Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Russian court practice on customs valuation disputes in Russia for Turkish-owned Russian groups: 2026 update

Kristina Kornouhova · February 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts tightened customs valuation scrutiny for Turkish-owned groups in 2026. What in-house counsel must assess now. Make an enquiry.

For Turkish-owned groups importing goods into Russia through related-party arrangements, the customs valuation landscape has shifted materially in 2026. Following a sustained period of post-clearance audit activity by the Federal Customs Service, Russian arbitrazh courts across several circuits have consolidated a more demanding evidentiary standard for upholding declared transaction values in related-party transactions – a development that carries direct implications for in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries with Turkish parent or affiliate supply chains.

§ I. What has changed: the evidentiary standard tightens

For much of the preceding period, Russian courts and the Federal Customs Service applied the transaction value method as the primary basis for customs valuation, consistent with the EAEU Customs Code's six-method hierarchy. Where importers demonstrated that the buyer-seller relationship had not influenced the declared price – through comparability analysis, test values, or transfer-pricing documentation – courts generally accepted the declared transaction value as the valuation basis.

The shift observable in 2026 court practice concerns the quality of evidence required to discharge that burden. Arbitrazh courts in several circuits – including within the Siberian and Ural federal districts – have begun requiring a more structured evidentiary package than in prior years. Comparability analyses that were previously accepted at face value are now subjected to closer scrutiny: courts have questioned whether the reference transactions used in comparability submissions are genuinely analogous in terms of commercial level, quantity, and trade conditions. Where a customs authority has applied an alternative valuation method – most commonly the method of identical or similar goods – courts have, in a growing number of decisions, declined to disturb that adjustment where the importer's counter-evidence was insufficiently particularised.

Equally significant is the treatment of transfer-pricing documentation. In related-party import transactions between Turkish affiliates and their Russian subsidiaries, transfer-pricing reports prepared primarily for Federal Tax Service purposes have been presented in customs proceedings as indirect evidence that the declared price reflects arm's-length conditions. Courts have increasingly distinguished between the two regimes: transfer-pricing compliance does not, in the prevailing interpretation of Russian customs courts, automatically establish that the customs transaction value is free from relational influence. The practical consequence is that documentation strategies calibrated only to tax requirements may leave a valuation gap in the customs context.

"What Russian courts are now requiring is a customs-specific valuation defence – one that speaks to the EAEU comparability criteria directly, not one repurposed from a transfer-pricing file." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead – Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

§ II. Which Turkish-owned Russian groups are most exposed?

The structural profile most affected is a Russian limited liability company or joint-stock company that is majority-owned by a Turkish holding entity and imports goods – finished products, components, raw materials, or machinery – from that holding entity or from other companies within the same Turkish group. This arrangement describes a significant share of Turkish direct investment in Russia across manufacturing, construction, textiles, food processing, and engineering sectors.

Several compounding factors increase exposure. First, Turkish-Russian trade volumes have grown substantially in the period following 2022, as Turkish entities have in many cases become the primary non-CIS external counterparty for Russian importers. This elevated volume has drawn correspondingly greater Federal Customs Service audit attention to Turkish-origin shipments and related-party arrangements involving Turkish entities.

Second, goods imported from Turkey into Russia cross a customs border that is external to the EAEU customs territory. Unlike intra-EAEU movements, where certain customs formalities are simplified, Turkish-origin imports are subject to full EAEU customs procedure – including customs valuation declarations, duties assessed on declared value, and the full audit regime. The post-clearance audit window under Russian procedural rules is typically three years from the date of customs declaration; this means that import transactions concluded as far back as 2023 remain within scope for active audit in 2026.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary operating in this profile, the regulatory timeline is not theoretical: post-clearance adjustments carry additional customs duties, interest, and administrative penalties that can be assessed simultaneously. Early-stage review of the existing valuation methodology and supporting documentation is therefore a cost-management issue, not only a compliance exercise.

If your Russian subsidiary imports goods from a Turkish parent or affiliate, the current audit window makes documentation review time-sensitive. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should in-house counsel do now?

Three areas of immediate focus are indicated by current court practice.

First, audit the existing evidentiary package for related-party imports. The key question is whether the firm's comparability analysis or test-value submission was prepared to the standard now being applied by arbitrazh courts – not merely to the standard that was sufficient at the time of declaration. Where declarations were made in 2023 or 2024 and the supporting documentation reflects an earlier, more permissive standard, strengthening that record before a post-clearance audit is initiated is materially more effective than constructing a defence after the fact.

Second, decouple the transfer-pricing file from the customs valuation defence. Russian courts have signalled that they will treat these as distinct analyses. A customs valuation defence for Turkish affiliate transactions should be built around EAEU comparability criteria: commercial level, quantity, the presence or absence of regulatory obligations, and the comparability of contractual conditions. The transfer-pricing report should be referenced, but a dedicated customs valuation memorandum is typically the more persuasive instrument in current proceedings.

Third, assess the appeals process strategically. Where a Federal Customs Service adjustment has already been issued following post-clearance audit, the administrative appeal stage – before the regional customs administration and then the Federal Customs Service centrally – remains available and has, in a proportion of matters, produced favourable outcomes without the need for court proceedings. Court proceedings before the arbitrazh court are available where administrative remedies are exhausted or where the importer elects to proceed directly. In practice, the decision between administrative and judicial routes depends on the quality of the available evidentiary record and the scale of the adjustment in dispute.

For matters with a significant adjustment in dispute, instructing Russian customs litigation counsel at the administrative appeal stage – rather than only upon commencement of court proceedings – has in recent practice demonstrably improved the evidentiary foundation available to the court. Counsel experienced in both the Tax Controversy regulatory framework and arbitrazh court procedure for customs matters is relevant here; pure customs brokers do not typically provide the litigation-focused analysis that courts now require.

For related reading on the broader customs valuation framework and strategic considerations, see Navigating customs valuation disputes in Russia and Strategic considerations in customs valuation.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian customs valuation court practice in 2026?

A: Russian arbitrazh courts have raised the evidentiary threshold for upholding declared transaction values in related-party import transactions. Where importers previously succeeded with comparability analyses accepted broadly at face value, courts in 2026 have begun examining whether reference transactions are genuinely analogous in commercial level, quantity, and trade conditions. Simultaneously, courts have declined to treat transfer-pricing documentation as automatically sufficient evidence of arm's-length pricing for customs valuation purposes – these are now treated as distinct analyses under Russian court practice.

Q: Which Turkish-owned Russian groups are affected, and why?

A: Any Russian entity that imports goods from a Turkish parent or affiliate and has declared those transactions under the transaction value method is potentially within scope. The exposure is highest where the import volumes are material, declarations were made within the three-year post-clearance audit window, and the supporting documentation has not been reviewed against the evidentiary standard now applied by Russian courts. Sectors with concentrated Turkish investment in Russia – manufacturing, construction materials, textiles, food processing – carry the most immediate operational exposure.

Q: What should in-house counsel prioritise as an immediate step?

A: The most effective immediate step is a structured review of the comparability analysis and associated documentation for related-party import declarations still within the post-clearance audit window. Where that documentation was prepared under an earlier, more permissive standard, supplementing or replacing it with a customs-specific evidentiary package – before any audit notice is received – substantially improves the position for any subsequent administrative or judicial challenge. Legal advice on whether the existing documentation meets the current standard is the appropriate starting point.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry