FTS Russia routinely challenges treaty benefits claimed against insolvency estates. Beneficial ownership is the critical test. Make an enquiry.
Where an insolvency estate in Russia receives passive income — dividends, interest, or royalties — that would otherwise qualify for treaty-rate withholding under a double tax treaty, the Federal Tax Service will require the estate to demonstrate beneficial ownership before any treaty benefit is granted. In practice, insolvency estates rarely satisfy this test. Treaty rates are frequently denied, and the standard domestic withholding rate applies instead.
Under Russian tax law, treaty benefits on passive income depend on the recipient being the beneficial owner. This means the entity must have the right to use and dispose of the income freely and must bear the associated economic risk. An insolvency estate presents a structural obstacle: the court-appointed administrator acts in the interests of creditors, not for the estate's own account. Income flows directly into the bankruptcy estate for distribution among creditors rather than to a principal who exercises genuine control over it. The FTS has consistently treated this structure as conduit-like and has denied reduced treaty rates accordingly.
For in-house counsel at a multinational with Russian subsidiaries or receivables, the consequence is direct. Where a Russian counterparty enters insolvency proceedings, any expectation of continued treaty-rate withholding on passive income flows should be reassessed immediately. The withholding obligation — and the exposure to arrears, penalties, and interest if incorrectly applied — falls on the withholding agent, not the estate. Tax Controversy advice should be sought before the next payment falls due.
For detailed analysis of the legislative framework and the beneficial ownership test as applied in Russian courts and FTS audits, see our briefing on double tax treaty application and beneficial ownership (/insights/tc-pb-004-double-tax-treaty-application-and-beneficial-/) and the Tax Controversy practice page (/practices/tax-controversy/).
If your Russian counterparty has entered insolvency and treaty-rate withholding remains in place, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
— Kristina Kornouhova Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners vetrovpartners.com/kornouhova/
Kristina Kornouhova heads the firm's tax controversy and antitrust practices. She advises Russian and foreign companies facing Federal Tax Service audits, transfer-pricing disputes, and FAS Russia proceedings.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry