The first creditors' meeting has a fixed agenda that determines the structural parameters of the entire insolvency. At the first meeting, creditors vote on: the recommendation regarding the next stage of proceedings (restructuring or liquidation); the selection of the insolvency administrator or the nomination of a candidate; the formation of the creditors' committee; and, in some circumstances, the approval of a restructuring plan submitted by the debtor.
Each of these decisions can have a material effect on the outcome for creditors. The selection of the insolvency administrator is particularly consequential: the administrator determines the pace of asset realisation, the vigour with which transaction challenges are pursued, and the degree to which the administrator cooperates with — or frustrates — individual creditors' investigative requests. A creditor who has no vote at the meeting where the administrator is selected has no input into that decision.
The insolvency administrator, once confirmed, acquires substantial discretion. Creditors who participated in the administrator's selection have, in practice, a stronger relationship with the administrator throughout the proceedings than creditors who were absent from the process.