Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Russian arbitrazh court on tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts under Article 269 of the Tax Code (thin capitalisation): key takeaways

Kristina Kornouhova · February 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts are applying Article 269 thin cap rules strictly to foreign-owned Russian subsidiaries. Key ruling analysed. Make an enquiry.

In practice, few provisions of Russian tax legislation generate as much litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts as the thin capitalisation rules embedded in Article 269 of the Tax Code. For foreign companies operating in Russia through locally incorporated subsidiaries, the stakes are substantial: where a court upholds a Federal Tax Service reclassification, interest payments that the subsidiary has been deducting for years are retroactively treated as dividend distributions, producing a disallowed deduction and a withholding tax exposure simultaneously. A recent case-comment from Russian arbitrazh court practice illustrates how courts are approaching this question in 2026 and what it means for in-house counsel managing Russian operations.

Background

The case arose from an FTS field audit of a Russian operating company whose ultimate beneficial ownership resided in a foreign holding structure. The company had received a series of intercompany loans from a related party that, when taken together, produced a debt-to-equity ratio well in excess of the threshold prescribed by Russian tax legislation for controlled debt. On audit, the tax authority applied the thin capitalisation calculation, disallowed the portion of interest payments attributable to the excess, and reclassified that amount as a deemed dividend distribution.

The company challenged the assessment before the arbitrazh court at first instance. It advanced two principal arguments. First, it contended that the thin capitalisation rules applied narrowly to direct shareholder financing and did not extend to loans routed through an intermediate entity that was not itself a shareholder. Second, it argued that the economic substance of the transaction was consistent with arm's length lending and that the reclassification therefore lacked a proper legal basis. The first-instance court rejected both arguments. The appellate instance upheld the first-instance ruling in its entirety, affirming the FTS assessment and the associated tax demand.

This ruling joins a pattern of cases in which Russian arbitrazh courts have declined to draw a distinction between direct-shareholder lending and lending by related parties within the same ownership structure. The detailed procedural history of this type of dispute is examined in our piece on tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts.

What does this ruling change?

The prevailing significance of this decision lies not in the statutory interpretation of Article 269 itself, which has been settled for some years, but in how courts are applying the facts. Historically, a subset of cases left open the possibility that indirect-shareholder loans, where the lender was a related party rather than the registered shareholder, occupied a grey area within the thin cap framework. The ruling under review closes that gap at the circuit level.

Three analytical points merit attention for in-house counsel.

First, the court treated the economic substance of the lending relationship as determinative rather than its legal form. Where the lender could be shown to be part of the same ownership chain as the borrower's direct or indirect shareholder, the controlled debt characterisation applied irrespective of whether the lender held shares in the borrower directly. The court was not persuaded by the argument that the absence of a direct ownership link insulated the transaction from Article 269 scrutiny.

Second, the court's treatment of the arm's length argument is instructive. The company had adduced transfer-pricing evidence suggesting that the interest rates were within an arm's length range. The court held that arm's length pricing was not a defence to thin capitalisation characterisation under Article 269: the two frameworks operate independently. A loan may be priced on arm's length terms and still generate non-deductible interest if the controlled debt ratio is exceeded. This is a distinction that in-house counsel from common-law or German-law backgrounds sometimes underestimate when assessing Russian intercompany debt structures.

Third, the computation methodology used by the FTS was upheld in full. The tax authority had calculated the controlled debt ratio on a quarter-by-quarter basis for the period under audit, using the consolidated balance sheet figures for each measurement date. The court accepted this methodology without qualification. Where the ratio fluctuated across quarters, the disallowance was applied proportionately, but the base characterisation of the debt as controlled remained constant throughout.

"This ruling reinforces what we observe consistently in Article 269 litigation: the courts focus on the economic reality of the ownership chain, not the contractual form of the debt, and transfer pricing arguments do not displace thin cap analysis." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries that carry intercompany debt, the practical implication is immediate: if any entity in the lending chain is related to the Russian borrower through a common parent or shareholder, the position should be reviewed against the controlled debt rules regardless of whether the lender is a direct shareholder.

If your Russian subsidiary carries intercompany debt from a related foreign entity, the structural analysis warranted by this ruling is best conducted before an FTS field audit commences — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

The ruling is a practical prompt to review three things before the next FTS inspection cycle begins.

The first priority is a debt-to-equity ratio audit. In-house counsel should request a current calculation of the controlled debt ratio for each Russian subsidiary carrying intercompany loans, measured on a quarterly basis consistent with the methodology upheld by the court. Where the ratio exceeds the legislative threshold in any quarter, the interest deductibility position should be treated as under litigation risk, not as a settled item.

The second is a lender-relationship map. The ruling's emphasis on economic ownership rather than legal form means that the relevant question is not only whether the direct lender holds shares in the Russian borrower, but whether any entity in the lending chain — parent, sister company, intermediate holding vehicle — sits within the same ownership structure. Structures assembled to avoid a direct shareholder-lender relationship may no longer provide the protection that was assumed at the time of their design.

The third is a provision review. Subsidiaries that have been deducting interest on controlled debt without a specific provision for potential thin cap disallowance may be carrying a tax liability that is not reflected on the balance sheet. Where intercompany loans have been in place for multiple years, the cumulative exposure — including the deemed dividend reclassification and associated withholding tax — may be material. Under Russian insolvency legislation, tax liabilities that crystallise on audit can accelerate creditor proceedings; for publicly reported entities, the provisioning question may also have disclosure implications.

A practical guide to tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts and a full overview of the Tax Controversy practice are available on our site. For matters that have already entered the audit phase, see the firm's matters record.

For in-house counsel whose Russian subsidiaries are approaching an FTS inspection or have already received a pre-audit information request, the window to restructure before a formal act of audit is issued is narrow. Early engagement with Russian tax counsel at this stage is demonstrably more effective than joining proceedings after an assessment has been raised.

To discuss your Russian subsidiary's exposure under Article 269 in confidence — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign multinationals with Russian subsidiaries funded by intercompany debt?

A: The ruling confirms that Russian arbitrazh courts will apply the thin capitalisation framework under Article 269 to loans from any related-party lender within the same ownership structure, not only to loans from direct shareholders. This extends the scope of potential disallowances to a wider category of intercompany lending arrangements that some groups had structured on the assumption that indirect-lender positions fell outside the provision. Additionally, the decision makes clear that arm's length pricing of the loan is not a defence to thin cap characterisation: the two frameworks are analysed independently under Russian tax legislation. Groups that have relied on transfer-pricing documentation alone to support their interest deductions in Russia should treat that reliance as insufficient.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Three immediate steps are advisable. First, calculate the controlled debt ratio for each Russian subsidiary on a quarterly basis for open tax years, using balance sheet figures consistent with the methodology upheld in the ruling. Second, map the full ownership chain of any foreign lender to identify whether it falls within the same ownership structure as the Russian borrower, regardless of whether it holds shares directly. Third, review whether the tax provision on the subsidiary's balance sheet adequately reflects the potential thin cap disallowance and associated withholding tax on deemed dividends. Where the exposure appears material, engaging Russian tax controversy counsel before an FTS field audit commences is advisable. Once a formal audit act is issued, the range of available responses narrows considerably.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry