Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Regulatory update: tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts for US-owned Russian groups

Kristina Kornouhova · June 2026 · 8 min read

Russian tax procedure for US-owned Russian subsidiaries shifted materially in 2026. What in-house counsel needs to know now. Make an enquiry.

Following amendments to the administrative and procedural framework governing Russian tax disputes that took effect across the latter part of 2025 and early 2026, US-owned Russian subsidiaries and operating groups now face a materially different environment when contesting Federal Tax Service assessments before Russian arbitrazh courts. The changes affect the pre-litigation appeal sequence, the evidentiary standards applied at first instance, and — critically for intragroup arrangements — the burden that falls on the taxpayer to demonstrate the commercial rationale of related-party transactions. For in-house counsel managing a Russian operating entity within a US-headquartered group, understanding these shifts is no longer optional planning. Under Russian tax procedure, the three-year audit limitation window means that historical transactions — including intragroup pricing and financing arrangements — remain exposed to challenge well after the relevant financial year has closed.

§ I. What changed in Russian tax litigation practice in 2026?

Russian tax litigation before arbitrazh courts proceeds through a defined sequence: a Federal Tax Service field or desk audit produces an assessment; the taxpayer challenges that assessment through two administrative appeal stages within the FTS hierarchy; only after those stages are exhausted can the taxpayer bring proceedings before the relevant regional arbitrazh court. The 2025–2026 amendments altered each of these stages in ways that compound in their effect on foreign-owned groups.

At the audit stage, the Federal Tax Service issued updated methodological guidance reinforcing the primacy of substance-over-form analysis. In practice, this has translated into more granular information requests from auditors directed at documenting the operational substance of intragroup service arrangements, treasury functions, and intellectual property licences held by non-Russian group entities. For US-owned groups in particular, auditors have focused on whether the Russian entity bears genuine economic risk or whether contractual arrangements allocate risk to offshore principals in a manner the FTS characterises as artificial.

At the administrative appeal stage, the revised procedural framework tightened the window for submitting supplementary documentation after the initial objection period. Previously, additional evidence could be introduced with relative flexibility up to the point of the regional appeal. Under the post-2025 regime, the prevailing approach in recent audits has been to treat evidence not submitted at the first administrative stage as inadmissible at subsequent stages, including arbitrazh court proceedings. This shift has significant practical consequences: the audit response and the initial administrative objection now effectively set the ceiling for the evidentiary record before the court.

At the arbitrazh court stage, first-instance panels have applied a more demanding standard when assessing whether intragroup pricing reflects arm's-length commercial terms. Courts have generally required taxpayers to present contemporaneous economic analyses — transfer pricing documentation, comparability studies, functional analyses — rather than accepting post-hoc expert reports prepared for litigation purposes. For a US-headquartered group with a Russian subsidiary, this means that documentation habitually prepared in English for US or OECD reporting purposes must be translated, contextualised under Russian transfer pricing methodology, and submitted at the audit stage, not assembled after an assessment has been issued.

For in-house counsel reviewing the current exposure of a US-owned Russian operating entity, the pre-litigation preparation window is the decisive one — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which US-owned Russian groups are most affected?

The procedural developments described above affect all taxpayers litigating before Russian arbitrazh courts. Their impact, however, is disproportionately significant for groups with a US parent or US intermediate holding company, for three structural reasons.

First, the geopolitical context — without entering political commentary — has produced a regulatory environment in which the Federal Tax Service applies heightened scrutiny to cross-border transactions involving US-resident entities. Auditors have been documented requesting, through formal information-exchange mechanisms, corroborating evidence of the counterparty's tax residence, beneficial ownership, and the substance of its Russian-connected activities. US groups that have historically relied on intercompany agreements drafted to satisfy US tax counsel's requirements may find that those agreements do not address the specific documentary benchmarks applied by Russian auditors.

Second, groups structured with US holding companies often present treasury and cash-pooling arrangements that are treated as loan relationships for Russian tax purposes. The deductibility of interest payments to related non-Russian parties has been an active area of FTS audit activity, and the litigation record in Russian arbitrazh courts through 2025 and 2026 shows that courts have upheld FTS disallowances where the taxpayer could not demonstrate a clear commercial purpose independent of tax optimisation. Groups whose Russian entities carry significant intragroup debt to US treasury vehicles should treat their interest deduction positions as an audit priority.

Third, and less obviously, US-owned Russian groups engaged in licensing Russian intellectual property to non-Russian group entities — or receiving licence income from US intellectual property owners — have faced challenge to the characterisation and pricing of those arrangements. Russian courts have generally applied a sceptical lens to royalty streams that flow from the Russian operating entity upward to a US or US-linked intellectual property holding vehicle, particularly where the Russian entity carries the commercial development costs of the underlying intangible.

"What the 2025–2026 procedural changes mean in practice is that the audit response is now effectively the first pleading — the evidentiary record assembled at that stage will govern the arbitrazh court proceedings that follow." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

§ III. What foreign in-house counsel should do now

The practical implications of these developments translate into a concrete set of actions for GCs and tax directors responsible for Russian operating entities within US-headquartered groups.

The most important shift in approach concerns timing. The tendency among foreign groups to engage specialist Russian tax counsel at the point at which a court claim becomes necessary — after the FTS assessment and after the administrative appeals — leaves counsel working within an evidentiary record that was assembled without litigation strategy in mind. Under the current framework for tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts, the audit response and first administrative objection are where the case is built or conceded. Engaging Russian tax litigation counsel at the audit stage, rather than the court stage, is no longer an optional efficiency measure.

The second priority concerns documentation. Transfer pricing files, intragroup service agreements, treasury policy documents, and intellectual property licensing arrangements should be reviewed for their alignment with Russian methodological requirements — not merely US or OECD standards. Where gaps exist, the appropriate response is a structured documentation exercise before the next audit cycle opens, not a reactive translation of existing English-language files.

Third, groups with active or recently concluded Russian FTS audits should verify whether the administrative appeal deadlines under the revised framework have been correctly mapped. The tightened submission windows that now apply under the prevailing procedural approach are strict, and missed deadlines at the administrative stage cannot be recovered in arbitrazh court proceedings.

For a structured analysis of the current litigation framework applicable to your Russian entity, our Tax Controversy practice is available to conduct a preliminary review of your audit exposure and litigation readiness. We have advised US and other foreign-headquartered groups on tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts through successive cycles of FTS audit activity. Our practical guide to the procedural sequence is available at A practical guide to tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts and a detailed treatment of the legal framework is set out in The law and practice of tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts. For groups with parallel regulatory exposures, our Matters Hub contains illustrative examples of prior mandates in this area.

For a preliminary review of your Russian entity's audit exposure and litigation readiness — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian tax litigation procedure in 2025–2026 that affects US-owned groups?

A: The Federal Tax Service introduced updated methodological guidance reinforcing substance-over-form analysis at the audit stage, and the administrative appeal framework was tightened to restrict the introduction of new evidence after the initial objection period. In practice, this means that evidence not placed on the record during the audit response and first administrative appeal is treated as inadmissible in arbitrazh court proceedings. For US-owned Russian groups, the combined effect is that transfer pricing documentation, intragroup service agreements, and commercial rationale materials must be assembled and submitted at the audit stage — not prepared retrospectively for litigation.

Q: Which categories of US-owned Russian operating entity face the greatest exposure under the updated framework?

A: Entities carrying intragroup debt to US treasury vehicles, entities receiving or paying royalties to US intellectual property holding companies, and entities structured with thin operational substance in Russia but significant contractual obligations to US-resident related parties are the three categories facing the greatest scrutiny. The Federal Tax Service has focused audit activity on these structures across 2025 and 2026, and Russian arbitrazh courts have upheld FTS disallowances in cases where taxpayers could not demonstrate a clear commercial purpose for the relevant arrangements independent of tax optimisation objectives.

Q: What should in-house counsel do now to reduce exposure before the next audit cycle?

A: Three steps are priorities. First, engage Russian tax litigation counsel at the audit stage — not only when court proceedings are imminent — so that the evidentiary record is built with the litigation sequence in mind. Second, review transfer pricing files and intragroup agreement documentation for alignment with Russian methodological requirements, not only US or OECD standards. Third, verify that all administrative appeal deadlines applicable to any active or recently completed FTS audit have been correctly identified under the revised procedural framework. The Tax Controversy practice at Vetrov & Partners can assist with each of these steps.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry