Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Case comment: VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups

Kristina Kornouhova · October 2026 · 6 min read

Russian courts are raising the bar for VAT refund claims in foreign-owned groups. What the latest ruling means for in-house counsel. Make an enquiry.

In the past two years of advising multinational groups on their Russian tax positions, one recurrent pressure point has stood out: the Federal Tax Service's treatment of VAT refund claims filed by Russian subsidiaries whose transactions run upward to foreign parent companies or intermediate holding structures. Auditors have grown progressively more sceptical of the commercial rationale underpinning intra-group supply chains, and that scepticism has increasingly found support in the courts. A recent ruling from a cassation-level arbitrazh court crystallised this trend in terms that in-house counsel overseeing Russian operations should understand before the next audit cycle begins.

Background

VAT refund disputes in foreign-owned Russian groups arise from a structural tension that is specific to how Russian VAT law interacts with cross-border corporate arrangements. A Russian operating subsidiary that purchases goods or services — whether from a domestic supplier or through an importation chain — accumulates input VAT credits that it is entitled to recover when those credits exceed its output VAT liability. In practice, this situation arises most commonly in capital-intensive start-up phases, in seasonal trading businesses, and in distribution structures where the Russian entity purchases at standard VAT rates but sells to VAT-exempt or partially exempt customers.

The difficulty for foreign-owned groups is not the legal entitlement itself: that is well-established under Russian tax legislation. The difficulty is evidentiary. The Federal Tax Service has, over several audit cycles, developed a line of challenge focused not on the subsidiary's immediate transaction documentation but on the broader commercial coherence of the group's structure. Auditors ask whether the intra-group supply chain has a purpose beyond VAT optimisation, whether pricing reflects arm's-length conditions, and whether the foreign beneficial owner's involvement adds genuine economic substance to the transaction.

These challenges feed directly into Tax Controversy disputes that can be costly and protracted, particularly where the Russian entity's refund position is material to the group's working capital. The Russian Supreme Court clarification on VAT refund procedure has previously addressed some of the procedural aspects of these disputes, but the substantive evidentiary standard remained less settled until the ruling examined here.

The decision

In a decision handed down in early 2027, a cassation arbitrazh court reviewed an appeal by a Russian trading subsidiary wholly owned through a series of intermediate holding entities registered in European Union jurisdictions. The subsidiary had claimed a VAT refund on purchases made under a distribution agreement, the counterparty to which was a related domestic entity. The Federal Tax Service had denied the refund on the basis that the arrangement lacked business purpose beyond the artificial generation of input VAT credits. The first-instance court and the appellate court had both upheld the tax authority's position.

At cassation, the court confirmed the denial but, critically, it elaborated on the evidentiary standard that Russian courts will apply when assessing whether a VAT refund claim by a foreign-owned group is substantiated. The court distinguished between two categories of documentation deficiency. The first is a formal deficiency — missing invoices, incomplete contracts, absent delivery confirmations — which, standing alone, does not justify denial of a VAT refund claim if the underlying economic reality of the transaction is otherwise established. The second is a substantive deficiency — the absence of evidence that the transaction served a genuine commercial purpose independent of its tax consequences — and this, the court held, is sufficient to sustain a Federal Tax Service denial even where formal documentation is complete.

The ruling's significance lies in where it places the burden. The court made clear that, once the Federal Tax Service has established a prima facie case of artificial structuring, the evidential burden shifts to the taxpayer to demonstrate positive commercial purpose. General statements about the efficiency of centralised procurement or the benefits of group-level supply arrangements were found insufficient. The subsidiary had produced group-level policy documentation but could not point to contemporaneous evidence of the commercial rationale for the specific transaction under review.

"The court's reasoning signals that Russian auditors will now enter VAT refund disputes armed with a procedural advantage: a successful prima facie showing shifts the burden immediately, and group-level documentation is no longer a reliable answer." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead – Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

If your Russian subsidiary is approaching an audit cycle with a material VAT refund position, make an enquiry before the audit opens rather than after — info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign-owned Russian groups

The ruling does not alter the legal entitlement to a VAT refund, but it reconfigures the practical conditions under which that entitlement can be successfully asserted. For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary, there are three immediate implications.

First, transaction-level documentation must be contemporaneous and specific. The court expressly declined to give weight to retrospective commercial rationale assembled after the audit commenced. Commercial purpose evidence that cannot be tied to the decision-making record at the time of the transaction will carry limited weight. Groups that maintain central deal files, approval records, and pricing committee minutes at the parent level but do not systematically ensure that the Russian entity retains its own corresponding contemporaneous record are now materially more exposed.

Second, intra-group pricing within the Russian operating layer needs to be defensible at the level of each individual transaction, not merely at the level of a transfer pricing study. The court drew a distinction between compliance with transfer pricing documentation requirements and proof of genuine arm's-length commercial purpose. These are related but not identical tests, and a transfer pricing study that satisfies the Federal Tax Service's formal requirements may not, on its own, establish business purpose for VAT refund purposes.

Third, the ruling has prospective value for groups assessing whether to restructure their Russian distribution or procurement chains. Where a VAT refund position is a predictable recurring feature of the Russian entity's tax profile, the cost of strengthening contemporaneous documentation now is materially lower than the cost of litigating a Federal Tax Service challenge later. Foreign companies holding Russian assets that generate regular input VAT surpluses should treat this ruling as a prompt to audit their internal documentation practices before the next Federal Tax Service inspection opens.

Request our practice review of your Russian subsidiary's VAT refund position — info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling shifts the practical burden in VAT refund disputes. Under the reasoning applied, once the Federal Tax Service has established a prima facie case that an intra-group arrangement lacks independent commercial purpose, the Russian taxpayer must produce positive, contemporaneous evidence of business rationale. Prior to this decision, courts had been more receptive to retrospective documentary responses, including group-level policy statements. That receptiveness appears to have narrowed significantly at cassation level. Foreign-owned groups should treat transaction-level documentation as a live risk area rather than an administrative formality.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: In-house counsel should undertake a targeted review of the Russian entity's VAT refund documentation practices, focusing specifically on whether the commercial rationale for intra-group purchases is captured in contemporaneous records held at the Russian level – not only at the parent or regional headquarters level. Where a VAT refund position is material, consider commissioning an internal documentation audit before the next Federal Tax Service inspection opens. The firm's Tax Controversy team can assist with that review and, where necessary, with the preparation of a pre-audit compliance response.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry