Russian courts are tightening VAT refund scrutiny for foreign-owned Russian entities. What changed and what in-house counsel must do. Make an enquiry.
Following a series of rulings handed down by Russian arbitrazh courts in the first half of 2026, the evidentiary and procedural environment for VAT refund disputes has shifted in ways that foreign-owned Russian groups and their in-house counsel can no longer treat as background noise. Courts have refined how they assess the interaction between general VAT recovery rules under Russian tax legislation and the relief mechanisms available under applicable double tax treaties — with results that in a number of cases have proved unfavourable to groups that assumed earlier, more permissive practice would hold.
Until recently, the prevailing approach in VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups was broadly consistent: where a group invoked double tax treaty relief — most commonly to characterise certain intra-group services or financing flows as non-taxable at the Russian level — the Federal Tax Service (FTS) would audit those positions as part of a desk or field audit, but courts tended to assess treaty relief arguments and the underlying VAT refund claim as essentially distinct matters. Treaty relief went to the question of withholding obligations; VAT refund went to the question of input tax substantiation. The two tracks ran in parallel.
What changed in 2026 is the degree to which courts are now treating the two as interconnected. In a number of rulings across several federal circuits, Russian arbitrazh courts — and on cassation review, circuit courts — have held that where a group has applied double tax treaty relief to re-characterise the nature of a supply or payment, the consequences of that re-characterisation flow through to the VAT position. Put differently, a service or transaction that the group has treated as non-taxable under treaty relief for withholding purposes may, in the court's analysis, also affect the deductibility of the associated input VAT and, consequently, the validity of the refund claim.
This does not amount to a change in the statutory framework. The Russian tax code provisions governing VAT recovery remain formally unchanged. What has evolved is judicial interpretation — specifically, how courts read the interaction between treaty relief arguments and the substantiation requirements for VAT input tax deductions. The shift is iterative, not yet settled across all circuits, and some courts continue to treat the two tracks independently. However, the trend is sufficiently pronounced across 2025–2026 rulings that groups relying on established filing positions should treat it as a live risk.
There is also a distinct but related development: the FTS has intensified audit scrutiny of VAT refund claims by foreign-owned Russian entities. In practice, desk audits of VAT refund applications filed by Russian subsidiaries of foreign groups are taking longer, requesting more extensive documentation on the beneficial ownership and business purpose of intra-group transactions, and more frequently escalating to field audits where a double tax treaty relief position is present on the same entity's returns. The regulatory timeline — a three-month desk audit period, with the prospect of a field audit extending to several months further — means that refund delays of a year or more are not uncommon in contested matters.
" For in-house counsel overseeing a Russian subsidiary's tax position, the regulatory timeline leaves little margin. A refund claim currently in audit will very likely be assessed against the emerging 2026 evidentiary standard, regardless of when it was originally filed."
If your Russian subsidiary has an open VAT refund claim or an FTS audit in progress involving double tax treaty relief positions, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The development is not uniform across all group structures or all treaty relationships. The groups most directly affected share one or more of the following characteristics.
First, groups that have relied on double tax treaty relief to treat intra-group management fees, royalties, or intercompany financing as non-taxable receipts at the Russian entity level — and that have simultaneously claimed input VAT refunds on costs associated with those activities — are facing heightened challenge. The court's linkage between treaty re-characterisation and VAT input tax position is most directly engaged where there is a visible nexus between the transactions attracting treaty relief and the costs generating the refund claim.
Second, groups with Dutch, Luxembourgish, Cypriot, or other holding-company jurisdictions in their ownership chain are subject to more intensive FTS scrutiny on beneficial ownership grounds. The FTS has, in recent years, developed a consistent audit methodology for challenging treaty relief where the immediate recipient of a payment is an intermediate holding entity rather than the final beneficial owner. Where that challenge succeeds — even partially — it tends to infect the associated VAT position in the courts' analysis.
Third, Russian subsidiaries of foreign groups that are also EAEU-related supply chain participants may face additional complexity. VAT refund disputes for cross-border supplies within the EAEU operate under a distinct regulatory framework — one that interacts imperfectly with bilateral double tax treaties where the treaty pre-dates EAEU membership. Courts are still working through these intersection issues, and the prevailing approach is not yet settled.
Smaller Russian subsidiaries — those with annual turnover below certain FTS audit thresholds and no material intra-group service or financing flows — are less immediately exposed. The development is primarily material for medium-to-large operational entities within multinational groups.
"The shift we are seeing in 2026 is not a legislative change — it is a reinterpretation of existing rules. Groups that built their VAT and treaty positions in isolation from each other are now being asked, in court, to justify the coherence of those positions as a whole." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners
The practical response has three elements, and the sequence matters.
The first priority is position mapping. Any Russian subsidiary that holds open VAT refund claims — whether in the audit phase, in pre-litigation dispute phase, or already in court — should assess whether those claims are linked, in the FTS's or court's potential view, to double tax treaty relief positions taken on the same entity's returns. This is not a speculative exercise: it is the question the FTS is now routinely asking in audit, and the question courts are applying in 2026 rulings. Groups that have not yet mapped the overlap between their treaty and VAT positions are working without a current risk assessment.
The second element is documentation. The evidentiary standard being applied in 2026 — particularly on business purpose and beneficial ownership — requires contemporaneous documentation at a level of detail that retrospective reconstruction cannot adequately substitute for. Intra-group service agreements, transfer pricing documentation, and the chain of approvals for payments subject to treaty relief should all be reviewed for consistency with the VAT refund position. Where gaps exist, they should be addressed proactively before an audit escalation.
The third element is procedural awareness. The FTS audit and appeals process in Russia follows a defined sequence — desk audit, field audit, FTS internal appeal, arbitrazh court — and each stage imposes its own evidentiary constraints. Evidence and arguments not raised at the administrative stage may face restrictions on admission in arbitrazh proceedings. Foreign-owned groups that are not actively managing this sequence — through Russian-qualified tax counsel — risk forfeiting procedural options that cannot be recovered later.
For groups that have not engaged Russian tax controversy counsel on their VAT and treaty positions, the first half of 2026 is a reasonable point at which to do so. The practice area sits squarely within the firm's Tax Controversy practice, and the team's experience in FTS audit and arbitrazh court proceedings for foreign-owned Russian entities is directly relevant.
Further analysis of the procedural landscape for VAT refund claims is set out in Navigating VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups and Comparative analysis of VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned groups. The firm's Matters page includes anonymised matter references from this practice area.
If your group's Russian subsidiary holds an open VAT refund claim or has received FTS enquiries on its treaty relief positions, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The court practice described above is iterative, not consolidated, and several questions remain genuinely unsettled as of mid-2026.
It is not yet clear whether the appellate chambers — and ultimately the Supreme Court's economic bench — will formally endorse the lower courts' linkage between treaty re-characterisation and VAT input tax deductibility. The reasoning in 2025–2026 rulings, while consistent in direction, varies in its analytical framework across circuits. A supervisory review clarifying or correcting the approach remains possible.
There is also uncertainty about how the approach applies in EAEU cross-border situations. The CIS and EAEU multilateral frameworks create treaty-like obligations that interact with bilateral tax treaties in ways that courts have not yet addressed uniformly. This uncertainty is material for groups with supply chains crossing EAEU borders.
Finally, the FTS's internal audit guidelines on VAT refund scrutiny for foreign-owned entities have not been publicly updated to reflect the 2026 court trends. Groups facing audits are therefore dealing with an administrative body whose formal instructions may not fully reflect current court outcomes — a gap that experienced Russian tax controversy counsel can help to navigate.
Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on VAT refund disputes in 2026?
A: Russian arbitrazh courts — and cassation circuit courts — have increasingly treated double tax treaty relief positions and VAT input tax deductibility as interconnected rather than independent. Where a group has invoked treaty relief to re-characterise a supply or payment, courts in a number of 2025–2026 rulings have held that the re-characterisation affects the associated VAT refund position. This is a shift in judicial interpretation, not a statutory amendment — the formal VAT recovery rules are unchanged.
Q: Which foreign-owned Russian subsidiaries face the greatest exposure from this development?
A: Groups most directly affected are those that have applied double tax treaty relief to intra-group service fees, royalties, or financing flows while simultaneously claiming VAT refunds on costs linked to those activities. Groups with intermediate holding companies in the ownership chain — where FTS beneficial ownership challenges are likely — face compounded risk. Russian subsidiaries involved in EAEU cross-border supply chains face additional complexity from the interaction between EAEU VAT rules and bilateral treaty obligations.
Q: What should an in-house counsel do now if the Russian subsidiary holds an open VAT refund claim?
A: The first step is to map whether the open VAT refund claim is linked, in the FTS's or court's likely view, to any double tax treaty relief position on the same entity's returns. If such a link exists, the documentation supporting both positions — intra-group agreements, business purpose evidence, beneficial ownership records — should be reviewed for consistency before the next audit stage. Procedural deadlines in the Russian FTS audit and appeal sequence are strict; raising arguments and evidence at the earliest available stage preserves options that cannot be recovered later.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry