Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups against state-related entities: key developments in 2027

Kristina Kornouhova · September 2026 · 10 min read

Russia's 2027 VAT refund rules tightened for foreign-owned groups facing state-entity counterparties. What in-house counsel should review. Make an enquiry.

Three developments in early 2027 have shifted the practical landscape for VAT refund disputes in Russia, and foreign-owned Russian groups transacting with state-related entities are bearing the majority of their impact. The Federal Tax Service has intensified the documentary scrutiny applied to input VAT recovery claims where the supplier or buyer sits in the state-sector orbit – a counterparty category that includes not only federal and regional state enterprises but also entities in which the state holds a controlling or significant participating interest. For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries, understanding what has changed, who is directly affected, and what the corrective steps are is a matter of operational priority rather than theoretical interest.

What changed in Russian VAT refund practice in 2027?

The most significant shift concerns the evidentiary standard applied during desk audits of VAT refund claims submitted by Russian legal entities with foreign ultimate beneficial ownership. Historically, the FTS treated such claims under a broadly uniform audit methodology, with heightened scrutiny reserved for high-risk sectors and transactions exhibiting features associated with VAT carousel arrangements. Since the first quarter of 2027, the prevailing approach has moved toward a differentiated standard: VAT refund claims arising from transactions with state-related entities are now routinely subject to extended desk audit timelines and an expanded document request regime.

In practice, this means that where a foreign-owned Russian operating company – a subsidiary of a European, Asian, or other non-Russian group – has supplied goods or services to a state enterprise or a majority state-owned company, and subsequently seeks to recover input VAT, the FTS has generally demanded documentation that goes substantially beyond the standard invoice-and-contract package. Requested materials have, in a number of recent matters, included evidence of the commercial rationale for the transaction, supporting correspondence, confirmations of actual delivery or service performance, and, in some instances, information concerning the foreign parent's ultimate beneficial owners.

The second development relates to the treatment of VAT refund claims in the context of intercompany pricing. State-related entities are, as a class, subject to separate transfer-pricing monitoring by the FTS. Where a transaction between a foreign-owned group member and a state-related entity has been identified as a controlled transaction for transfer-pricing purposes, the FTS has in the first half of 2027 increasingly linked the transfer-pricing inquiry to the VAT refund assessment – querying whether the contract price, and therefore the VAT base, was consistent with arm's-length standards before confirming the refund. This linkage is not new in principle, but its systematic application to cross-sector transactions involving state counterparties marks a material change from practice as recently as 2025.

The third development, and the one with the most immediate procedural consequence, is the extension of VAT refund dispute timelines at the pre-litigation stage. The FTS's internal escalation procedures for refund claims touching state-related entity transactions appear to require, as a matter of standard internal routing, a referral to a specialised control unit before a refund decision is issued. In practice, groups are reporting that the pre-litigation window – from claim submission through the administrative appeal stage – has extended by several months relative to the timelines that were customary before these procedural changes came into effect.

"The systematic linkage of VAT refund assessments to transfer-pricing positions, specifically in transactions involving state-related counterparties, is the development that foreign-owned groups most frequently underestimate when they first encounter a refund denial in Russia in 2027." — Kristina Kornouhova, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Tax & Antitrust, Vetrov & Partners

Which foreign-owned Russian groups are most affected?

The developments described above affect foreign-owned Russian groups unevenly, and the practical impact depends on three variables: the nature of the counterparty, the transaction type, and the group's existing compliance posture on VAT documentation.

Foreign-owned groups with Russian operating subsidiaries that supply goods, works, or services to state enterprises are the most directly affected category. This includes – but is not limited to – engineering and construction groups with public-infrastructure contracts, technology providers with government or state-enterprise clients, energy-sector service companies, and logistics operators whose primary or significant customer base sits within the state-owned sector. For these groups, the expanded document request regime is not a theoretical risk; it is a likely feature of the next VAT refund claim cycle.

Groups operating under long-term framework agreements with state-related entities face a particular variant of the problem. Where VAT refund claims accumulate across multiple reporting periods under the same framework agreement, the FTS's extended audit approach applies across each period's claim sequentially rather than once at the contract level. This means that the administrative burden is cumulative, and that an initial refund denial on evidentiary grounds sets a precedent that the same evidentiary package is insufficient for all subsequent claims under the same agreement unless the documentation approach is proactively revised.

Russian subsidiaries of groups headquartered in EAEU member states are not formally exempted from the heightened standard. While the EAEU's common VAT rules create a degree of regulatory convergence for cross-border supplies within the bloc, the FTS's differentiated approach to desk audits of state-related entity transactions operates as a domestic procedural layer that applies regardless of the parent group's EAEU membership. CIS-based groups operating through Russian entities should apply the same analysis.

For in-house counsel, the groups carrying the highest unhedged exposure are those whose Russian finance functions have continued to manage VAT refund submissions under pre-2026 documentation protocols – protocols designed for the uniform audit standard that no longer applies in this counterparty category.

For groups whose Russian subsidiaries are currently in the refund cycle or approaching a refund claim submission, the administrative timeline changes mean that the working capital assumptions underlying intercompany treasury models may require revision. Under the standard interpretation of the current extended pre-litigation window, a VAT refund claim that would previously have resolved within three to four months of submission may now remain outstanding for six months or longer before the administrative stage is complete – a window that carries direct implications for Russian subsidiary liquidity planning.

For in-house counsel assessing the VAT compliance posture of a Russian subsidiary with state-entity counterparties, the regulatory timeline leaves limited margin for delay. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What should foreign-owned groups do now?

Three actions represent the practical priority at this stage of the development cycle.

First, audit the existing VAT documentation protocol for all transactions with state-related entity counterparties. The standard invoice-and-contract package that satisfies an FTS desk audit in a routine commercial context is, under the prevailing approach for state-related entity transactions, unlikely to be sufficient. The documentation baseline should be expanded to include contemporaneous evidence of transaction purpose, delivery or performance confirmation, and – where the transaction is or may be a controlled transaction – a record of the pricing rationale at the time the contract was executed. This is not a retrospective exercise for already-submitted claims; it is a prospective protocol adjustment for claims not yet filed.

Second, assess whether any pending or recently submitted VAT refund claims involving state-related entity counterparties have been or are likely to be the subject of a transfer-pricing linkage inquiry. Where the FTS has opened a desk audit that includes both VAT refund and transfer-pricing questions, the response should be coordinated across both tracks from the outset. Responding to each inquiry in isolation, without a unified position on the pricing and VAT base, creates inconsistency risk that the FTS exploits at the administrative appeal stage.

Third, revisit the working capital and cash-flow assumptions in the Russian subsidiary's financial model. The extended pre-litigation window identified in the first half of 2027 should be treated as a structural feature of the current environment rather than a temporary administrative delay. Treasury and finance functions should be modelling VAT refund timelines on the basis of the extended period, and intercompany funding arrangements should be reviewed to ensure that prolonged refund delays do not create liquidity constraints at the Russian subsidiary level that require emergency intercompany lending under conditions that generate additional transfer-pricing scrutiny.

Our Tax Controversy practice has acted for foreign-owned Russian groups in administrative and judicial VAT refund disputes across a range of counterparty types. For groups with state-related entity exposure, earlier engagement with the documentation and procedural strategy is materially more effective than reactive defence after a refund denial has been issued. See also our practice note on navigating VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned groups and our comparative analysis of VAT refund dispute strategies for the detailed procedural framework underlying the steps described above.

Open questions and areas of uncertainty

Several aspects of the 2027 developments remain unresolved in formal guidance, and in-house counsel should be aware of the practical implications of that uncertainty.

The scope of the "state-related entity" category is not defined with precision in any consolidated regulatory instrument. The FTS's approach, as observed in practice, applies the heightened audit standard to a broad class that includes majority state-owned entities, entities in which the state holds a blocking minority, and entities operating under state concession arrangements. The outer boundary of this category – whether it extends, for example, to private companies that derive a predominant share of revenue from state contracts without direct state ownership – has not been authoritatively settled. The prevailing interpretation among practitioners at mid-2027 is that the FTS applies the standard to direct ownership structures rather than revenue-based proxies, but this position may be tested as audit practice develops.

The interaction between the extended VAT refund audit process and the Russian court system's approach to expedited review of administrative denials is a second area of open uncertainty. Courts have generally maintained the established judicial review timelines for tax dispute cases, but the administrative elongation of the pre-litigation stage means that the overall dispute cycle from claim to judicial resolution has lengthened in practice. Whether courts will, in time, respond to this by accelerating the litigation phase is an open question at this stage.

For groups with Russian assets, information on how these developments are tracking through Russian arbitrazh courts is available through our Matters Hub and through direct enquiry with the team.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russia's VAT refund rules for 2027?

A: Three developments have materialised in practice since the start of 2027. The FTS has applied an expanded documentary standard to VAT refund claims arising from transactions with state-related entity counterparties, requiring materials beyond the standard invoice-and-contract package. The FTS has also systematically linked VAT refund assessments to transfer-pricing inquiries where the relevant transaction is a controlled transaction. Finally, the pre-litigation administrative timeline for refund claims in this category has extended by several months relative to prior practice, reflecting internal FTS routing changes. These developments are observed in practice rather than codified in a single legislative amendment, which means the documentary and procedural adjustments required are not prescribed in formal guidance – they must be derived from audit practice and administrative appeal outcomes.

Q: Which foreign-owned groups are directly affected by these VAT refund developments?

A: Foreign-owned Russian operating subsidiaries that supply goods, works, or services to state enterprises or majority state-owned entities are directly in scope. The practical impact is highest for groups in engineering, technology, energy services, and logistics with significant state-sector client exposure. Groups operating under long-term framework agreements with state-related entities face a cumulative documentation burden across successive claim periods. Russian subsidiaries of groups headquartered in EAEU or CIS member states are not exempt – the FTS's differentiated audit standard applies as a domestic procedural matter regardless of the parent entity's jurisdiction. The critical risk indicator for in-house counsel is whether the Russian subsidiary's current VAT documentation protocol was designed for the pre-2026 uniform audit standard or has been updated to reflect the expanded requirements.

Q: What should in-house counsel do now in response to these developments?

A: Three actions are the practical priority. First, update the VAT documentation protocol for all transactions with state-related entity counterparties before the next claim cycle. Second, where any pending VAT refund claim intersects with a transfer-pricing inquiry, coordinate the response to both tracks under a unified position. Third, revise working capital assumptions in the Russian subsidiary's financial model to reflect an extended refund timeline. Groups that are currently in or approaching the refund cycle should seek specific advice on the documentation package and on the interaction between the VAT and transfer-pricing tracks before submissions are made or responses to FTS information requests are filed.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry