Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Article 54.1: Russian Supreme Court practice review under double tax treaty relief: key developments in 2026

Kristina Kornouhova · March 2026 · 9 min read

Supreme Court guidance on Article 54.1 now shapes DTT relief for foreign entities. What in-house counsel must know before the next audit. Make an enquiry.

Following a series of Supreme Court rulings handed down in the first half of 2026, the standard by which Russian tax authorities and courts evaluate Article 54.1 tax benefit denials has shifted in a direction that directly affects foreign-owned entities claiming double tax treaty relief. The Supreme Court's practice review — a formal document consolidating the court's positions across multiple cases — has clarified, and in several respects tightened, the analytical framework that Federal Tax Service inspectors must apply when assessing whether a taxpayer's transaction structure qualifies for treaty-based reduced withholding rates or exemptions. For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries or permanent establishments, the practical consequence is that DTT relief positions previously regarded as low-risk now require fresh scrutiny.

§ I. What changed: the Supreme Court's Article 54.1 practice review in context

Article 54.1 of the Russian Tax Code establishes the general anti-avoidance rule governing the denial of tax benefits. In its original formulation, courts interpreted the provision in two strands: first, whether the primary purpose of a transaction was the obtaining of a tax benefit; and second, whether the obligation under the transaction was performed by the party specified in the agreement. Applied to double tax treaty claims, this two-limb test had by 2024 generated a substantial body of lower-court case law, much of it inconsistent between circuits.

The Supreme Court's 2026 practice review does not repeal or amend Article 54.1. What it does is consolidate the court's preferred interpretive approach into a single authoritative document, which lower courts and Federal Tax Service inspectors are expected to follow. The review addresses three specific areas where prior case law diverged: the evidential standard for establishing beneficial ownership of income by a foreign treaty-resident counterparty; the weight to be given to the economic substance of a foreign parent or intermediary when assessing the availability of reduced withholding rates; and the treatment of intra-group arrangements where the legal form of the transaction and its commercial rationale are considered separately.

The shift is procedural as much as substantive. Before the practice review, an Article 54.1 challenge to a DTT claim required the FTS to establish both limbs of the test with documentary evidence. The review confirms that courts will assess the economic substance of the entire transaction chain — not only the formal counterparty — and that burden-of-proof considerations will be evaluated in light of the taxpayer's access to information about its foreign counterparty's structure. For foreign groups operating through Russian subsidiaries, this reframes the compliance question: it is no longer sufficient to demonstrate that a reduced withholding rate applies under the relevant bilateral treaty; the subsidiary must also be in a position to evidence the economic substance of the foreign recipient of the income.

§ II. Who is affected: which foreign entities face the highest exposure under the revised framework?

The practice review's practical impact is not uniform across all foreign-owned structures in Russia. Exposure concentrates in three categories of entity.

The first category comprises Russian subsidiaries paying dividends, royalties, or interest to parent companies or group treasury entities in treaty-partner jurisdictions where beneficial ownership has not been separately verified and documented. Where the foreign recipient is itself a holding company without operational substance — a structure that was common prior to 2022 for European groups and remains in use among EAEU-resident parent entities — the FTS can now be expected to invoke the practice review's substance analysis to challenge the treaty claim, even if the formal bilateral treaty between Russia and the relevant jurisdiction remains in force.

The second category includes permanent establishments and representative offices that have historically claimed treaty-based relief on income attributable to the head office abroad. The practice review sharpens the analytical lens on transactions where the economic rationale for attributing income to the foreign entity is functional rather than contractual — an area where previous case law was permissive.

The third and increasingly active category encompasses structures involving EAEU member states — Belarus, Kazakhstan, Armenia, and Kyrgyzstan — as intermediate or parent jurisdictions. EAEU treaty arrangements have in some cases been used by groups seeking to preserve reduced-rate access following changes to treaties with other jurisdictions. The 2026 practice review's substance analysis applies equally to EAEU-resident recipients, and the FTS has been explicit in its audit guidance that EAEU residency does not in itself satisfy the beneficial ownership test.

For in-house counsel, the audit risk is asymmetric: the FTS has three years from the filing of the relevant tax return to raise an Article 54.1 challenge, and the financial consequences of a successful challenge — denial of the DTT rate, application of the standard withholding rate, plus interest on the amount underpaid — can be material relative to the cost of early compliance work. Multinational groups that have not reviewed their Russian DTT positions since 2023 should treat this review as a trigger for a structural reassessment.

For in-house counsel assessing DTT relief positions ahead of a Federal Tax Service audit cycle, early external analysis materially reduces exposure. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

"The 2026 practice review effectively raises the evidentiary floor for DTT relief claims in Russia: groups that have relied on formal treaty residency alone, without substantive beneficial ownership documentation, are now carrying a risk that the FTS is actively resourced to pursue." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

§ III. What foreign companies and their advisers should do now

The practical response to the practice review divides into two sequential stages: a diagnostic review of existing DTT positions and, where gaps are identified, a structured remediation before the current audit cycle closes.

The diagnostic review should map each payment stream from the Russian entity to a foreign recipient that is currently structured to benefit from a reduced DTT rate or exemption: dividends to a foreign parent or holding company; royalties under intra-group IP licences; interest on shareholder loans or intra-group funding arrangements; and service fees where a treaty-based reduced rate is being applied. For each stream, in-house counsel should confirm three things: whether the foreign recipient would satisfy a substance analysis under the 2026 practice review standard; whether the internal documentation evidencing beneficial ownership and economic substance was prepared contemporaneously or retrospectively; and whether the relevant bilateral treaty remains in force and has not been suspended or amended since the tax position was originally taken.

The remediation stage is more complex. Where a DTT position is structurally weak, the available responses range from documentary strengthening — preparing or updating a beneficial ownership memorandum — to structural adjustment, which in current conditions requires careful analysis of the available treaty network and the commercial constraints on restructuring. A position that was defensible under pre-2026 case law may not survive an audit conducted by reference to the practice review, and filing an updated return before the FTS opens an audit carries different risk and cost implications than defending the position in proceedings.

In a recent matter, the firm acted for the Russian subsidiary of a Northern European manufacturing group facing an FTS desk audit of its royalty payments under an intra-group IP licence. The audit team applied precisely the substance analysis now formalised in the practice review, challenging the economic rationale for attributing IP ownership to the Dutch group holding company. The matter was resolved at the pre-litigation stage through a combination of documentary support and a reconfigured factual submission, without the subsidiary filing an amended return. The timeline from instruction to resolution was approximately five months.

For groups with more complex multi-jurisdictional structures, the interaction between Article 54.1 challenges and Russia's developing anti-abuse frameworks in other areas — transfer pricing, controlled foreign company rules, and the general anti-avoidance doctrine applied to specific types of transaction — means that a DTT relief review rarely operates in isolation. Our Tax Controversy practice provides integrated analysis across these overlapping frameworks.

For a structured review of your Russian DTT positions in light of the 2026 practice review, request an initial assessment: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in the Russian Supreme Court's approach to Article 54.1 and double tax treaty relief in 2026?

A: The Supreme Court issued a formal practice review in 2026 consolidating its preferred interpretive approach to Article 54.1 challenges in the context of double tax treaty relief claims. The review does not amend the statute, but it clarifies that courts will evaluate the economic substance of the entire transaction chain — not only the formal counterparty named in the agreement — when assessing whether a reduced treaty rate or exemption applies. It also addresses burden-of-proof considerations, confirming that taxpayers with access to information about their foreign counterparty's structure bear a higher evidentiary burden when that structure lacks operational substance. Lower courts and FTS inspectors are expected to follow the review's framework when conducting and adjudicating Article 54.1 challenges.

Q: Which foreign-owned entities operating in Russia are most directly affected by the revised Article 54.1 framework?

A: The highest exposure sits with three categories: Russian subsidiaries paying income to foreign holding companies or group treasury entities that lack operational substance in their treaty-resident jurisdiction; permanent establishments attributing income to a foreign head office on a functional rather than contractual basis; and structures involving EAEU-member-state intermediaries — including Belarusian, Kazakhstani, Armenian, or Kyrgyz entities — that have been used to maintain access to reduced rates following changes to other bilateral treaties. In each case, the 2026 practice review's substance analysis applies regardless of whether the relevant bilateral treaty formally remains in force.

Q: What practical steps should in-house counsel take before the next Federal Tax Service audit of a Russian subsidiary claiming DTT relief?

A: The immediate priority is a diagnostic review of each payment stream currently structured to benefit from a reduced DTT rate or exemption — dividends, royalties, interest, and relevant service fees. For each stream, counsel should confirm that the foreign recipient would satisfy the 2026 substance analysis, that beneficial ownership documentation was prepared contemporaneously, and that the relevant treaty remains in force without amendment or suspension. Where gaps are identified, remediation options range from documentary strengthening to structural adjustment, and the timing of any corrective action relative to an open audit cycle is legally significant. External tax controversy counsel familiar with both the practice review and current FTS audit methodology can identify which positions warrant priority attention.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry