Russian arbitrazh courts changed tax dispute procedure materially from January 2027. In-house counsel at foreign companies need to act. Make an enquiry.
From the start of 2027, Russian arbitrazh courts are applying a materially revised procedural approach to tax disputes – one that shortens effective preparation windows, tightens documentation standards, and places greater evidentiary burden on taxpayers challenging Federal Tax Service assessments. For in-house counsel at foreign companies with Russian subsidiaries or operating presences, these changes arrive without a transitional period: matters already in the pre-trial phase are subject to the new framework, and the documentation assembled under prior expectations may be insufficient to sustain a challenge.
Until late 2026, the procedural path through Russian tax controversy followed a relatively settled sequence: Federal Tax Service audit, objections, appeal within the FTS hierarchy, and then – where necessary – a claim before the arbitrazh court. The substantive and evidentiary standards that courts applied when assessing the merits of tax challenges, while never uniform, were broadly predictable and built up through consistent circuit-level practice over several years.
From the beginning of 2027, three shifts are being applied in practice.
The first concerns the evidential threshold at the pre-judicial appeal stage. Arbitrazh courts have consistently declined to admit materials first raised at the judicial stage if those materials could, in the court's assessment, have been submitted during the administrative appeal. The practical effect of this position – which had been developing incrementally in court practice since 2024 – has crystallised into a near-uniform approach in early 2027: the evidentiary record is treated as effectively closed at the conclusion of the FTS internal appeal. In-house teams that did not build a complete documentary file during the audit and internal appeal stages now face meaningful restrictions on supplementing that file in court.
The second shift relates to transfer pricing disputes. Courts have moved towards a more demanding review of comparability analyses submitted by taxpayers. Where previously a qualified transfer pricing study, properly prepared by recognised specialists, was generally sufficient to establish arm's-length pricing, courts are now scrutinising the methodology used to select comparables – and in a number of circuits are requiring taxpayers to explain and justify methodology choices as a threshold matter, before engaging with the substance of the pricing analysis.
The third development concerns the timeline for interlocutory measures. The availability of interim relief to suspend enforcement of a tax assessment pending judicial review has become more restricted. Courts are applying a stricter standard when assessing the taxpayer's ability to satisfy a future judgment, and applications for interim measures that are not supported by immediate and detailed evidence of harm are being declined at first instance. This matters because enforcement of an FTS assessment – including compulsory collection from bank accounts – can proceed during litigation unless interim relief is in place.
"
"The three procedural shifts of 2027 – tighter evidentiary cutoffs, stricter comparability review, and a higher bar for interim relief – combine to compress the effective window in which a foreign company's Russian subsidiary can build a viable tax defence."— Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners
"
The impact of these procedural developments varies by entity structure and the nature of the company's Russian operations, but certain categories face a disproportionate exposure.
Foreign-owned Russian subsidiaries engaged in intra-group transactions are the most directly affected by the transfer pricing development. Any entity that relies on intra-group pricing for goods, services, or financing – and that has not updated its comparable selection methodology to reflect the heightened judicial scrutiny – is operating with a transfer pricing defence that may not withstand judicial review in the current environment.
The shift in evidentiary standards at the pre-judicial stage has a particular impact on subsidiaries whose tax function is managed from the parent company's headquarters outside Russia. In practice, this means that the local finance and legal team – or local outside counsel – must be engaged substantially earlier in the audit process than has historically been the practice. Documentation decisions made in Moscow or Novosibirsk in the month following an audit act are now determinative of what the court will see twelve or eighteen months later. Decisions made at group tax headquarters in Frankfurt or Amsterdam without reference to Russian procedural standards carry real risk of producing an incomplete record.
Companies with significant Russian asset bases and tax assessments of material scale face an elevated risk from the interim measures restriction. Under Russian insolvency legislation, a tax liability that has been enforced compulsorily – with funds removed from bank accounts – is treated differently from an outstanding assessment when a taxpayer enters financial difficulty. For foreign shareholders holding equity in a Russian operating company, this means that the window between an adverse FTS decision and enforcement action is shorter in 2027 than it was in 2026, and it requires faster mobilisation of local legal resources.
For in-house counsel at multinationals with Russian legal matters already in progress, the regulatory timeline leaves limited margin to reassess documentation strategy mid-proceeding.
If your Russian subsidiary is facing an FTS audit or is in the pre-trial appeal stage, make an enquiry before the evidential record closes: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The most urgent action for any foreign company whose Russian entity is subject to a current FTS audit or an unresolved administrative appeal is a documentation audit – not of the tax position itself, but of the evidentiary record as it stands.
The questions that determine how exposed a company is to the 2027 procedural changes are practical ones: What documents were submitted during the audit? What objections were filed, and on what evidentiary basis? Were all transfer pricing materials submitted during the administrative appeal, or were some held back for the judicial stage? Has the interim measures position been assessed in the event of an adverse first-instance decision?
For companies that have not yet entered litigation, the preparation window is the critical asset. The evidential record can still be completed during an active administrative appeal. That window, once the appeal is concluded, effectively closes.
For companies whose matters are already before the arbitrazh court, the priority is a realistic assessment of the existing evidentiary record, identification of any materials that were not submitted at the administrative stage, and an analysis of whether any procedural route exists for their admission. In the current environment, that analysis should be conducted with Russian procedural counsel who has direct visibility of the relevant circuit's current approach – circuit variation remains meaningful, and the Siberian and Ural circuit courts have applied the new evidential approach in ways that differ in certain respects from practice in Moscow circuits.
Several aspects of the 2027 procedural environment are not yet fully settled through court practice, and in-house counsel should be alert to their evolution over the coming months.
The scope of the restriction on new evidence at the judicial stage is the most practically significant open question. Courts have applied the principle consistently, but the threshold of what constitutes evidence "that could have been submitted at the administrative stage" has not been tested exhaustively. There is meaningful variation between circuits, and in some matters specialist counsel has successfully argued that certain categories of expert evidence – particularly economic analyses responding to the FTS's own methodology – do not fall within the restriction because they are responsive, rather than original, evidence. This argument has not been definitively resolved in the Supreme Court's guidance, and it remains a live tactical question.
On transfer pricing, the Supreme Court's tax panel is expected to issue further guidance in 2027 on comparability standards. The direction of that guidance will materially affect how lower courts approach methodology challenges. Companies with transfer pricing disputes currently progressing through the system should consider whether it is procedurally advantageous to allow a matter to develop to a point where the Supreme Court's position is clearer.
The interim measures position may also evolve. The current restrictive approach reflects a doctrinal position that has built up through lower-court practice rather than binding Supreme Court authority. A well-argued application in a matter with a strong financial position and clear evidence of enforcement harm continues to have a reasonable prospect of success, particularly in circuits outside Moscow.
Q: What specifically changed in Russian tax litigation procedure from the start of 2027?
A: Three procedural shifts have crystallised in arbitrazh court practice from early 2027. First, the evidentiary record is now treated as effectively closed at the conclusion of the FTS internal appeal: courts have adopted a near-uniform approach to declining materials first raised at the judicial stage if those materials could have been submitted during the administrative process. Second, courts are applying a materially stricter review of comparability analyses in transfer pricing disputes, including scrutiny of methodology selection before engaging with the substance of the pricing study. Third, the standard for obtaining interim relief to suspend enforcement of a tax assessment has become more demanding, with applications unsupported by immediate evidence of harm being declined at first instance.
Q: Which types of foreign companies face the greatest exposure to these changes?
A: Foreign-owned Russian subsidiaries engaged in intra-group transactions are most directly affected by the transfer pricing development, particularly where the comparable selection methodology has not been reviewed recently. Companies whose audit and appeal process is managed substantially from outside Russia – without local procedural counsel engaged at the audit stage – face disproportionate risk from the evidentiary record restriction, because decisions made at that stage now determine what the court will see. Companies with large Russian asset bases and material tax assessments face elevated risk from the tightened interim measures standard, given that enforcement can proceed during litigation in the absence of a successful interim relief application.
Q: What should in-house counsel do if a Russian subsidiary is currently in an FTS audit or administrative appeal?
A: The immediate priority is a documentary review of the evidentiary record as it currently stands, conducted with local Russian procedural counsel. The specific questions are: what has been submitted, what remains outstanding, and whether the transfer pricing materials meet the current judicial standard on comparability methodology. The window in which the record can still be completed is the administrative appeal stage; once that concludes, the record is treated as closed. For matters already before the arbitrazh court, the priority shifts to assessing what, if any, procedural route exists to supplement the record – a question that depends on the specific circuit and the nature of the materials at issue.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry