Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Russian judicial practice on tax audit procedure and taxpayer rights in Russia in the construction and real estate sector — commentary

Kristina Kornouhova · October 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts are reshaping taxpayer rights in construction sector tax audits. What in-house counsel managing Russian assets must know. Make an enquiry.

In the past two to three years of advising foreign companies with Russian construction and real estate assets, one pattern has become difficult to ignore: the Federal Tax Service is conducting audits of companies in these sectors with markedly greater intensity, and Russian courts are simultaneously refining the procedural standards by which those audits must be conducted. For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary engaged in construction procurement, real estate development, or infrastructure contracting, the judicial trajectory described here is directly relevant to how you instruct local counsel and calibrate your compliance posture.

Background

The Russian construction and real estate sector presents an unusually concentrated set of tax audit risks. Long contractor chains, substantial VAT-recoverable inputs, intercompany arrangements for land and asset holding, and the widespread involvement of special-purpose vehicles in project financing all create conditions that the Federal Tax Service treats as elevated-risk. On-site field audits — the most intensive form of tax examination under Russian tax legislation — have been deployed with increasing frequency against companies in this sector, with scrutiny focused on the genuineness of contractor relationships, the substantiation of deductible expenses, and the completeness of VAT recovery documentation.

Against this backdrop, a body of judicial practice has developed — principally through the Economic Collegium of the Russian Supreme Court and the cassation-level commercial courts — addressing a specific set of procedural questions: what procedural rights does the taxpayer hold during the conduct of a field audit, what obligations does the tax authority assume, and where the tax authority departs from the prescribed procedural sequence, what consequence does that departure carry?

The cases that form the basis of this commentary arose in the construction and real estate sector. In each instance, the taxpayer was a legal entity engaged in construction activity, either as a developer or as a general contractor operating within a multi-tier procurement structure. The core legal questions concerned the right of the taxpayer to be notified of and to participate in procedural steps taken during the audit, the obligation of the inspectorate to disclose the evidentiary materials on which it proposes to rely before issuing its decision, and the consequences that attach when these obligations are not met.

The decision

The judicial practice under review reflects a consistent – though not absolute – trend towards stricter scrutiny of the Federal Tax Service's compliance with the procedural framework governing taxpayer rights during field audits. Courts at cassation level have, in a number of recent matters, declined to uphold audit assessments where the inspectorate was found to have conducted examination of witnesses or obtained documentary evidence from third parties without affording the taxpayer the opportunity to participate or to respond before the assessment decision was finalised.

The central principle articulated across these decisions is that the procedural rights afforded to taxpayers under Russian tax legislation are not purely formal in character. Where a procedural violation deprives the taxpayer of a meaningful opportunity to present its position — either because evidence was gathered in a manner the taxpayer could not challenge, or because the inspection's conclusions were drawn from materials the taxpayer had not seen — courts have treated this as a substantive defect capable of affecting the validity of the assessment. This is a notable development. For several years, the prevailing approach was that procedural irregularities would be treated as grounds for annulment only if they were of a severe or systemic nature. The more recent line of authority suggests that courts are applying a more exacting standard.

In the construction sector specifically, courts have addressed scenarios where the tax authority gathered information about the taxpayer's contractors through parallel inspections of those contractors, and then used that information in the primary assessment without disclosing it to the taxpayer in time for the taxpayer to respond. The courts in these matters found that this sequence — gathering evidence, relying on it, and then presenting it only at the stage of the assessment decision — undermined the taxpayer's right to be heard. The remedy applied was remittal for fresh examination, not automatic cancellation of the assessment.

"What these decisions signal is a shift in how Russian courts balance administrative efficiency against taxpayer due process — and for construction companies, whose audit exposure tends to be substantial, the procedural dimension of any field audit now warrants the same attention as the substantive tax position." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel whose Russian subsidiary is currently under field audit or has received a draft assessment, the procedural timeline for objecting to the inspectorate's findings is fixed and short — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign companies with Russian construction or real estate subsidiaries, the judicial practice described above has two immediate practical implications.

The first concerns audit response strategy. Russian tax legislation provides the taxpayer with a defined window — typically a month — to submit written objections to the draft assessment following a field audit. The judicial practice under review reinforces that this window is not merely a formality. Objections that specifically identify procedural departures by the inspectorate — failure to disclose evidence, failure to notify of witness examinations, reliance on materials gathered in parallel inspections of contractors — are now more likely to be treated seriously both by the inspectorate at the objection stage and by courts if the matter proceeds to litigation. Local counsel instructed to respond to a draft assessment should be examining the procedural conduct of the audit as a distinct line of argument, separate from the substantive merits of the deductions or VAT positions under challenge.

The second implication concerns transaction due diligence. Foreign companies acquiring interests in Russian real estate or construction businesses — or entering joint venture arrangements in these sectors — should treat the target company's audit history and any pending or concluded assessments as a primary due diligence item. Where an assessment has been upheld through administrative review but has not been challenged in court, the judicial trend described here suggests that a procedural challenge may still be available if the limitation window has not closed. That analysis requires early-stage input from Russian tax counsel, not a post-closing exercise.

Foreign companies whose Russian subsidiaries are active in construction procurement frequently underestimate the evidentiary burden that Russian courts now impose on taxpayers disputing audit findings. The judicial trend toward stricter procedural scrutiny creates a genuine opportunity — but only for taxpayers who have preserved their procedural objections at the right stages of the audit process.

For further analysis of the regulatory framework within which these audit disputes arise, see our regulatory update on tax audit procedure and taxpayer rights and our briefing for foreign creditors on audit procedure. The firm's Tax Controversy practice page sets out our full scope of advisory and dispute-resolution work in this area.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary in the construction or real estate sector, the procedural dimension of any field audit warrants early review — discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for companies facing a Russian tax audit in the construction sector?

A: The judicial practice described here does not introduce new statutory rights — those are established by the existing tax framework. What it changes is the weight that Russian courts are prepared to give to procedural violations during field audits. Courts are increasingly willing to treat a failure by the inspectorate to disclose evidence or to allow the taxpayer to participate in key procedural steps as a substantive defect, not merely a technical irregularity. For construction companies, where audit assessments commonly involve large figures and complex contractor documentation, this means that the procedural conduct of the audit is now a live argument — not a fallback position of last resort.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Companies with Russian construction or real estate subsidiaries should take three practical steps. First, ensure that local counsel monitors and documents the procedural conduct of any ongoing field audit in real time — not retrospectively. Second, when a draft assessment is received, instruct counsel to analyse both the substantive tax position and any procedural departures by the inspectorate before the objection deadline. Third, for companies acquiring Russian construction assets, include the target's audit history and any procedural grounds for challenging concluded assessments in the scope of tax due diligence. Early engagement with Russian tax counsel — before the objection window closes — is the defining factor in whether these arguments remain available.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry