Client. A Swiss manufacturing group importing industrial components into Russia through a wholly owned Russian trading subsidiary. The client's procurement and compliance functions were managed from Zurich, with day-to-day customs clearance handled locally.
Background. Russian customs authorities opened a post-clearance audit targeting the declared customs value of a series of import consignments. The authority contended that the transaction value method had been improperly applied and that the declared prices — agreed between the Swiss parent and its Russian subsidiary — did not reflect arm's-length terms for customs valuation purposes. The audit resulted in an assessment significantly increasing the dutiable value across multiple commodity codes, with administrative penalties imposed on top of the additional duties. The client faced a compounding exposure across several declaration periods, as the authority indicated it intended to extend the audit to earlier consignments if the initial assessment was not contested. The matter required analysis across Russian customs legislation, transfer-pricing documentation maintained for Federal Tax Service purposes, and the rules applicable under the EAEU Customs Code — a regulatory layer that foreign in-house teams frequently underestimate.
Our role. Vetrov & Partners was instructed to challenge the post-clearance assessment through the administrative appeal procedure before the regional customs authority and, on continuation, before the Federal Customs Service. Counsel analysed the basis on which the authority had rejected the transaction value method, reviewed the pricing documentation and existing transfer-pricing study, and prepared a consolidated legal position addressing both the customs valuation methodology and the procedural deficiencies in the audit conduct. The firm coordinated with the client's Zurich-based tax function to align the customs valuation arguments with the existing intercompany pricing documentation, avoiding inconsistency across the two regulatory regimes.
Outcome. The customs duty reassessment was successfully challenged; additional duties and administrative penalties were vacated in full on appeal. The Federal Customs Service upheld the transaction value method as originally applied, accepting the client's documentation and legal submissions. The additional duty exposure was eliminated, and the penalty assessments were cancelled. The matter was resolved within 11 months of initial instruction, without recourse to the arbitrazh courts.
Discuss a similar matter — info@vetrovpartners.com
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry