TAX DISPUTE — RUSSIA / NETHERLANDS — DOUBLE TAX TREATY · BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP · INDIVIDUAL DEBTORS Client. A Dutch investment holding company with a direct participation interest in a Russian operating entity in the Siberian Federal District.
TAX DISPUTE — RUSSIA / NETHERLANDS — DOUBLE TAX TREATY · BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP · INDIVIDUAL DEBTORS
Client. A Dutch investment holding company with a direct participation interest in a Russian operating entity in the Siberian Federal District.
Background. The counterparties — individual former directors of the Russian entity — sought to establish subsidiary liability against the foreign investor on the basis that the investor's reliance on the Russia–Netherlands double tax treaty was improper. The claim combined an attack on the investor's beneficial ownership status under Russian tax law with a subsidiary liability argument directed at the individuals. The interaction between treaty entitlement, beneficial ownership assessment, and the subsidiary liability mechanism under Russian insolvency and civil legislation created a multi-layered procedural challenge of a kind rarely encountered in first-instance tax proceedings.
Our role. The firm advised the Dutch investor throughout the first-instance proceedings before the Russian arbitrazh court. Counsel prepared the investor's position on beneficial ownership, analysed the applicable double tax treaty provisions, and coordinated with the investor's Netherlands advisers on the cross-border aspects of the matter. The firm challenged the legal basis of the subsidiary liability claim and the counterparties' standing to bring it in this form.
Outcome. Subsidiary liability claim dismissed at first instance. The court rejected the counterparties' challenge to the investor's treaty entitlement and found no grounds to impose subsidiary liability on the individuals. Resolution achieved within approximately 11 months of instruction.
Discuss a similar matter — info@vetrovpartners.com
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry