Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

A practical guide to VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups under CFC rules under Article 25.13 of the Tax Code for foreign companies

Kristina Kornouhova · May 2026 · 10 min read

Foreign-owned Russian subsidiaries face layered scrutiny in VAT refund disputes under CFC rules. A step-by-step guide for in-house counsel. Make an enquiry.

Unlike most OECD jurisdictions, where a VAT refund claim triggers a relatively standardised administrative review, Russian VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned groups unfold under two overlapping regulatory regimes. The first is the general VAT refund procedure administered by the Federal Tax Service (FTS). The second is the controlled foreign company framework under Russian law, which treats the foreign parent's ownership structure as a lens through which every material transaction of the Russian subsidiary is examined. For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries, understanding how these two regimes interact is the practical starting point – not a technicality.

What to prepare before submitting a VAT refund claim

Before a refund application reaches the FTS, the subsidiary's document base must be complete. An incomplete submission is one of the most common – and entirely avoidable – reasons that Russian tax authorities escalate a routine refund review into a full desk audit. Prepare the following:

Note: Where the Russian subsidiary is part of a structure in which the foreign parent holds a controlling interest, the FTS is specifically authorised to request the parent's financial statements and CFC-related filings as part of the desk audit. Failure to provide these documents within the statutory response window is treated as non-cooperation and may result in a refund suspension. Prepare these materials in advance, not in response to an FTS demand.

If your Russian subsidiary has a pending VAT refund claim and CFC obligations are in scope, make an enquiry before the FTS initiates its desk audit: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 1 — Assess the CFC position before filing

The first procedural step is not the refund filing itself. It is a structured assessment of whether the foreign group's ownership of the Russian subsidiary creates CFC obligations that will affect how the FTS reviews the refund claim.

Under CFC rules in Russian law – codified principally under Article 25.13 of the Tax Code – a foreign entity or individual is treated as a "controlling person" of a Russian company where the ownership threshold and control criteria are met. The practical consequence for VAT refund disputes is significant: the FTS is entitled to test whether transactions generating input VAT were conducted at arm's length and whether the economic substance of those transactions was genuine, with the CFC structure serving as circumstantial context for that analysis.

At this stage, in-house counsel should confirm: (i) whether CFC notifications have been filed for all relevant periods; (ii) whether the foreign parent has undisclosed offshore holding layers that the FTS may identify independently through automatic exchange-of-information mechanisms; and (iii) whether any intercompany transactions that generated input VAT could be characterised as non-arm's-length under transfer-pricing rules. These three questions directly shape the litigation risk in any subsequent VAT refund dispute.

For a comparative analysis of how this framework applies across different foreign ownership structures, see Comparative analysis: VAT refund disputes for foreign-owned Russian groups.

Step 2 — Submit the refund claim and manage the desk audit window

Once the document base is complete and the CFC position has been assessed, the refund claim is submitted to the FTS as part of the quarterly VAT return. The FTS then has a statutory period to conduct a desk audit (камеральная проверка). During this window, the tax authority may request documentary explanations, conduct counterparty checks (встречная проверка), and – where the ownership structure raises CFC concerns – extend the audit into a review of the intercompany transaction chain.

For foreign-owned groups, the audit window is routinely used to scrutinise three categories of transactions: (i) purchases from suppliers who are themselves connected to offshore structures; (ii) intercompany service agreements where the fee level is disputed; and (iii) import transactions where customs value and VAT base may diverge from what the FTS calculates independently.

In-house counsel should establish a designated point of contact for FTS correspondence during this period. All responses to FTS requests must be submitted within the statutory deadlines – extensions are not automatically granted. Where a request concerns CFC-related documentation, the response should be prepared with specialist tax counsel, since the characterisation of the response can affect the framing of any subsequent appeal.

The firm's Tax Controversy practice regularly assists foreign-owned groups at this stage – including preparing responses to FTS requests that combine VAT and CFC elements.

What happens if the FTS issues a refusal decision?

A refusal to refund VAT – whether in full or in part – will be issued in the form of a reasoned decision following the desk audit. For foreign-owned Russian groups under CFC rules, refusal decisions typically cite one or more of the following grounds: (i) absence of genuine economic substance in transactions giving rise to input VAT; (ii) failure to confirm the arm's-length character of intercompany transactions; (iii) supplier-side irregularities identified through counterparty checks; or (iv) non-disclosure or incomplete disclosure of CFC obligations affecting the group structure.

The refusal triggers a two-stage administrative appeal process before court proceedings can be initiated. The subsidiary must first file an objection with the same FTS inspectorate that issued the decision. If the objection is unsuccessful, an appeal to the regional FTS management is mandatory before filing a claim with the arbitrazh court.

This pre-court administrative path is not optional – Russian procedural law requires that it be exhausted in full before judicial recourse is available. Foreign-owned groups frequently underestimate the evidentiary importance of the administrative appeal stage: the written objection filed at this point forms the primary record for subsequent court proceedings, and arguments not raised administratively may be treated as waived in the arbitrazh court.

Under Russian insolvency and creditor-priority rules, unresolved VAT refund claims also interact with the subsidiary's balance-sheet position in ways that matter to group treasury and to restructuring considerations. Quantifying the refund exposure early is therefore relevant beyond the tax function alone.

For further background on how Russian courts have approached VAT refund disputes in the context of CFC-related arguments, see Russian Supreme Court clarification on VAT refund disputes.

If your Russian subsidiary has received an FTS refusal decision on a VAT refund claim, contact the team before the administrative appeal deadline: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 3 — Pursue the administrative appeal and prepare for arbitrazh court

The administrative objection to the FTS inspectorate must set out the legal and factual grounds on which the refusal is contested. For disputes with a CFC dimension, the objection should address directly any FTS characterisation of the group structure as a basis for the refusal. Leaving the CFC framing unanswered at the objection stage significantly weakens the subsequent appeal.

If the regional FTS management appeal is unsuccessful, the claim is brought before the relevant arbitrazh court. The procedural rules applicable to tax disputes in Russian arbitrazh courts are distinct from general commercial litigation rules, and the evidentiary standard applied to CFC-related arguments has been evolving. Courts in the Siberian and Ural circuits have addressed CFC-related VAT arguments in a number of disputes, and the procedural approach – including the burden of proof allocation between the taxpayer and the FTS – is relevant to how the claim is structured.

In court, the subsidiary bears the initial burden of demonstrating that the VAT refund is legally founded. The FTS then bears the burden of substantiating any CFC-related grounds for refusal. Where the FTS relies on automatic exchange-of-information data or FTS databases to establish the offshore dimension of the group structure, the taxpayer's ability to respond to that evidence depends on prior preparation. This is why Step 1 (the pre-filing CFC assessment) directly affects the outcome at this stage.

The firm's prior matters in this area – reviewed in our Matters Hub – include creditor-side and taxpayer-side mandates in tax proceedings before Siberian circuit arbitrazh courts.

Step 4 — Manage the post-dispute compliance position

A concluded VAT refund dispute – whether resolved at administrative appeal or after court proceedings – leaves a compliance trail that affects the Russian subsidiary's position in future FTS audits. Where the dispute involved CFC-related arguments, the FTS will flag the group's CFC disclosure record for enhanced scrutiny in subsequent periods.

Post-dispute, in-house counsel should confirm: (i) whether CFC notifications are filed correctly and on time for all subsequent periods; (ii) whether the transfer-pricing documentation policy for intercompany transactions has been reviewed in light of any arguments made during the dispute; and (iii) whether the subsidiary's VAT return preparation process has been updated to reflect lessons from the audit and appeal.

For groups subject to EAEU or CIS cross-border VAT arrangements – both frameworks that interact with the domestic VAT refund mechanism – there is an additional layer of compliance review. The interaction between domestic Russian VAT rules and EAEU treaty provisions is not automatically addressed by the domestic FTS procedure, and foreign-owned groups with supply chains crossing EAEU borders should verify that the refund claim methodology is consistent across both frameworks.

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long does the FTS desk audit take for a VAT refund claim submitted by a foreign-owned Russian subsidiary?

A: The standard desk audit period under Russian VAT procedure runs for two months from the date the VAT return is filed, with the possibility of extension to three months where the FTS identifies grounds for a more detailed review. For foreign-owned groups where CFC-related questions arise, extensions to the full three-month period are common. The refund itself, if approved, is transferred within a further statutory period after the audit closes. In practice, disputed refund claims for groups with CFC dimensions frequently remain unresolved for considerably longer once administrative appeals are factored in. In-house counsel should build this timeline into group cash-flow planning, particularly where the refund amount is material to the subsidiary's working capital position.

Q: What documents does the FTS typically request in a VAT refund audit involving CFC rules under Article 25.13 of the Tax Code?

A: Beyond the standard VAT invoice and contract documentation, the FTS commonly requests: copies of the foreign parent's CFC notification filings; financial statements of the controlling person for the relevant period; intercompany agreements and transfer-pricing documentation covering transactions that generated the input VAT being claimed; bank statements confirming settlement with counterparties; and, where the group structure involves intermediate holding entities, documentation of the ultimate beneficial owner. Where the FTS has already identified the group through automatic exchange-of-information mechanisms, the request may also include questions about the tax residency of the controlling person and the nature of any offshore holding arrangements. Preparing a complete document set before the claim is submitted is the most effective way to limit the scope and duration of the FTS request process.

Q: What happens if the Russian subsidiary fails to respond to an FTS request within the statutory deadline during a VAT refund audit?

A: Failure to respond within the statutory deadline gives the FTS grounds to treat the non-response as a basis for suspending or refusing the refund. In practical terms, a missed deadline in the context of a CFC-related audit is particularly damaging: it can be characterised by the FTS as evidence of non-cooperation, which then colours the entire audit record and makes the administrative appeal significantly harder to sustain. The FTS is also entitled to draw adverse inferences from the absence of documentation that a compliant taxpayer would be expected to hold. If a deadline cannot be met, a formal extension request should be submitted before the deadline expires – this is procedurally available and preserves the taxpayer's good-faith position in any subsequent appeal.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry