Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

A practical guide to tax litigation before Russian arbitrazh courts under Article 122 of the Tax Code for foreign companies

Kristina Kornouhova · February 2026 · 12 min read

Russian tax authorities routinely apply Article 122 penalties to foreign companies. A step-by-step guide to contesting them. Make an enquiry.

Unlike many civil law jurisdictions, which consolidate tax disputes within a single administrative tribunal, Russian law routes tax litigation for corporate entities through the general commercial court system — the arbitrazh courts — following a mandatory pre-trial stage. For in-house counsel at a foreign company with a Russian subsidiary or permanent establishment, this procedural architecture has direct consequences: missing a single deadline in the pre-trial chain can extinguish the right to judicial review entirely. This guide sets out the sequence of steps a foreign company should follow when contesting a penalty assessment under Article 122 of the Tax Code, from the audit act through to arbitrazh court proceedings and, where necessary, appellate review.

What to prepare before you begin — checklist

Before responding to any Federal Tax Service assessment, in-house counsel should verify the following:

Assembling this package before the first formal response is submitted substantially reduces the risk of evidentiary gaps at the court stage. Russian arbitrazh courts are reluctant to admit documents that were not presented at the administrative stage, and the Federal Tax Service routinely relies on this restriction.

Step 1. Understand what Article 122 charges and what it does not

Article 122 of the Tax Code imposes a financial penalty for non-payment or underpayment of tax resulting from an understated tax base, incorrect application of the applicable tax rate, or other unlawful acts or omissions. The standard penalty is a percentage of the unpaid tax amount. An aggravated rate applies where the understated liability is found to be intentional — a characterisation the Federal Tax Service increasingly applies in transfer pricing and related-party transaction disputes.

Three points are critical for foreign companies specifically.

First, Article 122 is a penalty provision — it is separate from the obligation to pay the underlying tax arrears and interest. Contesting the penalty and contesting the arrears assessment follow the same procedural path, but they are legally distinct. A company that partially concedes arrears may still mount a full defence to the Article 122 penalty if the factual predicate for the penalty charge is not established.

Second, Article 122 does not apply where the company has submitted an amended return and paid the additional liability before the tax authority opened a formal audit. The timing of the inspectorate's audit initiation notice therefore matters and should be verified at the outset.

Third, there is a limitation period for penalty assessments. The Federal Tax Service cannot assess a penalty for a period that falls outside the statutory limitation window. This is a threshold point that should be checked before any substantive response is prepared.

Step 2. Respond to the audit act — what must your written objections include?

The written objection (возражения на акт проверки) is the first formal document in the dispute chain. It is not a formality. Russian courts treat the positions taken at the objection stage as the foundation for the subsequent administrative appeal and, ultimately, the judicial claim. Positions introduced for the first time at court are technically admissible but frequently attract adverse comment from the bench.

An effective written objection should address four elements:

Procedural objections — any breach of the inspection procedure itself (notification failures, scope of inspection exceeding what was authorised, timing violations). Procedural violations do not automatically void an assessment, but they are material to the administrative appeal and can affect cost outcomes at court.Factual objections — a point-by-point challenge to the factual findings in the audit act, supported by primary documents. Each disputed finding should be addressed with a specific counter-narrative and the corresponding documentary evidence indexed.Legal objections — the applicable tax treatment under Russian law, citing the branch of legislation and the official Ministry of Finance and Federal Tax Service guidance that supports the company's position. Where those positions diverge from the audit act's legal characterisation, the conflict should be articulated clearly.Quantum objections — even where liability is conceded in principle, the calculation of the understated base, the applicable rate, and the penalty arithmetic should be independently verified and, where the inspectorate has made computational errors, challenged directly.

The objection is submitted to the inspectorate that issued the audit act. The submission deadline runs from the date of receipt of the act — business days, not calendar days — and the precise date of receipt should be documented carefully.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary facing an Article 122 assessment, the objection stage is often where the factual record is most effectively built or, where it is neglected, most damagingly compromised.

If your company has received a Federal Tax Service audit act and requires assistance with the written objection stage — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 3. Navigate the mandatory pre-trial administrative appeal

Under Russian tax procedure, a company may not file a claim in arbitrazh court without first exhausting the administrative appeal route. This requirement is absolute: an arbitrazh court will return or leave without consideration any claim that bypasses it.

The administrative appeal is filed with the superior tax authority — in most cases, the regional directorate of the Federal Tax Service that oversees the inspectorate that issued the challenged decision. The appeal must be filed within the statutory period running from the date the challenged decision entered into force. For in-force decisions, this window is strictly observed; late appeals are not accepted.

The appeal is decided on the documents. There is no oral hearing at this stage in ordinary cases. The reviewing authority may uphold the decision in full, reduce the assessment, or — in a minority of cases — issue a fresh decision. Critically, the superior authority may also increase the assessed liability. This asymmetric risk means that the appeal must be prepared with the same rigour as a court filing.

Several points are relevant for foreign companies in particular. If the challenged decision concerns a company that is tax-resident in a state with which Russia has a double taxation agreement — including most European Union member states, the United Kingdom, EAEU member states, and CIS jurisdictions — the tax treaty provisions may be relevant both to the substantive challenge and to the framing of the administrative appeal. Treaty arguments should be raised at this stage, not reserved for court.

The decision of the superior authority is the gateway to judicial proceedings. Once issued — or once the statutory review period expires without a decision — the company has the right to file in arbitrazh court.

Step 4. How should the arbitrazh court claim be structured?

The claim (заявление) filed in the arbitrazh court is a document of record. Unlike many common law jurisdictions, where pleadings are relatively brief and evidence is developed through disclosure, the Russian arbitrazh procedure is document-centric from the outset. The court will expect a complete evidentiary package at the time of filing.

The claim must identify the specific act, decision, or action being challenged; set out the legal basis for the challenge; and be accompanied by the full evidentiary bundle, including the audit act, the company's objections, the inspectorate's decision, the administrative appeal, the superior authority's decision, and all supporting primary documents. Filing fees must be paid and the payment receipt attached.

Venue rules require the claim to be filed in the arbitrazh court for the district in which the tax authority that issued the challenged decision is located. This is a jurisdiction point that foreign companies — whose registered address in Russia may differ from the inspectorate that conducted the audit — should verify before filing.

Time limit: the claim must be filed within three months of the date the company learned of the violation of its rights. In practice, this period runs from the date the superior authority's decision was received (or deemed received). This is a hard limitation. Russian arbitrazh courts restore the period only in genuinely exceptional circumstances. In-house counsel managing a Russian tax dispute should treat this deadline as the single most critical procedural date in the matter.

Under Russian arbitrazh procedure, the court conducts a preliminary hearing to verify admissibility and completeness before scheduling the main hearing. At the main hearing, witnesses are rare; the proceedings are primarily a legal argument over the documentary record already filed. Interim measures — suspension of enforcement of the tax decision pending judgment — are available but subject to conditions, and applications for them should be prepared as a separate procedural step if the assessment involves an imminent enforcement risk.

For in-house counsel who have reached this stage, co-ordinating directly with Russian litigation counsel — who will appear before the court and whose signature must be on the court filings — is the practical priority. The firm's Tax Controversy practice regularly acts in Article 122 disputes before arbitrazh courts in the Siberian and Ural federal districts.

If you are preparing or considering an arbitrazh court claim in a Russian tax dispute — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 5. Appellate and cassation review — when is it worth pursuing?

A first-instance arbitrazh court judgment may be appealed to the appellate arbitrazh court (апелляционный арбитражный суд) as of right, within one month of the judgment being issued. The appeal is a full review on the merits of both law and fact. New documents may be introduced only in limited circumstances, which reinforces the importance of completeness at the first-instance stage.

If the appellate court confirms the first-instance judgment, the company may file a cassation complaint with the relevant circuit cassation court (кассационный арбитражный суд). Cassation review is limited to questions of law — the cassation court does not re-examine the factual record. A cassation complaint may also be filed directly against a first-instance judgment where the case falls within a specific category, though this is the exception rather than the rule in tax disputes.

Beyond cassation, extraordinary review before the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation — through a cassation complaint to the Economic Disputes Panel — is available in principle. In practice, it is granted in cases that present questions of law with systemic significance. For foreign companies, this avenue is worth assessing where the legal point at issue has broader application across the company's Russian operations or where there is a conflict of circuit-level practice.

The decision to pursue appeal and cassation depends on the strength of the residual legal arguments, the tax amount at stake, and the broader risk of the judgment being used as a precedent against the company in related proceedings. The firm has acted in Article 122 cassation matters and can provide a realistic assessment of the appellate prospects in a specific case. Details of representative matters are available on the Matters page.

For further reading on the procedural mechanics of Russian tax litigation and the litigation landscape more broadly, see Tax Litigation Before Russian Arbitrazh Courts and The Law and Practice of Tax Litigation Before Russian Courts.

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long does the arbitrazh court stage typically take in an Article 122 tax dispute in Russia?

A: At first instance, Russian arbitrazh courts in tax disputes typically schedule a preliminary hearing within one to two months of the claim being filed, with the main hearing following within two to four months of that. Judgment is usually issued within a further month. In practice, a first-instance decision in a mid-complexity tax dispute can be expected within four to seven months of filing. If the case proceeds to the appellate level, add two to three months for that stage. Cassation review at circuit level adds a further two to four months. These ranges are indicative — courts in different circuits and in busier periods will vary, and particularly complex or high-value cases can take longer at each stage.

Q: What documentation does a foreign company typically need to prepare before filing an arbitrazh court claim in a Russian tax dispute?

A: The core filing package is: the original audit act; the company's written objections; the inspectorate's final decision; the administrative appeal to the superior tax authority; the superior authority's decision (or evidence of its expiry without decision); all primary accounting and contractual documents supporting the disputed tax positions; Russian-language translations of any foreign-language documents (certified where required); the power of attorney authorising Russian-qualified counsel; and evidence of payment of the court filing fee. Transfer pricing disputes require in addition the complete transfer pricing documentation package. Gaps in this bundle at the filing stage are difficult to remedy later — the arbitrazh procedure places the evidentiary burden on the claimant from the outset.

Q: What happens if the mandatory pre-trial administrative appeal stage is skipped or the filing deadline is missed?

A: If the pre-trial appeal requirement is not satisfied, the arbitrazh court will return the claim without consideration — it will not be examined on the merits. This is not a technical default that can be cured by re-filing with an explanation; the court's return of the claim is recorded and the pre-trial stage must then be completed before the claim is re-filed. Missing the deadline for the pre-trial appeal itself — the period running from the date the inspectorate's decision enters into force — is more serious: an appeal filed out of time will be rejected, and the right to challenge the decision through the administrative channel is lost. The company would then need to rely on an alternative judicial route, which is more limited in scope and carries additional risk. For foreign companies unfamiliar with Russian procedural timelines, the pre-trial deadline is the single most frequently missed step in the Article 122 dispute sequence.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry