Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Russian Supreme Court clarification on VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups

Kristina Kornouhova · September 2026 · 7 min read

Russia's Supreme Court has clarified VAT refund dispute procedure for foreign-owned Russian groups. What in-house counsel must know. Make an enquiry.

Following the Russian Supreme Court's clarification issued in mid-2027, the procedural framework governing VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian legal entities has shifted in ways that in-house counsel cannot treat as incremental. For multinational groups with Russian operating subsidiaries, the ruling reframes the documentary and procedural thresholds that the Federal Tax Service applies when reviewing VAT refund claims — and, critically, it confirms the evidentiary standard courts will apply when those claims are challenged. The development follows a sustained period of FTS audit intensity in this area and marks a point at which internal compliance assumptions built on pre-2025 practice require reassessment.

What changed — before and after the clarification

Before the Supreme Court's intervention, VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups were resolved by regional arbitrazh courts applying broadly consistent but not uniform standards. The absence of a definitive top-level ruling meant that Federal Tax Service inspectorates in different circuits could — and did — apply divergent documentary requirements when challenging the legitimacy of input VAT claimed by Russian subsidiaries of foreign parents. For in-house counsel managing a portfolio of Russian entities, this created material inconsistency: a refund claim accepted without challenge in one district might be refused on procedural grounds in another.

The Supreme Court's clarification resolves a specific point that had produced conflicting outcomes across circuits: the extent to which the FTS may look beyond the transactional documents of the Russian entity itself and require disclosure of group-level intercompany arrangements when assessing whether input VAT was genuinely incurred in connection with taxable supplies. The ruling establishes that, while the FTS retains broad audit powers, the evidentiary burden for challenging a properly documented refund claim rests with the tax authority — not the taxpayer — to demonstrate that the claimed deduction is artificial or that the underlying supply chain lacks business substance.

This represents a meaningful recalibration. Prior to the clarification, a number of circuit courts had placed the practical burden on taxpayers to disprove FTS assertions of sham transactions, even where primary documentation was complete. The Supreme Court has now aligned the standard more closely with the principle that a compliant taxpayer filing a complete return is entitled to prompt refund processing absent a substantiated FTS challenge.

"

"The Supreme Court's position on evidentiary burden in VAT refund disputes shifts the operational risk for foreign-owned groups materially. Properly documented claims now stand on firmer ground when the FTS challenges on substance."— Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

" — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

Which foreign-owned groups are most affected by this Russia regulatory update?

The clarification affects any foreign-owned Russian legal entity that regularly claims input VAT refunds — most commonly Russian manufacturing subsidiaries, trading companies, and service entities in sectors with significant capital expenditure or import-intensive supply chains. The ruling is particularly relevant for groups whose Russian operations are structured through intermediate holding layers, since the FTS has historically been most active in challenging refund claims where the intercompany supply chain is multi-tiered.

Foreign-owned groups with Russian entities engaged in export-linked production receive special attention. Where the Russian entity's taxable supplies are partially zero-rated for export purposes, the input VAT refund process is operationally critical to cash management. The Supreme Court's confirmation that the evidentiary burden lies with the FTS — rather than the taxpayer — provides a more robust procedural footing for defending these claims through arbitrazh court proceedings.

Groups that have historically settled FTS challenges informally, or accepted partial refunds to avoid drawn-out disputes, should also take note. The clarification gives in-house counsel a stronger procedural basis for contesting FTS positions that would previously have required the taxpayer to assume a disproportionate documentary burden. For in-house counsel managing Russian law compliance across a multinational structure, the ruling changes the litigation calculus for disputes that are currently open or are likely to arise in the next audit cycle.

For in-house counsel assessing the impact of this Russia regulatory update on current or pending VAT refund claims, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What should foreign companies do now — practical steps for in-house counsel

The clarification does not take effect retroactively in the sense of reopening concluded disputes, but its influence on pending cases and future audit cycles is immediate. In-house counsel should treat the following as priority review items.

First, audit the status of any VAT refund claims currently under FTS challenge. Where the FTS has advanced a challenge on the basis that the taxpayer has not sufficiently demonstrated business substance at the group level — rather than at the level of the Russian entity itself — the Supreme Court's clarification provides a direct procedural counter-argument. Cases in which the Russian entity's primary documentation is complete but the FTS is pressing for group-level disclosure are precisely the category the ruling addresses.

Second, review the documentary standard applied to refund claims filed within the most recent audit window. If internal procedures were calibrated to the pre-clarification circuit-level standard — which in some jurisdictions effectively required taxpayers to pre-empt FTS substance challenges with unsolicited group disclosure — those procedures now require updating. The operative standard is the completeness and accuracy of the Russian entity's own transactional documentation.

Third, coordinate with local Russian tax counsel before the next scheduled audit cycle begins. The FTS's response to the Supreme Court's ruling — in terms of how inspectorates adjust their challenge methodology — will take some months to crystallise in practice. Groups that engage Russian tax controversy counsel early will be better positioned to anticipate the FTS's adapted approach and to document their refund positions accordingly.

For groups with Russian entities in the Siberian and Ural federal districts, note that the West Siberian circuit arbitrazh courts have historically been among the more active in VAT refund litigation. Local procedural intelligence in this circuit is a material advantage.

If your group has Russian VAT refund disputes under review, or if you are preparing for an FTS audit cycle, request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in VAT refund dispute procedure following the Supreme Court's clarification?

A: The Supreme Court has established that the evidentiary burden in VAT refund disputes rests with the Federal Tax Service, not the taxpayer. Previously, circuit courts had inconsistently required Russian entities — particularly those owned by foreign groups — to disprove FTS assertions of artificial transactions even where primary documentation was complete. The clarification confirms that a properly documented refund claim must be accepted unless the FTS can substantiate its challenge. This ends a significant area of circuit-level divergence that had created compliance uncertainty for foreign-owned subsidiaries across Russia.

Q: Which foreign-owned Russian entities are most directly affected by this VAT refund ruling?

A: The ruling is most directly relevant to Russian manufacturing subsidiaries, trading companies, and service entities that regularly file input VAT refund claims — particularly where the supply chain is multi-tiered or where intercompany arrangements exist between the Russian entity and its foreign parent or intermediate holding companies. Entities involved in export-linked production, where input VAT refunds are operationally significant, are especially affected. Groups that have previously accepted FTS positions on substance challenges without contesting them through arbitrazh proceedings should reassess their approach in light of the changed evidentiary standard.

Q: What should in-house counsel do now in response to this Russia regulatory update?

A: Three immediate steps are advisable. First, review any VAT refund claims currently under FTS challenge to assess whether the FTS's position relies on a burden-of-proof approach the Supreme Court has now rejected. Second, update internal refund claim procedures to reflect the entity-level documentary standard confirmed by the ruling. Third, engage Russian tax controversy counsel ahead of the next FTS audit cycle to assess how local inspectorates are adapting their challenge methodology. Given that the FTS's practical response to the Supreme Court's clarification will take time to settle, early counsel engagement is the more cost-effective posture.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry