committee may proceed in parallel. For in-house counsel managing an active FTS field audit, this changes the risk exposure: what was previously managed as a financial dispute may carry concurrent criminal risk from an earlier procedural stage than previously assumed. Foreign groups that have historically engaged Russian counsel only at the enforcement stage should revisit that approach in light of this clarification.

The third concerns external counsel coordination. Where a criminal referral may involve a foreign parent's personnel, engaging Russian tax counsel at the audit stage — rather than after referral — materially affects the range of available responses. This is particularly relevant for foreign shareholders whose governance practices could, under the court's reasoning, be characterised as demonstrating the required intentionality.

If your Russian subsidiary is under FTS audit or you are reviewing criminal tax exposure for foreign management personnel, speak to our team in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling clarifies two points that lower courts had treated inconsistently. First, it confirms that intentionality under Article 199 of the Russian Criminal Code can be established by demonstrating effective control and awareness of an underpayment, without requiring that the individual personally signed the relevant tax declaration. Second, it confirms that criminal proceedings may be commenced before civil tax enforcement proceedings against the company have concluded. Together, these points mean that an FTS audit — even one still in its assessment phase — may now carry concurrent criminal risk for individuals who exercised control over the company's tax affairs.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, review the governance and documentation trail for tax positions taken in Russian subsidiaries: how instructions were given, whether those instructions created a record of awareness of any underpayment risk, and who is named in relevant communications. Second, ensure that external Russian counsel is engaged from the audit stage, not only after a criminal referral is made — the procedural options available to the company and its personnel narrow considerably once a referral is in place. Third, consider whether the current scope of Russian counsel instructions covers criminal exposure advice as well as civil tax defence, given that both proceedings may now run simultaneously under the framework confirmed by this ruling. The Tax Controversy practice at Vetrov & Partners advises on both tracks.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry