Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Tax

Capital amnesty programmes under Russian tax law at the arbitrazh court litigation stage: what in-house counsel need to know

Kristina Kornouhova · February 2026 · 10 min read

Capital amnesty protections survive arbitrazh court proceedings — but only if in-house counsel acts at the right procedural stage. Make an enquiry.

Unlike comparable voluntary disclosure programmes in EU member states, which typically disengage once formal judicial proceedings have commenced, Russian capital amnesty programmes under Russian tax law have historically permitted — and, in a number of documented instances, required — in-house counsel to raise amnesty protections before the arbitrazh court even after an assessment has been issued and appealed. For foreign companies managing Russian subsidiaries or holding structures with Russian-sited assets, understanding when and how those protections survive into the litigation stage is now a core compliance task, not an afterthought. This guide sets out five steps in-house counsel should work through once a Federal Tax Service dispute crosses from the pre-litigation appeal stage into active arbitrazh court proceedings.

What to prepare before proceedings begin

The following items should be assembled before the first arbitrazh court hearing, and ideally before the statement of claim is filed:

These materials are not merely background; they become exhibits in the arbitrazh court file. Assembling them before the statement of claim is lodged avoids later procedural complications.

If your company is approaching arbitrazh proceedings with a capital amnesty declaration on record, make an enquiry now: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 1. Assess whether the amnesty protection still applies at the arbitrazh court stage

The first — and most consequential — question is whether the amnesty protection attached to a particular declaration remains operative once the Federal Tax Service has issued a formal tax assessment and the dispute has entered the arbitrazh court litigation stage. The answer is not automatic.

Russian capital amnesty programmes have been structured around a guarantee of non-use: assets or income declared under the programme cannot be used as the basis for initiating tax liability. However, this guarantee operates subject to conditions. Courts have considered whether the assessment in question relates directly to the declared asset or income, whether the timeline of the audit falls within the protected period, and whether the declarant has maintained the status conditions attached to the programme phase under which the declaration was submitted.

In practice, the Federal Tax Service has occasionally argued before Russian courts that an assessment is based on a different legal ground — unreported income rather than the declared asset, for example — thereby falling outside the amnesty shield. Arbitrazh courts have not uniformly accepted this framing. In the majority of instances reviewed in Siberian and Ural circuit practice, courts have examined the substance of the assessment rather than the characterisation advanced by the tax authority. Counsel should be prepared for that contest and should not assume the protection applies without analysis.

The threshold question for in-house counsel is therefore: does the assessment in dispute relate — directly or by necessary implication — to assets or income covered by the declaration? If the answer is yes, the amnesty argument is available. If the answer is uncertain, the ambiguity itself has procedural value and must be raised early.

Step 2. Map the arbitrazh court process for Russian tax disputes

Russian tax disputes before the arbitrazh courts proceed through a defined sequence that differs materially from the inquisitorial model familiar to civil-law practitioners in continental Europe.

After mandatory pre-litigation appeal to the Federal Tax Service's own appellate division, the taxpayer files a statement of claim before the first-instance arbitrazh court for the region in which the company or, for some structural disputes, the relevant asset is registered. The court conducts substantive review — it is not limited to procedural legality, as some foreign practitioners expect — and can fully examine the merits of the assessment.

The first-instance decision may be appealed to the relevant appellate arbitrazh court (apeliatsia), and thereafter to the cassation court at circuit level. The cassation court reviews questions of law and procedure, not factual findings. For disputes of sufficient legal significance, further review at the level of the Supreme Court's economic panel is available, though not routinely granted.

At each stage, the capital amnesty argument must be expressly maintained. Russian courts do not carry procedural arguments forward automatically from earlier stages. If the amnesty argument is not articulated in the first-instance statement of claim, its admissibility at appellate level may be contested. This is the most frequent procedural error observed in practice.

Step 3. How should the amnesty argument be structured in written submissions?

The amnesty argument at the arbitrazh court stage is most effectively deployed as a standalone legal objection — a discrete ground for dismissal of the claim — rather than as a subsidiary point within a broader factual defence. This framing matters.

When presented as a standalone objection, the court is invited to consider whether the assessment can proceed at all, prior to examining the merits of the underlying tax position. This is procedurally more powerful than inviting the court to weigh the amnesty protection against the substance of the assessment. Russian courts are generally receptive to threshold legal objections that, if upheld, make further examination unnecessary.

The submission should set out: the fact of the declaration and its date; the phase of the programme under which it was submitted; the direct connection between the declared position and the assessment in dispute; and the legal consequence — non-use — that Russian tax legislation attaches to qualifying declarations. Each element should be supported by the documentary exhibits assembled at the preparatory stage.

The tax authority's likely counter-argument — that the assessment rests on a separate ground — should be anticipated and rebutted in the same submission, not left for reply. In practice, allowing that argument to stand uncontested in the first round of submissions gives the court an alternative framing it may find convenient to adopt.

For in-house counsel coordinating this process, the practical priority is ensuring that external Russian litigation counsel and internal tax compliance teams are working from the same chronological record. Discrepancies between the declared position and the company's accounting records, if discovered by the tax authority during proceedings, can significantly undermine the amnesty argument regardless of its formal legal strength.

The risk of forfeiting amnesty protection through a procedural misstep — raising it too late, framing it as secondary, or failing to connect it to the precise assessment ground — is real and, once the first-instance judgment is issued, not easily corrected on appeal.

For in-house counsel who need a Russian litigation team to structure this argument from filing stage: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Step 4. Document the amnesty claim throughout the proceedings

Documentation discipline during arbitrazh court proceedings is not simply a matter of file management — it affects the procedural record that appellate courts will review.

At each stage of the proceedings, all filings, court orders, and hearing transcripts that reference the amnesty argument should be collated and cross-referenced against the core documentary record assembled before filing. Russian arbitrazh courts maintain an electronic case record (available through the kad.arbitr.ru portal), and counsel should monitor entries closely: documents added to the file by the opposing party — including supplementary tax authority memoranda — sometimes introduce characterisations of the declared position that require a response.

Where the court requests additional documentation relating to the declaration, the response must be prepared precisely. Overbroad document production — providing more than the court has requested, particularly where additional documents touch on other declared positions not directly in dispute — can create unnecessary exposure. In-house counsel should instruct Russian litigation counsel to review any production request with this constraint in mind before responding.

If the case spans a period during which the terms of the amnesty programme have been formally amended or extended by subsequent Russian legislation, the submission record should reflect the version of the programme rules applicable at the time of the original declaration. Courts have at times been presented with arguments that later, more restrictive programme conditions apply retrospectively — a position that has generally not found favour in Russian courts, but which requires pre-emptive rebuttal if raised.

Step 5. Manage post-judgment compliance and ongoing disclosure obligations

A successful amnesty argument — resulting in dismissal of the assessment or a materially reduced liability — does not extinguish ongoing compliance obligations under Russian tax law and, where applicable, under currency control and foreign exchange regulations.

Following judgment in the taxpayer's favour, the company should undertake an internal review to confirm that the conditions attached to the relevant programme phase remain satisfied: asset location, ownership structure, and repatriation status, where applicable. If any structural changes occurred between the date of the declaration and the date of judgment, those changes should be assessed for their effect on the continuing validity of the protection. Russian courts have in a small number of instances been asked to revisit amnesty protections where subsequent restructuring altered the factual basis of the original declaration.

Where the matter has EAEU or CIS cross-border dimensions — as is commonly the case for foreign companies operating through holding structures in Kazakhstan, Belarus, or other member states — the post-judgment compliance review should extend to those jurisdictions. The interaction between Russian capital amnesty protections and the regulatory frameworks of other EAEU members is not uniform, and assumptions carried over from the Russian analysis should be verified locally.

Finally, if the litigation has produced a judicial record that touches on the company's broader Russian asset or income position, in-house counsel should consider whether that record has implications for future audit cycles. The Federal Tax Service has access to court records and the amnesty argument, once deployed, becomes part of the company's regulatory history with that authority.

Frequently asked questions

Q: Do capital amnesty protections automatically survive once the dispute reaches the arbitrazh court?

A: Not automatically. The protection must be expressly invoked in the statement of claim or, at the latest, in the first-instance submissions. Russian arbitrazh courts do not carry procedural arguments forward between stages without prompting. The protection remains legally available at the litigation stage, but counsel must connect it explicitly to the assessment being challenged and demonstrate that the declared position and the assessment ground overlap. Where the tax authority argues the assessment rests on a different legal basis, that argument must be rebutted in the same submission.

Q: What documents does the arbitrazh court typically expect to see in support of an amnesty argument?

A: Courts examining an amnesty argument will generally expect the original declaration (or a certified copy), evidence of submission and receipt, documentation establishing the scope of assets or income covered, and a factual chronology connecting those assets or income to the assessment in dispute. Supporting accounting records and intercompany documentation are commonly required where the declared position involves cross-border flows or holding structures. The more precisely the documentation maps the declared position onto the specific assessment ground, the stronger the submission. Courts have shown less patience with generic reference to programme participation without substantive factual support.

Q: Can the amnesty argument still be raised for the first time at the appellate (apeliatsia) stage?

A: In principle, Russian procedural rules permit new arguments to be raised on appeal in limited circumstances, but courts have shown reluctance to admit a substantive amnesty argument that was not raised before the first-instance court. The safer course is always to raise it in the statement of claim. If a first-instance judgment has already been issued without the argument having been made, the prospects of successfully introducing it at appellate level are materially lower, and the analysis should be approached as a case-specific assessment rather than a reliable procedural avenue.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry